肌电模式识别中的分类复杂度研究
该研究评估了最近邻可分性、纯度、重复性指数和可分性指数等分类复杂度估计算法,分析其与分类准确率的相关性及生成高性能肌电特征集的能力。结果显示最近邻可分性和可分性指数与分类准确率高度相关(相关系数可达0.98),并能生成高描述性特征集,同时揭示了分类器输入间相关性对准确率的影响及分类器对冗余的敏感性。
要点
- 最近邻可分性与可分性指数与分类准确率高度相关,相关系数可达0.98。
- 分类复杂度估计算法可用于改进特征选择、预测肌电模式识别性能及提示数据采集故障。
- 分类器输入间的相关性影响分类准确率,分类器对冗余敏感。
核心结论
- 最近邻可分性和可分性指数与分类准确率高度相关,相关系数可达0.98,且能生成高描述性特征集。
- 分类复杂度估计算法有助于改进特征选择、预测肌电模式识别性能并提示数据采集故障。
研究设计与样本
- 评估最近邻可分性、纯度、重复性指数和可分性指数等分类复杂度估计算法与分类准确率的相关性及生成高性能肌电特征集的能力。
- 可分性指数使用马氏距离、巴氏距离、海林格距离、KL散度和改进马氏距离进行评估。
- 使用线性判别分析、多层感知机和支持向量机三种分类器计算分类准确率。
主要发现
- 最近邻可分性和可分性指数与分类准确率高度相关,相关系数可达0.98。
- 最近邻可分性和可分性指数能生成高描述性特征集。
- 实验揭示了分类器输入间相关性对分类准确率的影响,并强调分类器对冗余的敏感性。
关键数值与推荐
- 最近邻可分性和可分性指数与分类准确率的相关系数可达0.98。
临床怎么用
- 可利用最近邻可分性和可分性指数等分类复杂度估计算法改进肌电特征选择。
- 分类复杂度估计算法可用于预测肌电模式识别性能。
- 分类复杂度估计算法可提示数据采集故障。
- 相关算法和图形用户界面已在BioPatRec中免费提供。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Limb prosthetics, exoskeletons, and neurorehabilitation devices can be intuitively controlled using myoelectric pattern recognition (MPR) to decode the subject's intended movement. In conventional MPR, descriptive electromyography (EMG) features representing the intended movement are fed into a classification algorithm. The separability of the different movements in the feature space significantly affects the classification complexity. Classification complexity estimating algorithms (CCEAs) were studied in this work in order to improve feature selection, predict MPR performance, and inform on faulty data acquisition. METHODS: CCEAs such as nearest neighbor separability (NNS), purity, repeatability index (RI), and separability index (SI) were evaluated based on their correlation with classification accuracy, as well as on their suitability to produce highly performing EMG feature sets. SI was evaluated using Mahalanobis distance, Bhattacharyya distance, Hellinger distance, Kullback-Leibler divergence, and a modified version of Mahalanobis distance. Three commonly used classifiers in MPR were used to compute classification accuracy (linear discriminant analysis (LDA), multi-layer perceptron (MLP), and support vector machine (SVM)). The algorithms and analytic graphical user interfaces produced in this work are freely available in BioPatRec. RESULTS: NNS and SI were found to be highly correlated with classification accuracy (correlations up to 0.98 for both algorithms) and capable of yielding highly descriptive feature sets. Additionally, the experiments revealed how the level of correlation between the inputs of the classifiers influences classification accuracy, and emphasizes the classifiers' sensitivity to such redundancy. CONCLUSIONS: This study deepens the understanding of the classification complexity in prediction of motor volition based on myoelectric information. It also provides researchers with tools to analyze myoelectric recordings in order to improve classification performance.
引用
- Nilsson N, Håkansson B, Ortiz-Catalan M, et al. Classification complexity in myoelectric pattern recognition. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2017. PMID: 28693533. doi:10.1186/s12984-017-0283-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。