住院卒中康复中目标设定的多中心实践研究
本研究通过电子问卷和多中心目标设定文档分析,描述住院卒中康复中的目标设定实践。五个卒中单元共纳入13名治疗师和49名患者,检查351条记录目标。结果显示目标设定由治疗师主导,仅41%符合SMART标准,48%从未被复审,目标与治疗计划衔接不完整。
要点
- 目标设定由治疗师主导,60%目标由治疗师设定,患者和家属很少直接参与。
- 仅41%的记录目标符合SMART标准,48%的目标从未被复审。
- 目标多聚焦基础移动和日常生活活动,与治疗计划衔接不完整。
核心结论
- 住院卒中康复目标设定由治疗师主导但与多学科团队讨论,患者聚焦移动和日常生活活动目标,进展监测和目标修订常未完成,目标与治疗、行动计划及进展的衔接不完整。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心研究,分两阶段:针对多学科团队的电子问卷和对康复患者目标设定文档的分析。
- 设置于五个住院卒中单元,招募参与目标设定的 staff 和接受卒中康复的患者。
- 共招募13名治疗师和49名患者,检查351条记录目标。
主要发现
- 所有单元均采用治疗师主导的目标设定,60%的目标由治疗师设定。
- 72%的目标以患者为中心,但患者和家属很少直接参与。
- 目标聚焦基础移动(约50%)和日常生活活动(约25%)。
- 仅41%的记录目标符合SMART标准。
- 48%的目标从未被复审,其余目标中24%仅标记为「进行中」而无日期或完成计划。
关键数值与推荐
- 60%的目标由治疗师设定。
- 72%的目标以患者为中心。
- 约50%的目标聚焦基础移动,约25%聚焦日常生活活动。
- 41%的记录目标符合SMART标准。
- 48%的目标从未被复审,24%的其余目标仅标记为「进行中」而无日期或完成计划。
临床怎么用
- 康复团队应促进患者和家属直接参与目标设定,而非仅由治疗师主导。
- 目标设定应遵循SMART标准以提高目标质量。
- 需建立定期复审和修订目标的机制,避免目标仅标记为「进行中」而无后续计划。
- 应加强目标与治疗/行动计划之间的明确衔接,而非仅 vague 建议治疗 modality。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe goal-setting during inpatient stroke rehabilitation. DESIGN: There were two stages: an electronic questionnaire for multidisciplinary teams and an analysis of goal-setting documentation for rehabilitation patients. SETTING: Five inpatient stroke units. PARTICIPANTS: Staff involved in goal-setting and patients undergoing stroke rehabilitation. RESULTS: A total of 13 therapists and 49 patients were recruited, and 351 documented goals were examined. All units used therapist-led goal-setting (60% of goals were set by therapists). In total, 72% of goals were patient-focused but patients and families were rarely directly involved. Goals focussed on basic mobility and activities of daily living (~50% and ~25% of goals, respectively). Only 41% of documented goals met the SMART criteria. Review of progress was limited: 48% of goals were never reviewed and 24% of the remainder were merely marked as 'ongoing' without a date or plan for completion. New goals and actions were often documented without any connection to previous goals. Integration between goals and treatment/action plans was mixed. In two units, goals were unconnected to a treatment or action plan, but for the remainder it was 90%-100%. However, that connection was generally vague and amounted to suggestions of the type of treatment modality that staff might employ. CONCLUSION: Goal-setting during inpatient stroke rehabilitation is therapist-led but discussed with the multidisciplinary team. Therapists mainly identified patient-focussed mobility and activities of daily living goals. Monitoring progress and revising goals were often uncompleted. Links between goals and treatment, action plans and progress were patchy.
引用
- Plant S, Tyson SF. A multicentre study of how goal-setting is practised during inpatient stroke rehabilitation. Clin Rehabil. 2017. PMID: 28714342. doi:10.1177/0269215517719485
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。