非进展性脑损伤后重返驾驶:法国推荐意见
法国SOFMER与Comète France协会基于文献综述制定非进展性脑损伤后重返驾驶的临床路径推荐。共识别1388篇摘要,分析379篇,无文章支持高于「专家意见」的推荐。推荐需先筛查视觉、感觉、运动及认知后遗症,单侧空间忽略者不建议重返驾驶,评估应由多专业人员完成并与患者共享综合结论。
要点
- 重返驾驶前需筛查视觉、感觉、运动及认知后遗症。
- 单侧空间忽略者不建议重返驾驶。
- 后遗症评估流程(临床、认知、道路评估)应由多专业人员完成。
核心结论
- 非进展性脑损伤后重返驾驶需经多专业评估与综合,目前推荐强度仅达专家意见水平。
研究设计与样本
- 按临床实践指南方法制定,识别1388篇摘要,分析379篇,草案经评审组审核并由法国高级卫生局验证。
主要发现
- 无文章支持形成高于「专家意见」的推荐。
- 重返驾驶前需检测视觉、感觉、运动及认知后遗症。
- 单侧空间忽略者不建议重返驾驶。
- 卒中或脑损伤后根据后遗症严重程度提出不同评估策略。
- 后遗症评估流程(临床、认知、道路评估)需多专业合作,结果经多专业综合并与患者及尽可能在场的亲属共享。
关键数值与推荐
- 单侧空间忽略者不建议重返驾驶。
- 后遗症评估流程包括临床、认知及道路评估,需多专业合作。
临床怎么用
- 对非进展性脑损伤患者重返驾驶前应筛查视觉、感觉、运动及认知后遗症。
- 发现单侧空间忽略时不应建议重返驾驶。
- 后遗症评估应由多专业团队完成并形成综合结论与患者共享。
- 无论评估结果如何,均需提供维持最佳移动能力的陪伴支持。
局限性
- 无文章支持形成高于「专家意见」的推荐。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: Return to drive after brain damage is a crucial question either for patients than health professionals. The Société française de medicine physique et de réadaptation (SOFMER) and Comète France association developed recommandations for patient's identification, evaluation and accompaniment as part of their project to resume to drive. The place of rehabilitation process and patient's focus has been also discussed. AIMS: Using a literature review, the aim was to define clinical pathways to determine people who need a fitness to drive evaluation after a non-evolutive brain damage as well as the assessment process. METHOD: Following the method for Clinical practice guidelines, 1388 abstracts were identified, among which 379 were analysed and confronted with the working group's experience. The draft propositions were submitted to a review group before being validated by the High French Health Autority. RESULT: No article enabled the development of recommendations above the "expert opinion". The detection of sensory (visual), sensitive, motor and/or cognitive sequelaes is needed before return to drive. It is not recommended to return to drive in case of unilateral spatial neglect. Different assessment strategies, function of sequeale's gravity, are proposed after stroke or brain injury. In case of sequeale, the assessment process (clinical, cognitive, on road evaluation) has to be pluriprofessional. The results are the subject of a pluriprofessional synthesis, shared with the patient and, if possible, in the presence of a close. An accompaniment to maintain the best mobility of the person is needed, whatever the assessment result.
引用
- D'apolito AC, Leguiet JL, Enjalbert M, et al. Return to drive after non-evolutive brain damage: French recommendations. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2017. PMID: 28533085. doi:10.1016/j.rehab.2017.04.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。