用于上肢康复的交互式可穿戴系统:一项系统综述
加速度计和惯性测量单元(IMU)是最常用技术(占84%),主要用于监测上肢运动和躯干姿势,但仅3项研究开展临床试验(含1项随机临床试验),临床证据有限。
要点
- 加速度计和IMU是上肢康复可穿戴系统最常用技术,占84%的论文。
- 多数系统用于卒中康复(21篇),传感器多附着于躯干、上臂、前臂、腕和手指。
- 仅3篇研究开展临床试验(含1项随机临床试验),临床有效性证据稀缺。
核心结论
- 可穿戴系统主要用于卒中康复中上肢运动和姿势的监测与反馈提供。
- 加速度计和IMU是最常用传感器,多通过临时装置附着于身体以改善上肢康复中的关节活动度和运动表现。
- 嵌入织物或衣物的传感器系统刚刚兴起,临床评估稀缺,需进一步研究提供有效性证据。
研究设计与样本
- 采用立方体分类法,从传感技术、反馈模式和系统测量三个维度对系统进行分类。
主要发现
- 加速度计和IMU占84%的论文,多采用多传感器配置测量上肢运动学和/或躯干姿势。
- 传感器多置于躯干、上臂、前臂、腕和手指,多可附着而非嵌入可穿戴设备或衣物。
- 16项研究应用结果知识(KR)反馈,14项应用表现知识(KP)反馈,15项同时应用两者。
- 16项研究以患者为对象进行可用性测试,仅3项开展临床试验(含1项随机临床试验)。
关键数值与推荐
- 加速度计和IMU使用率占84%的论文。
- 16项研究应用KR反馈,14项应用KP反馈,15项同时应用两者。
- 16项研究进行患者可用性测试,3项开展临床试验(含1项随机临床试验)。
临床怎么用
- 当前可穿戴系统多用于卒中康复中上肢运动和姿势的监测与反馈。
- 加速度计和IMU是主流传感技术,多通过临时装置附着于躯干和上肢。
- 临床有效性证据尚不充分,应用时需结合现有证据谨慎选择。
局限性
- 临床评估稀缺,仅3项临床试验(含1项随机临床试验),有效性证据不足。
- 多数传感器以可附着方式而非嵌入衣物,可穿戴性有待提升。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The development of interactive rehabilitation technologies which rely on wearable-sensing for upper body rehabilitation is attracting increasing research interest. This paper reviews related research with the aim: 1) To inventory and classify interactive wearable systems for movement and posture monitoring during upper body rehabilitation, regarding the sensing technology, system measurements and feedback conditions; 2) To gauge the wearability of the wearable systems; 3) To inventory the availability of clinical evidence supporting the effectiveness of related technologies. METHOD: A systematic literature search was conducted in the following search engines: PubMed, ACM, Scopus and IEEE (January 2010-April 2016). RESULTS: Forty-five papers were included and discussed in a new cuboid taxonomy which consists of 3 dimensions: sensing technology, feedback modalities and system measurements. Wearable sensor systems were developed for persons in: 1) Neuro-rehabilitation: stroke (n = 21), spinal cord injury (n = 1), cerebral palsy (n = 2), Alzheimer (n = 1); 2) Musculoskeletal impairment: ligament rehabilitation (n = 1), arthritis (n = 1), frozen shoulder (n = 1), bones trauma (n = 1); 3) Others: chronic pulmonary obstructive disease (n = 1), chronic pain rehabilitation (n = 1) and other general rehabilitation (n = 14). Accelerometers and inertial measurement units (IMU) are the most frequently used technologies (84% of the papers). They are mostly used in multiple sensor configurations to measure upper limb kinematics and/or trunk posture. Sensors are placed mostly on the trunk, upper arm, the forearm, the wrist, and the finger. Typically sensors are attachable rather than embedded in wearable devices and garments; although studies that embed and integrate sensors are increasing in the last 4 years. 16 studies applied knowledge of result (KR) feedback, 14 studies applied knowledge of performance (KP) feedback and 15 studies applied both in various modalities. 16 studies have conducted their evaluation with patients and reported usability tests, while only three of them conducted clinical trials including one randomized clinical trial. CONCLUSIONS: This review has shown that wearable systems are used mostly for the monitoring and provision of feedback on posture and upper extremity movements in stroke rehabilitation. The results indicated that accelerometers and IMUs are the most frequently used sensors, in most cases attached to the body through ad hoc contraptions for the purpose of improving range of motion and movement performance during upper body rehabilitation. Systems featuring sensors embedded in wearable appliances or garments are only beginning to emerge. Similarly, clinical evaluations are scarce and are further needed to provide evidence on effectiveness and pave the path towards implementation in clinical settings.
引用
- Wang Q, Markopoulos P, Yu B, et al. Interactive wearable systems for upper body rehabilitation: a systematic review. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2017. PMID: 28284228. doi:10.1186/s12984-017-0229-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。