短休息间歇抗阻训练与传统多组抗阻训练联合耐力训练在心血管疾病患者中的随机临床试验
这项随机临床试验比较了短休息间歇抗阻训练(3/7 RT)与传统多组抗阻训练(3×9 RT)联合耐力训练在心血管疾病患者12周监督下心脏康复中的效果。两组VO₂peak、30秒坐立试验和总瘦体重改善相似,但等速肌力在3/7 RT组提升更显著(+23±20 vs. +11±22 N·m;P=0.022)。
要点
- 两种抗阻训练模式在心脏康复中均可行且有效。
- 3/7 RT在等速肌力提升上优于3×9 RT(P=0.022)。
- VO₂peak、坐立表现和瘦体重改善两组无显著差异。
核心结论
- 短休息间歇抗阻训练与传统多组抗阻训练联合耐力训练在心血管疾病患者中均可行且有效。
- 在多项肌力评估中未观察到任一方案的一致优越性,临床选择可考虑患者偏好。
研究设计与样本
- 所有参与者接受12周监督下心脏康复,每周3次耐力训练联合相应抗阻训练。
主要发现
- VO₂peak两组均增加,组间无显著差异(+3.6±3.3 vs. +4.0±4.6 ml/kg/min;P=0.786)。
- 30秒坐立试验重复次数两组均增加(+2±3 vs. +2±3次;P=0.873)。
- 总瘦体重两组均增加(+1.04±1.5 vs. +0.94±1.7 kg;P=0.791)。
- 等速肌力股四头肌力量3/7 RT组提升更显著(+23±20 vs. +11±22 N·m;P=0.022)。
临床怎么用
- 在心脏康复中可选用3/7 RT或3×9 RT联合耐力训练,根据患者偏好选择训练方式。
- 若以提升等速肌力为主要目标,可考虑短休息间歇抗阻训练(3/7 RT)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This randomized clinical trial compared short-rest interval resistance training (3/7 RT) with traditional multiple-set resistance training (3×9 RT) during a 12-week supervised cardiac rehabilitation program in patients with cardiovascular disease. Seventy-one participants were randomized to endurance training combined with either 3/7 RT (n=37) or 3×9 RT (n=34), performed three times per week. Primary outcomes were changes in VO₂peak and quadriceps strength; secondary outcomes included 30-s sit-to-stand performance and total lean mass. VO₂peak increased similarly in both groups (+3.6±3.3 vs. +4.0±4.6 ml/kg/min; P=0.786), as did sit-to-stand performance (+2±3 vs. +2±3 repetitions; P=0.873) and total lean mass (+1.04±1.5 vs. +0.94±1.7 kg; P=0.791). Quadriceps strength increased in both groups across multiple strength assessments but improved more after 3/7 RT than after 3×9 RT (+23±20 vs. +11±22 N·m; P=0.022) for isokinetic strength. These findings suggest that both resistance training modalities are feasible and effective within a cardiac rehabilitation program. As no consistent superiority of either protocol was observed across muscle strength measures, either modality may be considered in clinical practice, with patient preference taken into account when selecting the training approach.
引用
- Gillet A, Lamotte M, Forton K, et al. Effect of Short-Rest Interval versus Traditional Multiple-Set Resistance Training Combined with Endurance Training in Patients with Cardiovascular Disease: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2026. PMID: 42839337. doi:10.1097/PHM.0000000000003170
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。