痉挛是否是一种综合征?痉挛定义与描述的历史视角
本文从历史视角梳理「痉挛」一词长期被用作中枢神经系统损伤后多种阳性运动体征的泛称,导致识别具体损害时产生歧义。作者基于临床经验与Toxnet协作,提出以「痉挛综合征」作为涵盖上运动神经元损伤相关临床表现、病理及非神经外周变化的新伞式术语,并指出常用量表如Tardieu和Ashworth系列存在效度与可靠性不足。
要点
- 「痉挛」泛称涵盖严格意义痉挛、痉挛性肌张力障碍、痉挛性共同收缩和痉挛发作,易混淆具体损害。
- Tardieu量表缺乏效度与可靠性证据,Ashworth量表不测量速度依赖性且不能可靠反映扭矩变化机制。
- 建议用「痉挛综合征」作为伞式术语,涵盖上运动神经元损伤相关表现、病理及非神经外周变化。
核心结论
- 将「痉挛」作为广泛诊断标签会造成歧义,可能掩盖具体损害并影响治疗决策与结局。
- 建议采用「痉挛综合征」作为涵盖上运动神经元损伤相关临床表现与病理的新伞式术语。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为历史视角的论述性文章,基于作者临床经验与Toxnet协作组的合作工作。
主要发现
- 「痉挛」长期被用作中枢神经系统损伤后多种阳性运动体征的泛称,包括严格意义痉挛、痉挛性肌张力障碍、痉挛性共同收缩和痉挛发作。
- 严格意义痉挛按Lance 1980定义,为速度依赖的紧张性牵张反射(肌张力)增高伴腱反射亢进,源于牵张反射高兴奋性。
- Tardieu和改良Tardieu量表缺乏效度与可靠性证据。
- Ashworth和改良Ashworth量表不测量痉挛的速度依赖性,也不能可靠反映扭矩变化的驱动机制。
关键数值与推荐
- 严格意义痉挛定义:速度依赖的紧张性牵张反射(肌张力)增高伴腱反射亢进,源于牵张反射高兴奋性(Lance 1980)。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估应区分严格意义痉挛、痉挛性肌张力障碍、痉挛性共同收缩和痉挛发作等具体损害。
- 使用Tardieu或Ashworth系列量表时需注意其效度、可靠性及对速度依赖性和机制反映的局限。
- 可考虑以「痉挛综合征」框架整合上运动神经元损伤相关表现、非神经外周变化与患者报告症状。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
"Spasticity" has long been used as a generalized term for a constellation of distinct positive motor signs arising from a central nervous system lesion, creating ambiguity in identifying individual impairments. These include spasticity sensu stricto - the velocity-dependent increase in tonic stretch reflexes (muscle tone) with exaggerated tendon jerks, resulting from hyperexcitability of the stretch reflex, as defined by Lance in 1980 - as well as spastic dystonia, spastic co-contraction, and spasms. Drawing on our clinical experience and collaborative work within the Toxnet group ( www.toxnet.net ), we believe that using "spasticity" as a broad diagnostic label creates ambiguity and may obscure the specific impairments contributing to the clinical presentation. Such generalization may compromise treatment decisions and outcomes and is compounded by using manual tools like the Tardieu and modified Tardieu Scales, which lack evidence of validity and reliability, and the Ashworth and modified Ashworth Scales, which do not measure the velocity-dependent nature of spasticity or provide dependable insights into the mechanisms driving the torque changes. To optimize clinical assessment precision and treatment outcomes, we propose "spasticity syndrome" as a new umbrella term encompassing the spectrum of clinical manifestations and underlying pathologies associated with upper motor neuron injury, alongside non-neural peripheral changes and patient-reported symptoms.
引用
- Francisco GE, Deltombe T, Carda S, et al. Is Spasticity a Syndrome? A Historical Perspective on Spasticity Definitions and Descriptions. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2026. PMID: 42424540. doi:10.1097/PHM.0000000000003094
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。