文献速递疼痛康复骨科与运动康复

为期6个月的陆地与水中运动干预对纤维肌痛女性身体成分和体适能的效果:Al-Ándalus准实验研究

Effectiveness of a 6-Month Land-Based and Water-Based Exercise Intervention on Body Composition and Physical Fitness in Women With Fibromyalgia: The Al-Ándalus Quasi-experimental Study.
PubMed 文献 · Arch Phys Med Rehabil · 2026-04-19

该准实验研究纳入250名纤维肌痛女性,比较常规护理、陆地运动和水上运动对体成分和体适能的影响。陆地运动在降低体脂百分比、增加肌肉量、改善上下肢力量、下肢柔韧性、敏捷性和心血管耐力方面优于常规护理,且部分效果在随访期维持。陆地运动在改善下肢力量和心血管耐力方面也优于水上运动。

要点

  • 陆地运动降低体脂百分比(-2%),增加肌肉量(1kg),并改善力量、柔韧性和耐力。
  • 水上运动改善上下肢力量和敏捷性,但随访期仅保留上肢力量增益。
  • 陆地运动在改善下肢力量和心血管耐力方面优于水上运动,且效果更持久。

核心结论

  • 陆地训练比水上运动和常规护理带来更大且更持久的益处。

研究设计与样本

  • 准实验研究,纳入250名纤维肌痛女性,准随机分为常规护理组(n=82)、陆地运动组(n=83)和水上运动组(n=85)。

主要发现

  • 陆地运动 vs 常规护理:体脂百分比平均差-2%(95%CI -3至0),肌肉量增加1kg(0-1),下肢力量改善3次重复(2-4),上肢力量改善4次重复(2-6),下肢柔韧性改善4cm(1-8),敏捷性改善-1s(-1至0),心血管耐力改善43m(19-68)。
  • 水上运动 vs 常规护理:下肢力量改善2次重复(1-3),上肢力量改善3次重复(2-5),敏捷性改善-1s(-1至0)。
  • 随访期:陆地运动维持下肢力量改善2次重复(1-3)、上肢力量改善3次重复(2-5)、下肢柔韧性改善5cm(1-8)、敏捷性改善-1s(-1至0);水上运动仅保留上肢力量增益2次重复(1-4)。
  • 陆地运动 vs 水上运动:下肢力量改善(干预后1次重复,0-2;随访期1次重复,0-2),心血管耐力改善(干预后30米,6-54;随访期37米,12-61),随访期敏捷性改善-1s(-1至0)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 陆地运动相比常规护理,体脂百分比平均差-2%(95%CI -3至0),肌肉量增加1kg(0-1)。
  • 陆地运动相比常规护理,下肢力量改善3次重复(2-4),上肢力量改善4次重复(2-6),下肢柔韧性改善4cm(1-8),敏捷性改善-1s(-1至0),心血管耐力改善43m(19-68)。
  • 水上运动相比常规护理,下肢力量改善2次重复(1-3),上肢力量改善3次重复(2-5),敏捷性改善-1s(-1至0)。
  • 陆地运动相比水上运动,下肢力量改善干预后1次重复(0-2)、随访期1次重复(0-2);心血管耐力改善干预后30米(6-54)、随访期37米(12-61)。

临床怎么用

  • 对于纤维肌痛女性,陆地运动可优先考虑以改善体成分、力量、柔韧性和心血管耐力,且效果可持续至随访期。
  • 水上运动可作为改善上下肢力量和敏捷性的替代选择,但长期维持效果有限。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To compare the effects of land-based, water-based exercise, and usual care on body composition and physical fitness in women with fibromyalgia. DESIGN: Quasi-experimental study. SETTING: University facilities and fibromyalgia associations. PARTICIPANTS: Two hundred fifty women (N=250) with fibromyalgia. INTERVENTIONS: Participants were quasi-randomized to usual care (n=82), land-based (n=83), or water-based groups (n=85). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Body composition (bioimpedance) and physical fitness (Senior Fitness Test and handgrip strength) were assessed at baseline, postintervention (24wk), and 12-week follow-up. RESULTS: Land-based reduced fat mass percentage (mean difference, -2%; 95% CI, -3 to 0), increased muscle mass (1kg; 0-1), and improved lower- (3 repetitions; 2-4) and upper-limb strength (4 repetitions; 2-6), lower-limb flexibility (4cm; 1-8), agility (-1s; -1 to 0) and cardiovascular endurance (43m; 19-68) versus usual care. Water-based improved lower- (2 repetitions; 1-3) and upper-limb strength (3 repetitions; 2-5) and agility (-1s; -1 to 0) compared with usual care. At follow-up, land-based maintained improvements in lower-limb (2 repetitions; 1-3) and upper-limb strength (3 repetitions; 2-5), lower-limb flexibility (5cm; 1-8), and agility (-1s; -1 to 0) versus usual care. Water-based retained only upper-limb strength gains (2 repetitions; 1-4). Compared with water-based, land-based yields greater improvements in lower-limb strength (postintervention: 1 repetition; 0-2; follow-up: 1 repetition; 0-2) and cardiovascular endurance (postintervention: 30 meters, 6-54; follow-up: 37 meters, 12-61). Agility was also higher at follow-up (-1s, -1 to 0). CONCLUSIONS: Land-based training provided greater and more lasting benefits than water-based exercise and usual care.

来源:Arch Phys Med Rehabil,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bañuelos-Terés LE, Álvarez-Gallardo IC, Gavilán-Carrera B, et al. Effectiveness of a 6-Month Land-Based and Water-Based Exercise Intervention on Body Composition and Physical Fitness in Women With Fibromyalgia: The Al-Ándalus Quasi-experimental Study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2026. PMID: 42013931. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2026.04.015

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。