核心实践原则:确定脊髓损伤临床与研究中坐位躯干控制评估驱动因素的混合方法研究
该研究采用解释性序列混合方法,调查美国脊髓损伤康复领域临床医生与临床研究者对坐位躯干控制评估的使用现状及影响因素。调查显示67名受访者中72%使用坐位躯干控制评估,最常用Berg平衡量表;质性分析识别出证据有限、缺乏标准化指南、资金与保险限制等机会层面障碍,以及从业者知识与技能等能力层面促进因素。结论认为躯干控制评估在脊髓损伤康复中被视为必要,但系统性与证据性挑战限制其整合。
要点
- 调查中72%的67名受访者使用坐位躯干控制评估,最常用Berg平衡量表。
- 质性结果强调脊髓损伤坐位功能测试与观察是坐位躯干控制的关键评估。
- 障碍主要涉及机会层面:证据有限、缺乏标准化指南、资金与保险限制。
核心结论
- 在美国医疗背景下,脊髓损伤康复中躯干控制评估被认为必要,但系统性与证据性挑战限制其整合。
- 研究结果强调需要共同制定指南并进一步研究,以证明评估在监测进展、跌倒风险和活动独立性方面的稳健性。
研究设计与样本
- 解释性序列混合方法设计,先进行调查,随后通过焦点小组和访谈三角验证调查结果。
- 调查对象为67名美国脊髓损伤康复经验丰富的临床医生和临床研究者;焦点小组和访谈共66人。
- 设置于美国领先的脊髓损伤机构。
主要发现
- 调查显示67名受访者中72%使用坐位躯干控制评估,最常用Berg平衡量表。
- 质性发现强调脊髓损伤坐位功能测试和观察是坐位躯干控制的关键评估。
- 基于理论领域框架和能力-机会-动机行为改变模型分析,识别出机会相关障碍:证据有限、缺乏标准化指南、资金限制和保险限制。
- 能力相关促进因素为从业者知识和实践技能;动机相关驱动因素为评估的临床相关性和变化敏感性。
临床怎么用
- 临床中应关注坐位躯干控制评估的使用,但需注意证据有限和缺乏标准化指南的现状。
- 可考虑将脊髓损伤坐位功能测试和观察作为坐位躯干控制评估的组成部分。
- 需关注资金和保险限制对评估实施的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To examine current practices in assessing seated trunk control (STC) after spinal cord injury (SCI), a key factor in rehabilitation outcomes and independence. Enablers and barriers to uptake of assessment tools in practice were identified using the Theoretical Domains Framework and mapped to the Capability-Opportunity-Motivation for Behavior Change model. DESIGN: Explanatory sequential mixed methods design using a survey of assessment tools used, followed by focus groups and interviews to triangulate survey responses, understand factors driving uptake, and identify ideal assessment characteristics. SETTING: Leading SCI institutions in the United States. PARTICIPANTS: US-based clinicians and clinical researchers experienced in SCI rehabilitation. (Survey: n= 67; Focus Groups and Interviews: n= 66) INTERVENTIONS: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Survey of commonly used assessment tools. RESULTS: The survey showed that 72% of 67 respondents used STC assessments, most frequently the Berg Balance Scale, whereas qualitative findings highlighted the Function in Sitting Test for SCI and observation as key assessments of STC. Analysis using the Theoretical Domains Framework and Capability-Opportunity-Motivation for Behavior Change identified barriers relating to Opportunity to use STC assessments: including limited evidence, absence of standardized guidelines, funding constraints, and insurance limitations. Capability-related facilitators to the use of assessments were practitioner knowledge and practical skills, whereas Motivation-related drivers were clinical relevance and sensitivity to change of assessments. CONCLUSIONS: In SCI rehabilitation in the US health care context, trunk control assessment is considered essential, although systemic and evidentiary challenges limit its integration. These findings underscore the need for codeveloped guidelines and further research to demonstrate the robustness of assessments in monitoring progress, fall risk, and activity independence.
引用
- Palermo AE, Gorgon E, Nicholson R, et al. Core Practice Principles: A Mixed Methods Approach to Determine What Drives the Use of Seated Trunk Control Assessments in Spinal Cord Injury Clinical and Research Practice. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2026. PMID: 41935598. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2026.03.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。