不同动作观察范式的大脑反应及跨范式解码可迁移性评估
本研究基于降帧法设计右手任务驱动、右手非任务驱动和左手任务驱动三种动作观察范式,采集19名参与者的脑电数据,分析不同范式诱发的SSMVEP与ERD,并评估跨范式解码的可迁移性。结果显示范式内容影响SSMVEP幅值和ERD强度,镜像刺激的脑电数据可直接用于跨范式训练提高识别准确率,而观察范式的数据需进一步开发校准方法。
要点
- 三种动作观察范式均诱发了枕区SSMVEP和感觉运动区ERD。
- 右手任务驱动范式诱发的ERD强于其他两种范式。
- 镜像刺激脑电数据可直接用于跨范式训练提高识别准确率。
核心结论
- 动作观察范式的内容影响诱发的SSMVEP幅值和ERD强度。
- 镜像刺激诱发的脑电数据可直接用于跨范式训练以提高识别准确率。
- 观察任务驱动或非任务驱动范式的数据需进一步开发校准方法才能有效用于跨范式解码。
研究设计与样本
- 基于降帧法设计三种动作观察范式:右手任务驱动(RHTD)、右手非任务驱动(RHNTD)和左手任务驱动(LHTD),每种含四个动作。
- 采集19名参与者在视觉反馈和软体机器人手套反馈条件下的脑电数据。
- 采用任务判别成分分析(TDCA)进行在线目标检测,并开发四种训练方案构建空间滤波器以评估跨范式解码可迁移性。
主要发现
- 三种范式均在枕区诱发稳态运动视觉诱发电位(SSMVEP),在感觉运动区诱发事件相关去同步(ERD)。
- RHTD范式诱发的ERD强于RHNTD和LHTD范式。
- RHNTD范式下SSMVEP识别准确率(85.20%)显著高于RHTD(72.37%)和LHTD(77.50%)。
- 结合镜像刺激脑电与目标会话数据后,识别准确率分别提升至77.50%(RHTD)和80%(LHTD)。
- 直接使用观察范式的脑电数据(无论是否任务驱动)进行训练或与目标会话数据结合时,识别准确率下降。
关键数值与推荐
- RHNTD范式下SSMVEP识别准确率为85.20%,显著高于RHTD的72.37%和LHTD的77.50%。
- 结合镜像刺激脑电与目标会话数据后,RHTD识别准确率提升至77.50%,LHTD提升至80%。
临床怎么用
- 在基于动作观察的脑机接口康复训练中,可优先考虑使用镜像刺激的脑电数据进行跨范式训练以提高解码准确率。
- 对于任务驱动或非任务驱动的动作观察范式,直接跨范式迁移效果不佳,需开发校准方法后再应用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Action observation-based brain-computer interface (AO-BCI) is a novel technology for stroke rehabilitation. Since various AO paradigms are employed in the rehabilitation of different limb movements, a limited training dataset can compromise recognition accuracy. Thus, this study aimed to analyze the brain responses to various AO paradigms systematically and assess the BCI recognition performance across AO paradigms for the first time. METHODS: On the basis of a frame rate reduction method, three AO paradigms, each containing four actions, were designed: the right-hand task-driven (RHTD) paradigm, the right-hand non-task-driven (RHNTD) paradigm, and the left-hand task-driven (LHTD) paradigm. EEG data were collected from 19 participants under the visual feedback condition and the soft robotic glove feedback condition. Task discriminative component analysis (TDCA) was utilized to perform online target detection. EEG responses were analyzed. Moreover, four training schemes, including target session (TS) data, source session data, a combination and transfer with least squares transformation, were developed to construct spatial filters in TDCA to assess the transferability of cross-paradigm decoding in AO-BCI. RESULTS: The three designed AO paradigms elicited steady state motion visual evoke potentials (SSMVEP) in the occipital cortex and induced event-related desynchronization (ERD) in the sensorimotor cortex. The RHTD paradigm induced stronger ERD than the other two paradigms. In addition to EEG responses, the recognition accuracy of the SSMVEP under the RHNTD paradigm (85.20%) was significantly greater than that under the RHTD paradigm (72.37%) and the LHTD paradigm (77.50%). Furthermore, when combing EEG from the mirrored stimulus and TS data, the recognition accuracy increased to 77.50% (RHTD) and 80% (LHTD) respectively. However, when EEG data from observing the AO paradigm, whether task-driven or not, were directly used for training or combed with TS data, the recognition accuracy decreased. CONCLUSION: This study revealed that the content of AO paradigms affects the amplitude of the evoked SSMVEP and ERD. Furthermore, EEG data elicited by the mirrored stimulus can be directly utilized in cross-paradigm training to increase recognition accuracy, whereas data from observing paradigms involving task-driven or not require further development of calibration methods to be effectively applied in cross-paradigm decoding.
引用
- Hu G, Tang H, Zeng F, et al. Brain responses to different action observation paradigms and assessing transferable cross-paradigm decoding. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2026. PMID: 41832543. doi:10.1186/s12984-026-01946-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。