主动辅助机器人疗法变体:虚拟辅助与本体感觉训练在卒中后手指运动训练中的可行性与动机评估
该研究将46名慢性卒中患者随机分配至标准机器人疗法、虚拟辅助或本体感觉训练三组,使用FINGER机器人进行一周三次训练,自适应算法将成功率调节至约80%。三种模式均实现约80%的成功率,但虚拟辅助组动机显著降低,本体感觉训练对本体感觉受损者仍有吸引力但需更多辅助。
要点
- 慢性卒中患者使用三种机器人训练模式均能达到约80%的游戏成功率。
- 虚拟辅助因缺乏物理辅助导致感知能力下降,动机显著降低。
- 本体感觉训练对本体感觉受损者仍有动机,但需更高水平辅助。
核心结论
- 虚拟辅助和本体感觉训练两种新模式对慢性卒中患者可行,均能实现高游戏成功率和训练动机。
- 物理辅助在提升训练动机方面优于虚拟辅助。
- 本体感觉训练虽需高辅助水平,但对本体感觉差者仍有激励作用。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,46名慢性卒中患者随机分为标准、虚拟辅助和本体感觉训练三组。
- 使用FINGER机器人进行一周三次训练,自适应算法将成功率调节至约80%。
- 训练前评估基线本体感觉和运动功能,使用内在动机量表评估训练动机。
主要发现
- 运动与本体感觉能力差异较大的参与者在三种模式下均达到约80%成功率。
- 虚拟辅助组因未提供物理辅助导致感知能力下降,动机显著降低。
- 本体感觉受损者认为本体感觉训练有吸引力,但挑战更大且需要更高水平辅助。
关键数值与推荐
- 自适应算法将游戏成功率调节至约80%。
- 使用内在动机量表评估训练动机。
临床怎么用
- 对于慢性卒中患者,虚拟辅助和本体感觉训练可作为机器人疗法的可行变体。
- 若目标是提升训练动机,物理辅助可能优于虚拟辅助。
- 本体感觉训练可用于本体感觉受损者,但需准备更高水平的辅助。
局限性
- 研究为试点可行性试验,样本量有限(N=46)。
- 训练仅持续一周三次,长期效果未知。
- 未报告组间基线特征比较及具体统计检验值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Standard robotic therapy for upper extremity stroke rehabilitation provides physical assistance during video game-based training. While effective, it requires complex equipment, focuses on visuo-motor control, and yields variable results—raising the question: can more pragmatic or targeted movement training strategies be developed? To explore this, we pilot tested two novel robotic therapy modes. In the Virtual Assistance mode, game parameters are modulated to promote task completion without physical assistance – potentially useful when only sensors are available, although its acceptability for people with more severe motor impairment is unclear. In the Proprioceptive Training mode, participants play video games through a combination of visual and haptic cues. This approach aims to retrain proprioception but may also be too challenging for individuals with proprioceptive impairment to find it motivating. This study tested the feasibility of both variants across a range of motor and proprioceptive impairments, comparing them to training with Standard robotic therapy. METHODS: Chronic stroke participants (N = 46) were randomized to receive Standard, Virtual, or Proprioceptive Training. Participants used the FINGER robot to train in three sessions across one week, during which an adaptive algorithm titrated success to ~ 80%. Baseline proprioceptive and motor function were assessed prior to training, and motivation for training was assessed using the Intrinsic Motivation Inventory. Feasibility was evaluated by levels of gameplay success and motivation for training. RESULTS: Participants of widely varying motor and proprioceptive ability achieved ~ 80% success for all three modes. However, Virtual Assistance resulted in significantly diminished motivation, due to lower perceived competence when participants were not provided with physical assistance. Participants with impaired proprioception rated Proprioceptive Training engaging, although it was more challenging for them and they required an increased level of assistance. CONCLUSION: Both training paradigms were feasible for use with chronic stroke survivors and were able to achieve high gameplay success and motivation for training. However, physical assistance appeared to have an advantage over Virtual Assistance in raising training motivation. Proprioceptive Training required high levels of assistance, but was motivating even for people with poor proprioception.
引用
- Farrens AJ, Reinsdorf D, Garcia-Fernandez L, et al. Variants of active assist robotic therapy: feasibility of virtual assistance and proprioceptive training as gauged by their effects on success and motivation during finger movement training after stroke. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2025. PMID: 40682190. doi:10.1186/s12984-025-01667-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。