并发声化生物反馈在平衡与步态训练中的应用综述
本文综述了49篇关于声化生物反馈用于平衡与步态训练的研究,其中足部原地平衡任务20篇、步行与跑步等步态任务29篇。除2项研究外,其余研究均报告至少一项在生物力学、临床或心理社会指标上的统计学显著正向效应,仅7项研究报告负面效应。作者建议未来研究应推动该技术向神经康复领域转化,并明确报告声音设计与实验设计细节。
要点
- 声化生物反馈通过特定非言语声音传递生物数据,可近实时提供同步的增强生物力学反馈。
- 49篇研究中除2项外均报告至少一项统计学显著正向效应,仅7项报告负面效应,其中5项同时报告正向效应。
- 未来需设计可转化至神经康复领域的方案,并分享声音设计与实验设计细节以促进互相学习。
核心结论
- 声化生物反馈在平衡与步态训练中显示出积极影响,现有成功证据支持其未来可能产生更有意义的正向效应,可帮助具有不同平衡与移动挑战及目标的人群。
研究设计与样本
- 综述纳入49篇论文,均基于实验研究与统计分析评估声化生物反馈辅助运动训练的效果;其中足部原地平衡任务20篇,步行和跑步等步态任务29篇。
主要发现
- 49篇研究中除2项外均报告至少一项生物力学、临床或心理社会指标的统计学显著正向效应。
- 仅7篇研究报告某一生物力学、临床或心理社会指标存在负面效应,其中5篇同时报告至少一项其他正向效应。
- 综述汇总了声音设计选择、实验设计特征与运动训练结果,并指出知识空白与未来方向。
临床怎么用
- 声化生物反馈可用于足部原地平衡任务及步行、跑步等步态任务的运动训练,并可能借助音乐动机性、音乐干预的神经可塑性益处及听觉-运动耦合促进运动(再)学习。
- 声化生物反馈不强制严格等时节律,可跟随运动控制系统输出驱动的节律,可能提供与节律性听觉刺激相似或额外的益处。
- 未来研究应策略性选择对照组与评估任务,以判断某一任务训练的改善能否迁移至其他相关运动任务。
局限性
- 仅7篇研究报告负面效应,其中5篇同时报告其他正向效应,负面效应的报告与汇总有限。
- 未来需分享声音设计过程与实验设计细节,当前研究间可学习性受限。
- 需发展可转化至神经康复领域的声音设计与实验设计。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Sonified biofeedback is a subtype of auditory biofeedback that conveys biological data through specific non-verbal sounds. It can be designed to provide augmented biomechanical feedback in near-real-time when provided as "concurrent" biofeedback. As a practice that developed spanning across engineering and the arts, sonified biofeedback can extend beyond simple tones and beeps, towards more fully incorporating music in movement training. Sonified biofeedback may leverage the motivational aspects of music in movement training, the neuroplasticity benefits demonstrated from participation in music-based interventions, and neurological auditory-motor coupling, all while providing task-relevant cues to facilitate motor (re)learning. Sonified biofeedback may also provide similar benefits as rhythmic cueing (e.g., rhythmic auditory stimulation), or added benefits because sonified biofeedback does not impose a strict isochronous rhythm when it follows rhythms that are driven by outputs of the motor control system. In this review paper, the unique opportunity presented by concurrent sonified biofeedback as a movement training tool for balance and gait is introduced and discussed. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION: This review paper brings together prior research from clinical, engineering, and artistic design sources using sonified biofeedback in balance and gait training across diverse end-users to highlight trends, reveal gaps in knowledge, and provide perspective for future work in the area. The goal was to review progress and critically assess research using sonified biofeedback during movement training for postural control or gait. 49 papers were selected based on their experimental investigation and statistical analyses of the effects of using sonified biofeedback to assist in movement training for feet-in-place balance tasks (20 papers) or gait tasks such as walking and running (29 papers). The sound design choices, experimental design features, and movement training results are summarized and reviewed. All but two studies reported at least one statistically significant positive effect of training with sonified biofeedback in biomechanical, clinical, or psychosocial measures. Conversely, only seven studies shared any negative effect on one biomechanical, clinical, or psychosocial measure (with five of these studies also reporting at least one other positive effect). After describing these encouraging findings, this review closes by sharing perspectives about future directions for designing and using sonified biofeedback in balance and gait training, and opportunities for more cohesive growth in this practice. One such suggestion is to pursue sonified designs and experimental designs that can translate to the neurorehabilitation field. This includes strategically selecting control groups and evaluation tasks to understand if improvements from training with one task transfer to additional relevant movement tasks. Additionally, it is important that future publications share details about the design processes and sound designs so researchers can more readily learn from one another. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, this review shares the positive impact of using sonified biofeedback in balance and gait training. This review highlights the evidence of existing successes and potential for even more impactful future positive effects from using sonified biofeedback to help diverse populations with a spectrum of balance and mobility challenges and goals.
引用
- Zaferiou A, Hirsch Z, Bacani T, et al. A review of concurrent sonified biofeedback in balance and gait training. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2025. PMID: 40011952. doi:10.1186/s12984-025-01565-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。