重复经颅磁刺激策略治疗卒中后吞咽障碍:系统综述与网络Meta分析
高频/同侧半球、高频/双侧半球、高频/同侧小脑、高频/双侧小脑及高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球rTMS均显著改善吞咽功能;急性期高频/同侧半球有效,亚急性期高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球疗效最佳,慢性期rTMS未能改善吞咽功能。
要点
- 多数rTMS方案可改善卒中后吞咽障碍,高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球在亚急性期疗效最佳。
- 急性期高频/同侧半球rTMS有阳性效果,慢性期rTMS未见改善吞咽功能。
- 高频/双侧半球rTMS的SMD为-2.59,高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球为-2.72。
核心结论
- 多数rTMS方案(高频/同侧半球、高频/双侧半球、高频/同侧小脑、高频/双侧小脑、高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球)可能改善卒中后吞咽障碍患者的吞咽功能。
- 高频/同侧半球rTMS在急性期有阳性效果,高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球方案在亚急性期疗效似乎最佳,但rTMS在慢性期未能改善吞咽功能。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索PubMed、Embase和Cochrane数据库自建库至2024年8月30日的随机对照试验(RCT)。
- 采用网络Meta分析合并直接与间接证据,效应量为标准均数差(SMD)及95%可信区间(CrI)。
主要发现
- 与对照相比,高频/同侧半球rTMS显著改善吞咽功能(SMD -0.94;95%CrI -1.51至-0.44)。
- 高频/双侧半球rTMS显著改善吞咽功能(SMD -2.59;95%CrI -3.50至-1.72)。
- 高频/同侧小脑rTMS显著改善吞咽功能(SMD -0.79;95%CrI -1.55至-0.10)。
- 高频/双侧小脑rTMS显著改善吞咽功能(SMD -1.02;95%CrI -1.83至-0.29)。
- 高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球rTMS显著改善吞咽功能(SMD -2.72;95%CrI -4.12至-1.41)。
关键数值与推荐
- 急性期卒中患者,高频/同侧半球rTMS有阳性效果(SMD -1.36;95%CrI -2.86至-0.02)。
- 亚急性期卒中患者,高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球rTMS疗效最佳(SMD -2.68;95%CrI -4.26至-1.26)。
- 慢性期卒中患者,rTMS未能改善吞咽功能。
临床怎么用
- 对于卒中后吞咽障碍患者,可考虑使用高频/同侧半球、高频/双侧半球、高频/同侧小脑、高频/双侧小脑或高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球rTMS方案。
- 急性期患者可优先考虑高频/同侧半球rTMS,亚急性期患者可优先考虑高频/同侧半球+低频/对侧半球rTMS。
- 慢性期患者使用rTMS改善吞咽功能的证据不支持,需谨慎选择。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) is a promising approach in improving swallowing function after stroke. However, comparative efficacy of different rTMS protocols for poststroke dysphagia (PSD) remains unclear. DATA SOURCES: PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane database were systematically searched for eligible random controlled trials (RCTs) from inception to August 30, 2024. STUDY SELECTION: RCTs comparing rTMS with control or head-to-head comparisons of 2 rTMS protocols in patients with PSD. DATA EXTRACTION: Data were extracted by 2 independent reviewers. A network meta-analysis combining direct and indirect evidence was conducted to assess the pooled findings of RCTs with standard mean difference (SMD) with 95% credible interval (CrI). DATA SYNTHESIS: Eighteen RCTs involving 760 participants (mean age of 62.4 [range 49.7-74.7] years; 45.7% women) were included. Pooled data showed that high frequency (HF)/ipsilesional hemisphere (ipsi-hemi) (SMD, -0.94; 95% CrI, -1.51 to -0.44), HF/bilateral hemisphere (bi-hemi) (SMD, -2.59; 95% CrI, -3.50 to -1.72), HF/ipsilesional cerebellar (ipsi-CRB) (SMD, -0.79; 95% CrI, -1.55 to -0.10), HF/bilateral cerebellar (bi-CRB) (SMD, -1.02; 95% CrI, -1.83 to -0.29), and HF/ipsi-hemi + low frequency (LF)/contralesional hemisphere (contra-hemi) (SMD, -2.72; 95% CrI, -4.12 to -1.41) rTMS all significantly improved swallowing function compared with control. For patients with acute stroke, HF/ipsi-hemi rTMS had a positive effect (SMD, -1.36; 95% CrI, -2.86 to -0.02); in subacute stage, HF/ipsi-hemi + LF/contra-hemi rTMS showed the best efficacy (SMD, -2.68; 95% CrI, -4.26 to -1.26). However, rTMS failed to improve swallowing function in chronic stage. CONCLUSIONS: This network meta-analysis showed that most of the rTMS protocols (HF/ipsi-hemi, HF/bi-hemi, HF/ipsi-CRB, HF/bi-CRB, and HF/ipsi-hemi + LF/contra-hemi) may improve swallowing function in patients with PSD. The HF/ipsi-hemi rTMS had a positive effect in acute stage and the HF/ipsi-hemi + LF/contra-hemi protocol seemed to have the best efficacy when applied in subacute stroke.
引用
- Wu X, Zhang B, Ambler G, et al. Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Strategies for Poststroke Dysphagia: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2024. PMID: 39743164. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2024.12.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。