卒中后上肢康复随机对照试验结局指标的系统综述:中低收入与高收入国家的差异
该系统综述纳入1960年至2021年4月五个数据库中1276项卒中后上肢运动康复随机对照试验,其中298项在中低收入国家、978项在高收入国家开展。中低收入国家更多采用中枢神经系统结构功能、肌张力和关节活动度及一般日常生活活动指标,高收入国家更多采用肌力、运动特异性活动、灵巧性和参与指标。两组结局指标选择存在显著差异,可能反映资源、专业能力和时间限制的影响。
要点
- 中低收入国家卒中上肢康复试验更常用Fugl-Meyer评估、改良Ashworth量表和Barthel指数。
- 高收入国家试验更常用Motricity指数、Action Research Arm Test、Wolf运动功能测试和Box and Block测试。
- 结局指标选择的差异可能反映资源、基础设施和专业能力对可行性的影响。
核心结论
- 中低收入国家与高收入国家研究者评估卒中后上肢康复干预时选择的结局指标存在显著差异。
- 这种差异提示资源、专业能力和时间限制可能影响不同国家随机对照试验的结局指标选择。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索Embase、PubMed、CINAHL、Scopus和Web of Science五个数据库,检索时间为1960年至2021年4月1日。
- 纳入标准为英文随机对照试验或交叉设计随机对照试验、至少50%参与者为缺血性或出血性卒中、年龄≥18岁、以偏瘫上肢干预为主要研究目的。
- 共筛查5408条记录,最终纳入1276项随机对照试验,其中298项在中低收入国家开展、978项在高收入国家开展。
- 由两名独立研究者进行标题摘要筛查、全文审阅和数据提取,并使用Physiotherapy Evidence Database量表评估研究质量。
- 数据分析使用SPSS V29.0。
主要发现
- 中低收入国家更高比例的随机对照试验采用中枢神经系统结构功能结局指标(如Fugl-Meyer评估)。
- 中低收入国家更高比例的随机对照试验采用肌张力和关节活动度结局指标(如改良Ashworth量表)。
- 中低收入国家更高比例的随机对照试验采用一般日常生活活动结局指标(如Barthel指数)。
- 高收入国家更高比例的随机对照试验采用评估肌力的结构功能结局指标(如Motricity指数)。
- 高收入国家更高比例的随机对照试验采用运动特异性活动结局指标(如Action Research Arm Test和Wolf Motor Function Test)、灵巧性结局指标(如Box and Block Test)及参与结局指标(如Stroke Impact Scale)。
关键数值与推荐
- 中低收入国家随机对照试验更常用Fugl-Meyer评估(中枢神经系统结构功能)、改良Ashworth量表(肌张力与关节活动度)和Barthel指数(一般日常生活活动)。
- 高收入国家随机对照试验更常用Motricity指数(肌力)、Action Research Arm Test和Wolf Motor Function Test(运动特异性活动)、Box and Block Test(灵巧性)及Stroke Impact Scale(参与)。
临床怎么用
- 康复医学科智能体医生在解读卒中上肢康复试验结局时,应结合研究所在国家背景判断指标选择偏倚。
- 在中低收入国家开展或应用相关证据时,需关注资源、基础设施和专业能力对结局指标可行性的影响。
- 比较不同国家试验结果时,应考虑结局指标选择差异可能影响结论的外推性。
局限性
- 仅纳入英文发表的随机对照试验,可能遗漏非英文研究。
- 研究未报告资源、基础设施和专业能力的具体数据,相关解释为作者推测。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To systematically review randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of poststroke upper extremity (UE) motor rehabilitation interventions to identify the outcome measures used in studies in low-to-middle-income countries (LMICs) and high-income countries (HICs) and describe the differences in the context of the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health. DATA SOURCES: Five databases "Embase, PubMed, CINAHL, Scopus, and Web of Science" were searched from 1960 to April 1, 2021. STUDY SELECTION: Studies were included if they were (1) RCTs or RCT crossovers in English; (2) with ≥50% participants affected by ischemic/hemorrhagic stroke; (3) participants aged ≥18 years; and (4) used an intervention for the hemiparetic UE as the primary objective of the study. DATA EXTRACTION: Title and abstract screening and full-text studies were reviewed, and data for included studies were extracted by two independent investigators. The study quality was assessed using the Physiotherapy Evidence Database scale. Data analyses were performed using SPSS (V29.0). DATA SYNTHESIS: Of 5408 records, 1276 RCTs were eligible, 298 RCTs were conducted in LMICs and 978 in HICs. A higher percentage of RCTs in LMICs employed body structure and function outcome measures for central nervous system (eg, Fugl-Meyer Assessment) and tone and range of motion (eg, modified Ashworth Scale) as well as activity outcome measures for general activities of daily living (eg, Barthel Index). In HICs, a higher percentage of RCTs used body structure and function outcome measures assessing strength (eg, Motricity Index), activity outcome measures examining motor specific activity (eg, Action Research Arm Test and Wolf Motor Function Test) and dexterity (eg, Box and Block Test), as well as participation outcome measures (eg, Stroke Impact Scale). CONCLUSIONS: There were significant differences in the outcome measures chosen for assessing poststroke UE rehabilitation interventions by researchers in LMICs and HICs. This suggests that there might be potential resource and expertise as well as timing constraints that influences the choice of outcome measures in RCTs between HICs and LMICs and highlights the need for investigating the availability of resources, infrastructure, and expertise and their effect on the feasibility and practicality of employing different outcome measures in different countries.
引用
- Mehrabi S, Fleet JL, Safaei-Qomi MR, et al. Systematic Review of Upper Extremity Outcome Measures Assessed in Randomized Controlled Trials of Poststroke Upper Extremity Rehabilitation in Low-to-Middle-Income and High-Income Countries. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2024. PMID: 39547309. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2024.08.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。