指南与共识神经康复

Fugl-Meyer评估方案变异解读:名义组共识过程的结果与建议

Interpreting Variations in Fugl-Meyer Assessment Protocols: Results and Recommendations From a Nominal Group Consensus Process.
指南 / 共识 · Arch Phys Med Rehabil · 2024-10-24

本研究通过名义组共识技术,识别6种上肢Fugl-Meyer评估(FMA-UE)方案在实施与评分指导上的变异,并达成最优实施程序的共识。10名卒中康复专家参与3阶段共识过程,以80%或以上同意率为共识标准,最终对10条一般实施指导中的7条达成共识,并给出「最佳实践」建议。案例显示不同方案间FMA-UE评分差异可达21分,提示方案变异可能影响研究结果的解读与转化。

要点

  • 6种FMA-UE方案在一般实施指导上存在变异,可影响多个测试项的评分。
  • 10条一般实施指导中7条达成共识(≥80%同意),形成最佳实践建议。
  • 案例中不同方案FMA-UE评分差异可达21分,提示方案变异影响显著。

核心结论

  • FMA-UE实施方案的变异可导致机构间研究结果解读与转化出现差异,并限制标准化评估在循证实践中的价值与采用。
  • 名义组共识结果为制定更广泛传播和审查的FMA-UE统一建议迈出第一步。

研究设计与样本

  • 名义组共识技术,包括对方案内容的迭代独立审查、匿名投票和小组共识会议。
  • 10名卒中康复及FMA-UE实施专家组成跨专业共识组,通过Zoom参加虚拟会议。
  • 共识标准为事先设定的80%或以上同意率。

主要发现

  • 10条一般实施指导中7条达成共识。
  • 共识组建议总结了面向研究者和临床医生的「最佳实践」一般指导。
  • 案例中发现FMA-UE最高分与最低分之间差异可达21分。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共识判定阈值:同意率80%或以上。
  • 共识达成条目数:10条一般实施指导中的7条。
  • 案例中FMA-UE评分最大差异:21分。

临床怎么用

  • 研究者和临床医生可参考共识组总结的「最佳实践」一般指导实施FMA-UE。
  • 在卒中康复研究中应关注FMA-UE方案变异对评分解读和跨机构比较的影响。

局限性

  • 共识组仅10名专家,样本量有限。
  • 10条一般实施指导中仅7条达成共识,部分条目未形成共识。
  • 结果为制定统一FMA-UE建议的第一步,尚需更广泛传播和审查。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To identify variations among administration and scoring instructions of 6 upper extremity Fugl-Meyer Assessment (FMA-UE) protocols and to achieve consensus regarding optimal administration procedures. DESIGN: Nominal group consensus technique comprised of iterative independent reviews of protocol content, anonymous voting, and group consensus meetings. SETTING: Clinicians working in clinical practice and research settings participated in virtual meetings via Zoom. PARTICIPANTS: Ten experts in stroke rehabilitation and administration of the FMA-UE contributed to the interprofessional consensus group. INTERVENTIONS: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Qualitative reviews of each FMA-UE protocol and rater responses (agree/disagree) regarding variations in general administration instructions (ie, instructions that could affect the scoring of many individual test items) were discussed and analyzed during a 3-phase consensus process. An a priori target of 80% or greater agreement was used to determine group consensus. RESULTS: Consensus was attained for 7 of 10 general administration instructions. Recommendations from our consensus group summarize "best practice" general instructions for researchers and clinicians. A case example, in which we found up to a 21-point difference between the highest and lowest FMA-UE scores, highlights the potential effect of these protocol variations. CONCLUSIONS: Variations among FMA-UE administration protocols during stroke rehabilitation studies can lead to discrepancies in the interpretation and translation of research findings across institutions and limit the perceived value and uptake of standardized assessments for evidence-based practice. The results of this nominal group consensus provide a first step toward developing cohesive FMA-UE recommendations for wider dissemination and review.

来源:Arch Phys Med Rehabil,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fasoli SE, Mazariegos J, Rishe K, et al. Interpreting Variations in Fugl-Meyer Assessment Protocols: Results and Recommendations From a Nominal Group Consensus Process. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2024. PMID: 39461495. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2024.10.004

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。