脑卒中患者Berg平衡量表计算机自适应测试:不牺牲精度的测量效率提升
该研究基于519例亚急性和慢性脑卒中步行患者的回顾性数据,用项目反应理论验证Berg平衡量表(BBS)的单维性并模拟计算机自适应测试(CAT)。结果显示BBS CAT在平均仅施测5.43个条目时即可达到与完整14条目高度相关的平衡能力估计(r=0.952),测量效率显著提升且精度未受损。
要点
- BBS满足单维性,可采用评定量表模型进行测量。
- BBS CAT施测5个及以上条目时精度在0.5 logit以内。
- 基于精度停止规则的CAT平均仅需5.43个条目。
核心结论
- BBS计算机自适应测试在亚急性和慢性脑卒中步行患者中能高效复现完整量表的信度。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性数据库研究,纳入519例亚急性和慢性脑卒中步行患者,采用主成分分析残差和Rasch分析。
主要发现
- 主成分分析残差支持BBS单维性,Rasch分析支持使用评定量表模型。
- 全部条目施测时BBS CAT最大精度为SE=0.40 logits。
- 施测4个及以上条目时CAT估计平衡能力与实际能力高度相关(r>0.9)。
- 施测5个及以上条目时精度在0.5 logits以内(SE<0.48 logits)。
- 基于精度停止规则时CAT估计与实际能力高度相关(r=0.952),平均施测条目数为5.43。
关键数值与推荐
- 精度停止规则阈值为0.5 logit标准误(SE)。
临床怎么用
- BBS CAT可为脑卒中康复中的平衡能力测量提供高效方式,节省临床时间。
局限性
- 未来工作应旨在增强测量的可解释性以促进临床决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objectives of this study were to confirm the Berg Balance Scale's (BBS) measurement properties and unidimensionality with an item response theory analysis in persons with subacute and chronic stroke and to examine the precision and efficiency of computerized adaptive testing (CAT). METHODS: Data were obtained from 519 ambulatory persons with subacute and chronic stroke in 2 retrospective databases. A principal component analysis (PCA) of residuals was used to evaluate unidimensionality. BBS fit to a rating scale model versus a partial credit model was examined, and item parameters were generated for CAT calibration. Person measures from all 14 items were defined as actual balance ability. BBS CAT simulations were used to examine changes in measurement precision with increasing number of items administered and a precision-based stopping rule (0.5 logit standard error [SE] threshold). RESULTS: A PCA of residuals supports the BBS unidimensionality and Rasch analysis supports using the rating scale model for measurement. Maximum precision for BBS CAT was SE = 0.40 logits when administering all items. BBS CAT estimated balance ability was highly correlated with actual ability when 4 or more items were administered (r > 0.9). Precision was within 0.5 logits when 5 or more items were administered (SE < 0.48 logits). BBS CAT estimated balance ability was highly correlated with actual ability (r = 0.952) using a precision-based stopping rule. The average number of items administered with the precision-based stopping rule was 5.43. CONCLUSION: The BBS is sufficiently unidimensional, and the rating scale model can be used for measurement. BBS CAT is efficient and replicates the full instrument's reliability when measuring balance ability in ambulatory persons with subacute and chronic stroke. Future work should aim to enhance the interpretability of measures to facilitate clinical decision-making. IMPACT: BBS CAT provides an efficient way of measuring balance ability for individuals in stroke rehabilitation giving clinicians more time with patients.
引用
- Seamon BA, Kautz SA, Velozo CA, et al. Computerized Adaptive Testing for the Berg Balance Scale Improves Measurement Efficiency Without Compromising Precision in People With Stroke. Phys Ther. 2024. PMID: 39113593. doi:10.1093/ptj/pzae112
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。