儿童与青少年混合式联合健康服务:范围综述
本范围综述检索6个数据库共9868项研究,最终纳入21项针对儿童与青少年的研究,评估混合式联合健康服务的定义、服务特征、结局指标和结果。术语不统一,超75%使用定制软件,67%聚焦心理健康,最常见结局为可行性与满意度但工具不一致,57%研究显示有效但无成本效果评估。
要点
- 混合式服务术语不统一,所有干预均以面对面开始,可能用于建立治疗联盟和解决技术问题。
- 超75%使用定制软件限制可推广性,67%聚焦心理健康,仅少数涉及物理、作业或言语治疗。
- 57%研究显示有效,但无成本效果评估,可行性与满意度测量工具不一致。
核心结论
- 尽管混合式联合健康服务对儿童与青少年有潜力,文献仍处初步阶段,需标准化定义、结局指标和 clearer 报告服务特征与结果以促进临床整合。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,检索Medline(Ovid)、Embase、CINHAL、Psycinfo、Cochrane CENTRAL和Web of Science共6个数据库。
- 从9868项可能符合标准的研究中,49项聚焦儿童与青少年,全文审查后纳入21项研究。
主要发现
- 混合式联合健康服务的术语因研究而异,针对不同临床人群,研究设计、远程与面对面治疗的类型和频率各异。
- 超过75%的案例使用定制编写软件,限制了可扩展性。
- 所有干预均以面对面开始,可能用于建立治疗联盟和解决技术问题。
- 大多数混合式联合健康服务(67%)属于心理健康领域,仅少数涉及物理、作业或言语治疗。
- 最常见的结局是可行性和满意度,但测量工具不一致;57%的研究显示混合式联合健康服务有效,但无研究测量成本效果。
关键数值与推荐
- 超过75%的案例使用定制编写软件。
- 67%的混合式联合健康服务属于心理健康领域。
- 57%的研究显示混合式联合健康服务有效。
- 无研究测量成本效果。
临床怎么用
- 临床开展混合式联合健康服务时可参考:干预以面对面开始可能有助于建立治疗联盟和解决技术问题。
- 需注意术语和结局测量工具不一致,选择可行性与满意度工具时应考虑标准化。
- 目前证据多集中于心理健康领域,物理、作业或言语治疗领域的混合式服务证据较少。
局限性
- 文献仍处初步阶段,术语和结局测量工具不一致。
- 超过75%使用定制软件,限制可扩展性。
- 无研究测量成本效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Hybrid models that integrate both in-person and remote health services are increasingly recognized as a promising approach. Nevertheless, research that defines and characterizes these models in children and young people is scarce and essential for establishing guidelines for implementation of hybrid allied health services. This scoping review evaluates four key aspects of hybrid allied health services in children and young people: 1. definitions, 2. service characteristics, 3. outcome measures, and 4. results of hybrid allied health services. METHODS: Six databases were searched: Medline (Ovid), Embase, CINHAL, Psycinfo, Cochrane CENTRAL, and Web of Science. Of the 9,868 studies potentially meeting the inclusion criteria, 49 studies focused on children and young people. Following full-text review, n = 21 studies were included. RESULTS: Terminology used for hybrid allied health services varied across studies which targeted diverse clinical populations and varied in study design, type and frequency of remote and in-person treatments. Over 75% of cases used custom-written software, limiting scalability. All interventions started in-person, possibly to establish a therapeutic alliance and solve technological issues. Most hybrid allied health services (67%) were in mental health, while only a minority involved physical, occupational or speech therapy. The most common outcomes were feasibility and satisfaction, but tools used to measure them were inconsistent. Although 57% of studies demonstrated effectiveness of hybrid allied health services, none measured cost-effectiveness. DISCUSSION: Despite the potential of hybrid allied health services for children and young people, the literature remains at a preliminary stage. Standardization of definitions and outcome measures, and clearer reporting of service characteristics and results would likely promote consolidation of hybrid allied health services in children and young people into clinical practice.
引用
- Krasovsky T, Weiss PL, Gafni-Lachter L, et al. Hybrid approaches to allied health services for children and young people: a scoping review. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2024. PMID: 39030627. doi:10.1186/s12984-024-01401-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。