文献速递神经康复

扩展现实评估卒中后手部灵巧性:经典箱块测试与沉浸式虚拟现实及混合现实测试的对比

Extended reality to assess post-stroke manual dexterity: contrasts between the classic box and block test, immersive virtual reality with controllers, with hand-tracking, and mixed-reality tests.
PubMed 文献 · J Neuroeng Rehabil · 2024-03-15

该研究纳入21名健康对照和21名偏瘫卒中患者,比较传统箱块测试(BBT)与三种扩展现实(XR)手部灵巧性测试的效度、信度和可用性。结果显示BBT-VR-HT和MD-MR与BBT的相关性高(r=0.94和0.95),重测信度优秀(ICC≥0.96),可用性优秀(SUS中位数83),而BBT-VR-C相关性较低(r=0.65)且可用性良好(SUS中位数70)。

要点

  • BBT-VR-HT和MD-MR与经典BBT的收敛效度高,可作为卒中后手部灵巧性评估工具。
  • BBT-VR-HT和MD-MR的可用性优秀(SUS中位数83),重测信度优秀(ICC≥0.96)。
  • BBT-VR-C内容效度较差(评定为比传统BBT更难),收敛效度较低(r=0.65)。

核心结论

  • 不同的扩展现实手部测试是评估卒中后手部灵巧性的有效、短期可靠且可用的工具。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入21名健康对照参与者和21名偏瘫卒中患者,每人均完成三次传统BBT、BBT-VR-C、BBT-VR-HT和MD-MR测试。
  • 内容效度由5名医疗专业人员评定各测试相对于传统BBT的执行难度。
  • 收敛效度通过传统BBT与XR测试得分之间的相关性评估,重测信度通过第二和第三次试验间的相关性评估,可用性采用系统可用性量表(SUS)评估。
  • 上肢运动平滑度(SPARC)在卒中患者和健康对照间比较了两种BBT-VR版本。

主要发现

  • 在卒中患者中,BBT与BBT-VR-HT的相关系数r=0.94(p<0.001),BBT与MD-MR的相关系数r=0.95(p<0.001),均高于BBT与BBT-VR-C的相关系数r=0.65(p=0.001)。
  • BBT-VR-HT和MD-MR的可用性均评为优秀,SUS中位数分别为83[57.5-91.3]和83[53.8-92.5]。
  • BBT-VR-C、BBT-VR-HT和BBT-MR的重测信度均优秀,ICC分别为0.96(p<0.001)、0.96(p<0.001)和0.99(p<0.001)。
  • BBT-VR-C的可用性评为良好,SUS中位数为70[43.8-83.8]。
  • 健康对照的上肢运动在完成BBT-VR-C(t=2.05;p=0.043)和BBT-VR-HT(t=5.21;p<0.001)时均显著比卒中患者更平滑。

关键数值与推荐

  • 医疗专业人员评定BBT-VR-HT(0[0-1])和BBT-MR(0[0-1])的执行难度与传统BBT相同,而评定BBT-VR-C(1[0-2])比传统BBT更难。

临床怎么用

  • BBT-VR-HT和MD-MR可用于卒中后手部灵巧性的客观评估,其效度、信度和可用性均支持临床使用。
  • BBT-VR-C虽然信度优秀,但内容效度和收敛效度较低,临床选择时需注意其评估难度高于传统BBT。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Recent technological advancements present promising opportunities to enhance the frequency and objectivity of functional assessments, aligning with recent stroke rehabilitation guidelines. Within this framework, we designed and adapted different manual dexterity tests in extended reality (XR), using immersive virtual reality (VR) with controllers (BBT-VR-C), immersive VR with hand-tracking (BBT-VR-HT), and mixed-reality (MD-MR). OBJECTIVE: This study primarily aimed to assess and compare the validity of the BBT-VR-C, BBT-VR-HT and MD-MR to assess post-stroke manual dexterity. Secondary objectives were to evaluate reliability, usability and to define arm kinematics measures. METHODS: A sample of 21 healthy control participants (HCP) and 21 stroke individuals with hemiparesis (IHP) completed three trials of the traditional BBT, the BBT-VR-C, BBT-VR-HT and MD-MR. Content validity of the different tests were evaluated by asking five healthcare professionals to rate the difficulty of performing each test in comparison to the traditional BBT. Convergent validity was evaluated through correlations between the scores of the traditional BBT and the XR tests. Test-retest reliability was assessed through correlations between the second and third trial and usability was assessed using the System Usability Scale (SUS). Lastly, upper limb movement smoothness (SPARC) was compared between IHP and HCP for both BBT-VR test versions. RESULTS: For content validity, healthcare professionals rated the BBT-VR-HT (0[0-1]) and BBT-MR (0[0-1]) as equally difficult to the traditional BBT, whereas they rated BBT-VR-C as more difficult than the traditional BBT (1[0-2]). For IHP convergent validity, the Pearson tests demonstrated larger correlations between the scores of BBT and BBT-VR-HT (r = 0.94;p < 0.001), and BBT and MD-MR (r = 0.95;p < 0.001) than BBT and BBT-VR-C (r = 0.65;p = 0.001). BBT-VR-HT and MD-MR usability were both rated as excellent, with median SUS scores of 83[57.5-91.3] and 83[53.8-92.5] respectively. Excellent reliability was found for the BBT-VR-C (ICC = 0.96;p < 0.001), BBT-VR-HT (ICC = 0.96;p < 0.001) and BBT-MR (ICC = 0.99;p < 0.001). The usability of the BBT-VR-C was rated as good with a median SUS of 70[43.8-83.8]. Upper limb movements of HCP were significantly smoother than for IHP when completing either the BBT-VR-C (t = 2.05;p = 0.043) and the BBT-VR-HT (t = 5.21;p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: The different XR manual tests are valid, short-term reliable and usable tools to assess post-stroke manual dexterity. TRIAL REGISTRATION: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04694833 ; Unique identifier: NCT04694833, Date of registration: 11/24/2020.

来源:J Neuroeng Rehabil,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Everard G, Burton Q, Van de Sype V, et al. Extended reality to assess post-stroke manual dexterity: contrasts between the classic box and block test, immersive virtual reality with controllers, with hand-tracking, and mixed-reality tests. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2024. PMID: 38491540. doi:10.1186/s12984-024-01332-x

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。