脊髓损伤步态康复下肢可穿戴外骨骼用户需求的定性研究
该研究通过访谈15名脊髓损伤患者和10名临床医生,采用定向内容分析法,识别出78个编码归为9类需求。患者与临床医生之间、有无外骨骼经验患者之间的一致性均有限(分别为50.00%和55.77%),提示设计过程需纳入多类用户,并推荐纳入有技术经验者。
要点
- 患者与临床医生需求一致性仅50.00%,双方需求互补,均应参与设计。
- 有外骨骼经验的患者内部共识强、需求表达清晰,推荐纳入设计过程。
- 下肢外骨骼可及性与可用性不足在多数访谈中被提及。
核心结论
- 患者与临床医生对外骨骼需求的一致性有限,说明两类用户需求互补,设计过程应同时纳入。
- 推荐纳入有外骨骼使用经验的患者,因其内部共识强且能清晰表达需求。
- 研究补充了文献中未报道的16个新编码,提示外骨骼开发需关注更多用户相关方面。
研究设计与样本
- 在西班牙3个康复中心访谈15名脊髓损伤患者(9名无外骨骼经验、6名有经验)和10名临床医生。
- 采用定向内容分析法对访谈资料进行编码与归类。
主要发现
- 共识别78个编码,归为9类:物理结果、可用性、心理相关编码、技术特征、活动、获取问题、使用情境、技术开发与临床康复情境。
- 至少20%的受访用户表达了上述78个编码,其中16个编码未在文献中发现。
- 患者与临床医生之间的一致性百分比为50.00%,两类患者之间为55.77%。
- 多数访谈中提及下肢外骨骼用于步态康复的可及性与可用性有限。
关键数值与推荐
- 一致性百分比计算方式:两组中均超过20%受访者表达的编码数,除以任一组超过20%表达的编码总数。
- 患者与临床医生一致性为50.00%,有无外骨骼经验患者之间一致性为55.77%。
临床怎么用
- 设计、开发与评估下肢可穿戴外骨骼用于步态康复时,应同时纳入患者与临床医生的需求。
- 建议纳入有外骨骼使用经验的患者参与需求定义与评价。
- 需关注外骨骼在实际康复中心情境中的可及性、可用性与实施可行性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: We aim to determine a comprehensive set of requirements, perceptions, and expectations that people with spinal cord injury (SCI) and the clinicians in charge of their rehabilitation have regarding the use of wearable robots (WR) for gait rehabilitation. BACKGROUND: There are concerns due to the limited user acceptance of WR for gait rehabilitation. Developers need to emphasize understanding the needs and constraints of all stakeholders involved, including the real-life dynamics of rehabilitation centers. METHODS: 15 people with SCI, 9 without experience with WR and 6 with experience with these technologies, and 10 clinicians from 3 rehabilitation centers in Spain were interviewed. A directed content analysis approach was used. RESULTS: 78 codes grouped into 9 categories (physical results, usability, psychology-related codes, technical characteristics, activities, acquisition issues, context of use, development of the technologies and clinical rehabilitation context) were expressed by at least 20% of the users interviewed, of whom 16 were not found in the literature. The agreement percentage between each group and subgroup included in the study, calculated as the number of codes that more than 20% of both groups expressed, divided over the total amount of codes any of those two groups agreed on (≥ 20%), showed limited agreement between patients and clinicians (50.00%) and between both types of patients (55.77%). The limited accessibility and availability of lower limb exoskeletons for gait rehabilitation arose in most of the interviews. CONCLUSIONS: The limited agreement percentage between patients and clinicians indicates that including both types of users in the design process of these technologies is important, given that their requirements are complementary. Engaging users with prior technology experience is recommended, as they often exhibit strong internal consensus and articulate well-defined requirements. This study adds up the knowledge available in the literature and the new codes found in our data, which enlighten important aspects that ought to be addressed in the field to develop technologies that respond to users' needs, are usable and feasible to implement in their intended contexts. APPLICATION: The set of criteria summarized in our study will be useful to guide the design, development, and evaluation of WR for gait rehabilitation to meet user's needs and allow them to be implemented in their intended context of use.
引用
- Herrera-Valenzuela D, Díaz-Peña L, Redondo-Galán C, et al. A qualitative study to elicit user requirements for lower limb wearable exoskeletons for gait rehabilitation in spinal cord injury. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2023. PMID: 37848992. doi:10.1186/s12984-023-01264-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。