临床前与临床试验对照干预设计:第三届卒中康复圆桌会议共识核心推荐
该共识由卒中康复与康复圆桌会议(SRRR)工作组制定,采用图论投票系统对对照比较器设计中的挑战进行重要性及易解决程度排序,并开发了CONSIGN网络决策支持工具。共识形成六条推荐,涵盖研究领域、专业学科和国际边界,旨在改善对照比较器的选择、描述和报告。
要点
- 对照比较器选择是试验设计的关键问题,需建立强有力的选择理由。
- «识别合适的对照类型»被评易于解决且非常重要。
- CONSIGN工具含七步流程,经超130名神经康复研究人员多轮试点完善。
核心结论
- 建立对照比较器的强有力理由可提高试验的完整性和发现的有效性。
- CONSIGN决策支持工具旨在应对已识别的挑战并增强比较器的选择、描述和报告。
- 共识形成六条推荐,跨越研究领域、专业学科和国际边界。
研究设计与样本
- SRRR工作组采用图论投票系统对对照比较器设计中的挑战进行重要性及易解决程度排序。
- CONSIGN网络工具经多轮试点测试完善,试点包括超过130名神经康复研究人员。
- 通过四个假设示例试验(涵盖临床前、情绪、失语症和运动恢复)展示工具的实际应用。
主要发现
- «识别合适的对照类型»被评易于解决且非常重要。
- «常规护理的变异性»被评难以解决且重要性低。
- «理解对照的内容及其与实验干预的区别»被评非常重要但不易解决。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识定义了六条推荐,跨越研究领域、专业学科和国际边界。
临床怎么用
- 使用CONSIGN七步网络工具指导对照比较器的设计、描述和报告。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Control comparator selection is a critical trial design issue. Preclinical and clinical investigators who are doing trials of stroke recovery and rehabilitation interventions must carefully consider the appropriateness and relevance of their chosen control comparator as the benefit of an experimental intervention is established relative to a comparator. Establishing a strong rationale for a selected comparator improves the integrity of the trial and validity of its findings. This Stroke Recovery and Rehabilitation Roundtable (SRRR) taskforce used a graph theory voting system to rank the importance and ease of addressing challenges during control comparator design. "Identifying appropriate type of control" was ranked easy to address and very important, "variability in usual care" was ranked hard to address and of low importance, and "understanding the content of the control and how it differs from the experimental intervention" was ranked very important but not easy to address. The CONtrol DeSIGN (CONSIGN) decision support tool was developed to address the identified challenges and enhance comparator selection, description, and reporting. CONSIGN is a web-based tool inclusive of seven steps that guide the user through control comparator design. The tool was refined through multiple rounds of pilot testing that included more than 130 people working in neurorehabilitation research. Four hypothetical exemplar trials, which span preclinical, mood, aphasia, and motor recovery, demonstrate how the tool can be applied in practice. Six consensus recommendations are defined that span research domains, professional disciplines, and international borders.
引用
- Hayward KS, Dalton EJ, Barth J, et al. Control intervention design for preclinical and clinical trials: Consensus-based core recommendations from the third Stroke Recovery and Rehabilitation Roundtable. Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2023. PMID: 37837348. doi:10.1177/15459683231209162
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。