分层贝叶斯动态模型预测慢性卒中康复运动结局的长期变化
该研究提出分层贝叶斯动态模型(HBDM),纳入监督训练、自我训练和遗忘效应,并利用相似患者的先验信息改善早期预测。基于DOSE试验(40例)和EXCITE试验(95例)的MAL数据分析,模型能较好拟合个体动态,预测精度优于静态回归和简单动态模型,并可提前8个月预测新参与者的MAL。
要点
- HBDM可个体化预测慢性卒中康复中MAL的长期变化。
- 模型纳入监督训练、自我训练和遗忘效应,并利用分层先验改善稀疏数据预测。
- 预测精度随训练次数增加而提高,6个月RMSE从1.36降至0.69。
核心结论
- HBDM能较好拟合慢性卒中患者MAL的个体动态,预测精度优于静态回归和未纳入监督训练、自我训练或遗忘效应的简单动态模型。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为基于两项临床试验数据的再分析,采用分层贝叶斯动态(状态空间)模型。
- DOSE试验纳入40例慢性卒中参与者,随机分配至0、15、30或60小时剂量条件。
- EXCITE试验纳入95例慢性卒中参与者,分配至60小时剂量,分即时或延迟条件。
主要发现
- 对全部40例DOSE参与者,平均RMSE=0.28(个体水平RMSE 0.26 ± 0.19,95%CI)。
- 对全部95例EXCITE参与者,平均RMSE=0.325(个体水平RMSE 0.32 ± 0.31)。
- 贝叶斯留一交叉验证显示模型预测精度优于静态回归模型和未纳入监督训练、自我训练或遗忘效应的简单动态模型。
- 预测新参与者训练后6个月MAL时,仅用基线MAL的平均RMSE为1.36,加入第1、2、3轮训练后MAL后分别降至0.91、0.79和0.69。
临床怎么用
- 该模型可用于模拟不同恢复阶段、剂量和训练安排,以优化个体化康复方案。
局限性
- 原文未报告模型在临床实践中应用的外部验证或前瞻性研究结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Given the heterogeneity of stroke, it is important to determine the best course of motor therapy for each patient, i.e., to personalize rehabilitation based on predictions of long-term outcomes. Here, we propose a hierarchical Bayesian dynamic (i.e., state-space) model (HBDM) to forecast long-term changes in a motor outcome due to rehabilitation in the chronic phase post-stroke. METHODS: The model incorporates the effects of clinician-supervised training, self-training, and forgetting. In addition, to improve forecasting early in rehabilitation, when data are sparse or unavailable, we use the Bayesian hierarchical modeling technique to incorporate prior information from similar patients. We use HBDM to re-analyze the Motor Activity Log (MAL) data of participants with chronic stroke included in two clinical trials: (1) the DOSE trial, in which participants were assigned to a 0, 15, 30, or 60-h dose condition (data of 40 participants analyzed), and (2) the EXCITE trial, in which participants were assigned a 60-h dose, in either an immediate or a delayed condition (95 participants analyzed). RESULTS: For both datasets, HBDM accounts well for individual dynamics in the MAL during and outside of training: mean RMSE = 0.28 for all 40 DOSE participants (participant-level RMSE 0.26 ± 0.19-95% CI) and mean RMSE = 0.325 for all 95 EXCITE participants (participant-level RMSE 0.32 ± 0.31), which are small compared to the 0-5 range of the MAL. Bayesian leave-one-out cross-validation shows that the model has better predictive accuracy than static regression models and simpler dynamic models that do not account for the effect of supervised training, self-training, or forgetting. We then showcase model's ability to forecast the MAL of "new" participants up to 8 months ahead. The mean RMSE at 6 months post-training was 1.36 using only the baseline MAL and then decreased to 0.91, 0.79, and 0.69 (respectively) with the MAL following the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd bouts of training. In addition, hierarchical modeling improves prediction for a patient early in training. Finally, we verify that this model, despite its simplicity, can reproduce previous findings of the DOSE trial on the efficiency, efficacy, and retention of motor therapy. CONCLUSIONS: In future work, such forecasting models can be used to simulate different stages of recovery, dosages, and training schedules to optimize rehabilitation for each person. Trial registration This study contains a re-analysis of data from the DOSE clinical trial ID NCT01749358 and the EXCITE clinical trial ID NCT00057018.
引用
- Schweighofer N, Ye D, Luo H, et al. Long-term forecasting of a motor outcome following rehabilitation in chronic stroke via a hierarchical bayesian dynamic model. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2023. PMID: 37386512. doi:10.1186/s12984-023-01202-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。