文献速递神经康复

非侵入性脑刺激改善卒中后上肢运动功能与日常生活活动能力的系统综述与网状Meta分析

Non-invasive Brain Stimulation Techniques for the Improvement of Upper Limb Motor Function and Performance in Activities of Daily Living After Stroke: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Arch Phys Med Rehabil · 2023-05-26

该系统综述与网状Meta分析纳入87项RCT共3750例卒中患者,比较tDCS、rTMS、TBS和taVNS对上肢运动功能及ADL的疗效。配对Meta分析显示除cTBS和阴极tDCS外,所有NiBS对运动功能均优于假刺激;taVNS、阳极tDCS及低频和高频rTMS对ADL优于假刺激。NMA显示taVNS在改善运动功能和ADL方面排名最佳,但需进一步大样本RCT确认其相对优越性。

要点

  • 除cTBS和阴极tDCS外,各NiBS对卒中后上肢运动功能均优于假刺激。
  • taVNS、阳极tDCS及低频和高频rTMS对ADL优于假刺激。
  • NMA排名taVNS在改善运动功能和ADL方面最佳,但证据需大样本RCT确认。

核心结论

  • 兴奋性刺激方案是改善卒中后上肢运动功能和ADL最有前景的干预。
  • taVNS似乎是卒中患者的有前景干预,但需进一步大样本RCT确认其相对优越性。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述与网状Meta分析,检索PubMed、Web of Science和Cochrane数据库2010年1月至2022年6月的文献。
  • 纳入评估tDCS、rTMS、TBS或taVNS对卒中后上肢运动功能和ADL效果的RCT。
  • 共纳入87项RCT,3750例参与者;由2名独立评价者提取数据,采用Cochrane偏倚风险工具评估。

主要发现

  • 配对Meta分析显示,除cTBS和阴极tDCS外,所有NiBS对运动功能均显著优于假刺激(SMD范围0.42-1.20)。
  • taVNS、阳极tDCS及低频和高频rTMS对ADL显著优于假刺激(SMD范围0.54-0.99)。
  • NMA显示taVNS对运动功能优于cTBS(SMD 1.00;95%CI 0.02-2.02)、阴极tDCS(SMD 1.07;95%CI 0.21-1.92)和单纯物理康复(SMD 1.46;95%CI 0.59-2.33)。
  • P-score显示taVNS在改善运动功能(SMD 1.20;95%CI 0.46-1.95)和ADL(SMD 1.20;95%CI 0.45-1.94)方面排名最佳。
  • taVNS之后,兴奋性刺激方案(间歇TBS、阳极tDCS和高频rTMS)对急性/亚急性(SMD范围0.53-1.63)和慢性卒中(SMD范围0.39-1.16)的运动功能和ADL最有效。

关键数值与推荐

  • 运动功能:除cTBS和阴极tDCS外,NiBS优于假刺激的SMD范围为0.42-1.20。
  • ADL:taVNS、阳极tDCS及低频和高频rTMS优于假刺激的SMD范围为0.54-0.99。
  • taVNS对运动功能优于cTBS的SMD为1.00(95%CI 0.02-2.02),优于阴极tDCS的SMD为1.07(95%CI 0.21-1.92),优于单纯物理康复的SMD为1.46(95%CI 0.59-2.33)。
  • taVNS改善运动功能的P-score SMD为1.20(95%CI 0.46-1.95),改善ADL的P-score SMD为1.20(95%CI 0.45-1.94)。

临床怎么用

  • 卒中后上肢运动功能康复可优先考虑兴奋性刺激方案(间歇TBS、阳极tDCS、高频rTMS)。
  • taVNS在改善运动功能和ADL方面排名最佳,可作为有前景的干预选择,但需大样本RCT进一步验证。
  • cTBS和阴极tDCS对运动功能的疗效未显著优于假刺激,选择时需谨慎。

局限性

  • taVNS的相对优越性需进一步大样本RCT确认。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To compare the efficacy of non-invasive brain stimulation (NiBS) such as transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS), theta-burst stimulation (TBS), and transcutaneous vagus nerve stimulation (taVNS) in upper limb stroke rehabilitation. DATA SOURCES: PubMed, Web of Science, and Cochrane databases were searched from January 2010 to June 2022. DATA SELECTION: Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) assessing the effects of "tDCS", "rTMS", "TBS", or "taVNS" on upper limb motor function and performance in activities of daily livings (ADLs) after stroke. DATA EXTRACTION: Data were extracted by 2 independent reviewers. Risk of bias was evaluated with the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool. DATA SYNTHESIS: 87 RCTs with 3750 participants were included. Pairwise meta-analysis showed that all NiBS except continuous TBS (cTBS) and cathodal tDCS were significantly more efficacious than sham stimulation for motor function (standardized mean difference [SMD] range 0.42-1.20), whereas taVNS, anodal tDCS, and both low and high frequency rTMS were significantly more efficacious than sham stimulation for ADLs (SMD range 0.54-0.99). NMA showed that taVNS was more effective than cTBS (SMD:1.00; 95% CI (0.02-2.02)), cathodal tDCS (SMD:1.07; 95% CI (0.21-1.92)), and Physical rehabilitation alone (SMD:1.46; 95% CI (0.59-2.33)) for improving motor function. P-score found that taVNS is best ranked treatment in improving motor function (SMD: 1.20; 95% CI (0.46-1.95)) and ADLs (SMD:1.20; 95% CI (0.45-1.94)) after stroke. After taVNS, excitatory stimulation protocols (intermittent TBS, anodal tDCS, and HF-rTMS) are most effective in improving motor function and ADLs after acute/sub-acute (SMD range 0.53-1.63) and chronic stroke (SMD range 0.39-1.16). CONCLUSIONS: Evidence suggests that excitatory stimulation protocols are the most promising intervention in improving upper limb motor function and performance in ADLs. taVNS appeared to be a promising intervention for stroke patients, but further large RCTs are required to confirm its relative superiority.

来源:Arch Phys Med Rehabil,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ahmed I, Mustafaoglu R, Rossi S, et al. Non-invasive Brain Stimulation Techniques for the Improvement of Upper Limb Motor Function and Performance in Activities of Daily Living After Stroke: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2023. PMID: 37245690. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2023.04.027

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。