联合与单一神经刺激及传统吞咽疗法治疗卒中后吞咽障碍的疗效比较:一项网络荟萃分析
该网络荟萃分析纳入50项随机对照试验共2250例卒中后吞咽障碍患者,比较联合与单一神经刺激及传统吞咽疗法的疗效。结果显示NMES+TDT、tDCS+TDT和rTMS+TDT在改善吞咽功能及缩短咽部通过时间等方面疗效更优,联合疗法总体优于单一疗法。
要点
- NMES+TDT在改善吞咽功能和缩短咽部通过时间方面排名最高。
- rTMS+TDT和tDCS+TDT分别对缩短咽部通过时间和减少误吸/渗漏排名最高。
- 联合疗法疗效受治疗频率、次数和疗程调节。
核心结论
- 联合疗法包括NMES+TDT、tDCS+TDT和rTMS+TDT在改善卒中后吞咽障碍患者吞咽功能及缩短咽部通过时间、口腔通过时间和减少误吸/渗漏方面显示更好疗效。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为频率学派网络荟萃分析,纳入50项随机对照研究共2250例参与者。
- 采用标准化均数差(SMD)及95%置信区间(95%CI)表示疗效效应量,并用R软件netrank函数对疗法排序。
- 研究特征通过贝叶斯网络荟萃分析模型进行元回归分析。
主要发现
- NMES+TDT改善吞咽功能的SMD为3.82(95%CI 1.62-6.01),tDCS+TDT为3.34(95%CI 1.09-5.59),rTMS+TDT为3.32(95%CI 1.18-5.47),NMES为2.69(95%CI 0.44-4.93),TDT为2.27(95%CI 0.12-4.41)。
- NMES+TDT缩短咽部通过时间的SMD为-0.50(95%CI -0.68至-0.32),rTMS+TDT为-0.44(95%CI -0.67至-0.21),TDT为-0.28(95%CI -0.46至-0.10),NMES为-0.19(95%CI -0.34至-0.04)。
- rTMS缩短口腔通过时间的SMD为-0.51(95%CI -0.93至-0.08)。
- 在减少误吸/渗漏方面,各疗法比较未见显著差异。
- 改善吞咽功能和缩短咽部通过时间排名最高的疗法为NMES+TDT,缩短口腔通过时间排名最高的为rTMS,减少误吸/渗漏排名最高的为tDCS+TDT。
关键数值与推荐
- NMES+TDT改善吞咽功能SMD 3.82(95%CI 1.62-6.01),缩短咽部通过时间SMD -0.50(95%CI -0.68至-0.32)。
- tDCS+TDT改善吞咽功能SMD 3.34(95%CI 1.09-5.59)。
- rTMS+TDT改善吞咽功能SMD 3.32(95%CI 1.18-5.47),缩短咽部通过时间SMD -0.44(95%CI -0.67至-0.21)。
- rTMS缩短口腔通过时间SMD -0.51(95%CI -0.93至-0.08)。
- NMES改善吞咽功能SMD 2.69(95%CI 0.44-4.93),缩短咽部通过时间SMD -0.19(95%CI -0.34至-0.04);TDT改善吞咽功能SMD 2.27(95%CI 0.12-4.41),缩短咽部通过时间SMD -0.28(95%CI -0.46至-0.10)。
临床怎么用
- 对于卒中后吞咽障碍患者,可优先考虑NMES+TDT、tDCS+TDT或rTMS+TDT等联合治疗方案以改善吞咽功能。
- 若目标为缩短咽部通过时间,NMES+TDT排名最高;若目标为缩短口腔通过时间,rTMS排名最高;若目标为减少误吸/渗漏,tDCS+TDT排名最高。
- 制定治疗方案时应考虑治疗频率、次数和疗程对疗效的调节作用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Comparative therapeutic benefits of combined and single neurostimulation therapies including neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES), pharyngeal electrical stimulation (PES), repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS), transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), and traditional dysphagia therapy (TDT) remain unknown in post-stroke dysphagia (PSD) rehabilitation. Therefore, we performed the first network meta-analysis (NMA) to determine comparative effectiveness of combined and single neurostimulation and traditional dysphagia therapies for PSD. METHODS: A frequentist NMA model was performed with therapy effect sizes presented as standardized mean differences (SMD) and corresponding 95% confidence interval (95% CI) for therapy comparisons while netrank function ranked the therapies in R-Software. Meta-regression models for study characteristics were analyzed using Bayesian NMA Model. RESULTS: Overall, 50 randomized controlled studies with 2250 participants were included. NMES + TDT 3.82 (95% CI, 1.62-6.01), tDCS + TDT 3.34 (95% CI, 1.09-5.59), rTMS + TDT 3.32 (95% CI, 1.18-5.47), NMES 2.69 (95% CI, 0.44-4.93), and TDT 2.27 (95% CI, 0.12-4.41) demonstrated very large effect in improving swallowing function. NMES + TDT -0.50 (95% CI, -0.68 to -0.32, rTMS + TDT -0.44 (95% CI, -0.67 to -0.21), TDT -0.28 (95% CI, -0.46 to -0.10), and NMES -0.19 (95% CI, -0.34 to -0.04) demonstrated medium to small effect in reducing pharyngeal transit time (PTT). rTMS -0.51 (95% CI, -0.93 to -0.08) demonstrated medium effect in reducing oral transit time (OTT). No significant therapy comparison differences were found for reducing aspiration/penetration. The highest ranked therapy was NMES + TDT for better swallowing function and reduction of PTT, rTMS for reduction of OTT, and tDCS + TDT for reduction of aspiration/penetration. Therapeutic effects of the therapies were moderated by frequency, sessions, and duration. CONCLUSION: Combined therapies including NMES + TDT, tDCS + TDT, and rTMS + TDT demonstrate better therapeutic effect for improved swallowing function and reduction of PTT, OTT, and aspiration/penetration for PSD.
引用
- Banda KJ, Wu KC, Jen HJ, et al. Comparative Effectiveness of Combined and Single Neurostimulation and Traditional Dysphagia Therapies for Post-Stroke Dysphagia: A Network Meta-Analysis. Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2023. PMID: 37078600. doi:10.1177/15459683231166940
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。