文献速递神经康复骨科与运动康复

下肢外骨骼控制策略在脑损伤步态康复中的系统综述与临床有效性分析

Control strategies used in lower limb exoskeletons for gait rehabilitation after brain injury: a systematic review and analysis of clinical effectiveness.
PubMed 文献 · J Neuroeng Rehabil · 2023-02-19

该综述纳入159项临床研究,分析下肢外骨骼控制策略在脑损伤患者步态康复中的应用与临床有效性。研究发现辅助控制(100%)、基于规则算法(72%)和轨迹跟踪控制(97%)最常见,仅14%采用自适应控制。不同控制策略在急性、亚急性和慢性卒中患者中显示不同疗效,但证据等级仍较低且实验方案缺乏标准化。

要点

  • 辅助控制与轨迹跟踪是最常见策略,自适应控制仅占14%。
  • 急性卒中患者中,轨迹跟踪联合柔顺控制临床有效性最高但训练时间最长。
  • 亚急性卒中患者中,基于EMG阈值算法的辅助控制以最低训练强度获得最大改善。

核心结论

  • 当前证据下,不同外骨骼控制策略对脑损伤患者临床结局的有效性证据等级仍低。
  • 实验方案缺乏标准化导致异质性高,需标准化比较以指导未来技术开发。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索4个数据库2000年1月至2020年9月文献,最终纳入159篇全文评估。
  • 纳入标准为对受损参与者进行临床有效性评估且明确解释或引用控制策略的研究。

主要发现

  • 辅助控制占100%外骨骼,基于规则算法占72%,基于地面反作用力阈值占63%,轨迹跟踪控制占97%。
  • 仅14%外骨骼采用自适应控制策略。
  • 临床验证的实验方案和结局指标选择存在高度变异性。

关键数值与推荐

  • 急性卒中:辅助控制联合轨迹跟踪与柔顺控制,证据等级高,参与者N=19,临床有效性最高但训练时间最长。
  • 亚急性卒中:辅助控制采用基于EMG的阈值算法作为步态检测指标和控制信号,证据等级高,参与者N=8,以最低训练强度获得最大改善。
  • 慢性卒中:辅助控制采用自适应振荡器算法联合轨迹跟踪,证据等级高,参与者N=19,以较低训练强度获得最大改善。

临床怎么用

  • 根据卒中分期选择控制策略:急性期可考虑轨迹跟踪联合柔顺控制,但需预留较长训练时间。
  • 亚急性期可优先选择基于EMG阈值算法的辅助控制,以较低训练强度获得改善。
  • 慢性期可考虑自适应振荡器算法联合轨迹跟踪,以较低训练强度获得改善。
  • 临床应用中需注意当前证据等级较低,应结合患者具体情况个体化选择。

局限性

  • 不同控制策略临床有效性的证据等级仍低。
  • 实验方案缺乏标准化,导致研究间高度异质性。
  • 控制参数与生物力学指标间关系尚不明确。
  • 基于患者病理特征在线自适应控制参数的外骨骼是否优于现有策略仍待解答。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: In the past decade, there has been substantial progress in the development of robotic controllers that specify how lower-limb exoskeletons should interact with brain-injured patients. However, it is still an open question which exoskeleton control strategies can more effectively stimulate motor function recovery. In this review, we aim to complement previous literature surveys on the topic of exoskeleton control for gait rehabilitation by: (1) providing an updated structured framework of current control strategies, (2) analyzing the methodology of clinical validations used in the robotic interventions, and (3) reporting the potential relation between control strategies and clinical outcomes. METHODS: Four databases were searched using database-specific search terms from January 2000 to September 2020. We identified 1648 articles, of which 159 were included and evaluated in full-text. We included studies that clinically evaluated the effectiveness of the exoskeleton on impaired participants, and which clearly explained or referenced the implemented control strategy. RESULTS: (1) We found that assistive control (100% of exoskeletons) that followed rule-based algorithms (72%) based on ground reaction force thresholds (63%) in conjunction with trajectory-tracking control (97%) were the most implemented control strategies. Only 14% of the exoskeletons implemented adaptive control strategies. (2) Regarding the clinical validations used in the robotic interventions, we found high variability on the experimental protocols and outcome metrics selected. (3) With high grade of evidence and a moderate number of participants (N = 19), assistive control strategies that implemented a combination of trajectory-tracking and compliant control showed the highest clinical effectiveness for acute stroke. However, they also required the longest training time. With high grade of evidence and low number of participants (N = 8), assistive control strategies that followed a threshold-based algorithm with EMG as gait detection metric and control signal provided the highest improvements with the lowest training intensities for subacute stroke. Finally, with high grade of evidence and a moderate number of participants (N = 19), assistive control strategies that implemented adaptive oscillator algorithms together with trajectory-tracking control resulted in the highest improvements with reduced training intensities for individuals with chronic stroke. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the efforts to develop novel and more effective controllers for exoskeleton-based gait neurorehabilitation, the current level of evidence on the effectiveness of the different control strategies on clinical outcomes is still low. There is a clear lack of standardization in the experimental protocols leading to high levels of heterogeneity. Standardized comparisons among control strategies analyzing the relation between control parameters and biomechanical metrics will fill this gap to better guide future technical developments. It is still an open question whether controllers that provide an on-line adaptation of the control parameters based on key biomechanical descriptors associated to the patients' specific pathology outperform current control strategies.

来源:J Neuroeng Rehabil,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. de Miguel-Fernández J, Lobo-Prat J, Prinsen E, et al. Control strategies used in lower limb exoskeletons for gait rehabilitation after brain injury: a systematic review and analysis of clinical effectiveness. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2023. PMID: 36805777. doi:10.1186/s12984-023-01144-5

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。