新冠肺炎期间用于卒中康复的增强现实系统
本研究将增强现实康复系统(AR Rehab)虚拟训练整合到慢性卒中患者常规康复中,随机分为中心组和家庭组,各完成20次人机整合训练。结果显示两组在FMA-UE、FMA-LE和SF-12v2 PCS均有显著改善,且接触率明显降低,提示该模式可在疫情期间有效缓解人力短缺并达成训练目标。
要点
- AR Rehab人机整合训练可显著改善慢性卒中患者上肢和下肢运动功能。
- 中心组在平衡能力和心理健康方面显著改善,家庭组在日常生活活动能力方面显著改善。
- 该模式可减少康复人力投入并降低接触率,适用于疫情等资源受限场景。
核心结论
- 人机整合模式能有效且高效地减少康复专业人员的工作量,同时达成训练目标。
- 该模式缓解了人力短缺,并在疫情期间降低了接触率。
研究设计与样本
- 慢性卒中参与者被随机分配到中心组(AR-Centre)或家庭组(AR-Home),进行20次人机整合干预。
- 中心组每节训练3/4由人类训练师(PT/OT/助理)提供、1/4由虚拟训练师提供;家庭组每节训练1/4由人类训练师提供、3/4由虚拟训练师提供。
- 共10个康复中心的129例患者入组整合项目,其中39例被选入研究分析。
主要发现
- 两组FMA-UE均显著改善(AR-Centre: p=0.0022;AR-Home: p=0.0043)。
- 两组FMA-LE均显著改善(AR-Centre: p=0.0007;AR-Home: p=0.0052)。
- 两组SF-12v2 PCS均显著改善(AR-Centre: p=0.027;AR-Home: p=0.036)。
- AR-Centre组BBS(p=0.0438)和SF-12v2 MCS(p=0.017)显著改善。
- AR-Home组BI(p=0.0007)显著改善。
关键数值与推荐
- 接触率在AR-All中降低30.75–72.30%,在AR-Centre中降低0.00–60.00%,在AR-Home中降低75.00–90.00%。
- 功能评估包括FMA-UE、FMA-LE、FAC、BBS、BI、SF-12v2 PCS和MCS,于干预前后进行。
- 干预后收集用户体验问卷,并以交付人力和虚拟训练所需时间与人力资源及临床显著改善比例作为补充指标。
临床怎么用
- 可将AR Rehab虚拟训练整合到慢性卒中患者常规康复中,以人机整合方式减少治疗师直接接触时间。
- 根据资源条件选择中心或家庭模式:中心模式人力训练占3/4,家庭模式虚拟训练占3/4。
- 在疫情等资源受限场景下,该模式有助于维持训练目标并降低接触率。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入39例慢性卒中患者进行分析,样本量有限。
- 研究在真实世界疫情设置下进行,结果可能受特定环境因素影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The lack of the rehabilitation professionals is a global issue and it is becoming more serious during COVID-19. An Augmented Reality Rehabilitation System (AR Rehab) was developed for virtual training delivery. The virtual training was integrated into the participants' usual care to reduce the human trainers' effort so that the manpower scarcity can be eased. This also resulted in the reduction of the contact rate in pandemics. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the feasibility of the AR Rehab-based virtual training when integrated into the usual care in a real-world pandemic setting, by answering questions of whether the integrated trials can help fulfill the training goal and whether the trials can be delivered when resources are limited because of COVID-19. METHODS: Chronic stroke participants were randomly assigned to either a centre-based group (AR-Centre) or a home-based group (AR-Home) for a trial consisting of 20 sessions delivered in a human-machine integrated intervention. The trial of the AR-Centre was human training intensive with 3/4 of each session delivered by human trainers (PTs/OTs/Assistants) and 1/4 delivered by the virtual trainer (AR Rehab). The trial of the AR-Home was virtual training intensive with 1/4 and 3/4 of each session delivered by human and virtual trainers, respectively. Functional assessments including Fugl-Meyer Assessment for Upper Extremity (FMA-UE) and Lower Extremity (FMA-LE), Functional Ambulation Category (FAC), Berg Balance Scale (BBS), Barthel Index (BI) of Activities of Daily Living (ADL), and Physical Component Summary (SF-12v2 PCS) and Mental Component Summary (SF-12v2 MCS) of the 12-Item Short Form Health Survey (SF-12v2), were conducted before and after the intervention. User experience (UX) using questionnaires were collected after the intervention. Time and human resources required to deliver the human and virtual training, respectively, and the proportion of participants with clinical significant improvement were also used as supplementary measures. RESULTS: There were 129 patients from 10 rehabilitation centres enrolled in the integrated program with 39 of them were selected for investigation. Significant functional improvement in FMA-UE (AR-Centre: p = 0.0022, AR-Home: p = 0.0043), FMA-LE (AR-Centre: p = 0.0007, AR-Home: p = 0.0052), SF-12v2 PCS (AR-Centre: p = 0.027, AR-Home: p = 0.036) were observed in both groups. Significant improvement in balance ability (BBS: p = 0.0438), and mental components (SF-12v2 MCS: p = 0.017) were found in AR-Centre group, while activities of daily living (BI: p = 0.0007) was found in AR-Home group. Contact rate was reduced by 30.75-72.30% within AR-All, 0.00-60.00% within AR-Centre, and 75.00-90.00% within AR-Home. CONCLUSION: The human-machine integrated mode was effective and efficient to reduce the human rehabilitation professionals' effort while fulfilling the training goals. It eased the scarcity of manpower and reduced the contact rate during the pandemics.
引用
- Yang ZQ, Du D, Wei XY, et al. Augmented reality for stroke rehabilitation during COVID-19. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2022. PMID: 36482468. doi:10.1186/s12984-022-01100-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。