确定儿童和成人非进行性神经系统疾病运动神经康复的最佳移动神经反馈方法:范围综述
该范围综述检索PubMed、Web of Science和Scopus数据库,最终纳入23项独特研究,所有研究均使用EEG,除一项外均为卒中人群。最常报告的功能结局为FMA(n=13)和ARAT(n=6),FMA显示训练前后有统计学和功能显著变化,但ARAT无显著变化;FMA结局与训练剂量正相关。结论确认BCI神经反馈训练改善运动结局的有效性,并提示联想学习范式可能特别可行有效。
要点
- BCI神经反馈训练可改善卒中成人运动结局,FMA显示显著变化且与训练剂量正相关。
- 机器人反馈与电刺激反馈范式之间FMA结果无差异。
- ARAT未显示统计学和功能显著变化,需更多儿童和成人临床试验优化方法和剂量。
核心结论
- BCI神经反馈训练确认改善运动结局的有效性,并有成人卒中神经可塑性增强的一些证据。
- 联想学习范式近期出现,可能特别可行和有效。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,检索PubMed、Web of Science和Scopus数据库,从5109篇论文中筛选出23项独特研究。
- 仅纳入要求运动尝试而非运动想象的研究,所有研究使用EEG,除一项外均为卒中人群。
主要发现
- 最常报告的功能结局为FMA(n=13)和ARAT(n=6),FMA显示训练前后有统计学和功能显著变化,ARAT无显著变化。
- 机器人反馈与电刺激反馈范式之间结果无差异,FMA结局与训练剂量正相关。
关键数值与推荐
- FMA(n=13)和ARAT(n=6)用于评估有效性、设计特征和与训练剂量的相关性。
临床怎么用
- BCI神经反馈训练可用于卒中成人运动康复,FMA结局与训练剂量正相关,提示可考虑剂量优化。
- 联想学习范式可能特别可行有效,但需更多儿童和成人临床试验 refine 方法和剂量并与其它循证训练策略比较。
局限性
- 除一项外均为卒中人群,儿童和成人非进行性神经系统疾病的其他人群证据有限。
- 仅纳入要求运动尝试而非运动想象的研究,可能限制对其他BCI范式的覆盖。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Brain-computer interfaces (BCI), initially designed to bypass the peripheral motor system to externally control movement using brain signals, are additionally being utilized for motor rehabilitation in stroke and other neurological disorders. Also called neurofeedback training, multiple approaches have been developed to link motor-related cortical signals to assistive robotic or electrical stimulation devices during active motor training with variable, but mostly positive, functional outcomes reported. Our specific research question for this scoping review was: for persons with non-progressive neurological injuries who have the potential to improve voluntary motor control, which mobile BCI-based neurofeedback methods demonstrate or are associated with improved motor outcomes for Neurorehabilitation applications? METHODS: We searched PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus databases with all steps from study selection to data extraction performed independently by at least 2 individuals. Search terms included: brain machine or computer interfaces, neurofeedback and motor; however, only studies requiring a motor attempt, versus motor imagery, were retained. Data extraction included participant characteristics, study design details and motor outcomes. RESULTS: From 5109 papers, 139 full texts were reviewed with 23 unique studies identified. All utilized EEG and, except for one, were on the stroke population. The most commonly reported functional outcomes were the Fugl-Meyer Assessment (FMA; n = 13) and the Action Research Arm Test (ARAT; n = 6) which were then utilized to assess effectiveness, evaluate design features, and correlate with training doses. Statistically and functionally significant pre-to post training changes were seen in FMA, but not ARAT. Results did not differ between robotic and electrical stimulation feedback paradigms. Notably, FMA outcomes were positively correlated with training dose. CONCLUSION: This review on BCI-based neurofeedback training confirms previous findings of effectiveness in improving motor outcomes with some evidence of enhanced neuroplasticity in adults with stroke. Associative learning paradigms have emerged more recently which may be particularly feasible and effective methods for Neurorehabilitation. More clinical trials in pediatric and adult neurorehabilitation to refine methods and doses and to compare to other evidence-based training strategies are warranted.
引用
- Behboodi A, Lee WA, Hinchberger VS, et al. Determining optimal mobile neurofeedback methods for motor neurorehabilitation in children and adults with non-progressive neurological disorders: a scoping review. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2022. PMID: 36171602. doi:10.1186/s12984-022-01081-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。