失语症脚本训练中复杂度与反馈的可行性研究
本研究采用随机平衡单盲2×2析因设计,探讨脚本复杂度与反馈对失语症脚本训练效果的影响。结果显示训练脚本的准确性和语速在治疗后及3、6、12周维持期均显著改善,高复杂度脚本比低复杂度脚本在治疗后准确性提高11.33%、维持期提高9.90%,反馈无显著效应,非流畅型失语症患者获益更大。
要点
- 脚本训练可显著改善失语症患者训练脚本的准确性和语速,并维持至12周。
- 高复杂度脚本较低复杂度脚本在治疗后准确性提高11.33%、维持期提高9.90%。
- 反馈条件对脚本训练效果无显著影响,非流畅型失语症患者获益更大。
核心结论
- 脚本训练可作为失语症的治疗选择,高复杂度脚本更有助于促进脚本产生技能的获得与维持。
- 反馈条件对训练效果无显著影响,非流畅型失语症患者比流畅型患者获益更大。
研究设计与样本
- 随机平衡单盲2×2析因设计,在独立城市康复医院开展。
- 实验治疗为基于计算机的AphasiaScripts脚本训练程序,脚本长10轮,设置高/低复杂度及高/低反馈条件。
- 参与者被指导每天练习3次30分钟、每周6天、持续3周。
主要发现
- 训练脚本的准确性和每分钟词数在治疗后及3、6、12周维持期均获统计学显著改善。
- 未训练脚本的改善小于训练脚本,仅准确性在治疗后和3周维持期有统计学显著性。
- 复杂度对治疗后准确性(F1=4.8391,P=.0501)和维持期准确性(F1=5.3391,P=.0413)有影响。
- 高复杂度脚本较低复杂度脚本在治疗后准确性提高11.33%、维持期提高9.90%。
- 反馈无显著效应,非流畅型失语症患者比流畅型患者获益更大。
关键数值与推荐
- 高复杂度脚本较低复杂度脚本在治疗后准确性提高11.33%。
- 高复杂度脚本较低复杂度脚本在维持期准确性提高9.90%。
- 复杂度对治疗后准确性的效应:F1=4.8391,P=.0501;对维持期准确性的效应:F1=5.3391,P=.0413。
临床怎么用
- 可将基于计算机的脚本训练作为失语症康复选项,优先选用较高复杂度脚本以促进技能获得与维持。
- 训练强度可参考每天3次30分钟、每周6天、持续3周,并关注治疗后3、6、12周的维持效果。
- 反馈条件的设计对疗效影响不显著,非流畅型失语症患者可能从脚本训练中获益更多。
局限性
- 需在其他类型失语症治疗中进一步研究这些变量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To explore the effect of complexity and feedback on script training outcomes in aphasia DESIGN: Randomized balanced single-blind 2 × 2 factorial design. SETTING: Freestanding urban rehabilitation hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Adults with fluent and nonfluent aphasia (at least 6 months post onset). INTERVENTIONS: Experimental treatment was AphasiaScripts, a computer-based script training program. Scripts were 10-turns long and developed at different complexity levels to allow for comparison of high vs low complexity. The program was modified to contrast high vs low feedback conditions during sentence practice. Participants were instructed to practice three 30-minute sessions per day, 6 days per week for 3 weeks. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Gains achieved from baseline in accuracy and rate of production of trained and untrained script sentences at post treatment and at 3-, 6-, and 12-weeks after the end of treatment. RESULTS: Sixteen participants completed the intervention. On the trained script, gains were statistically significant for both accuracy and words per minute at post treatment and 3-, 6-, and 12-week maintenance. Gains on the untrained script were smaller than on the trained script; they were statistically significant only for accuracy at post treatment and 3-week maintenance. Complexity had an influence on accuracy at post-treatment (F1=4.8391, P=.0501) and at maintenance (F1=5.3391, P=.0413). Practicing scripts with high complexity increased accuracy by 11.33% at post treatment and by 9.90% at maintenance compared with scripts with low complexity. Participants with nonfluent aphasia made greater gains than those with fluent aphasia. There was no significant effect of feedback. CONCLUSIONS: This study reinforces script training as a treatment option for aphasia. Results highlight the use of more complex scripts to better promote acquisition and maintenance of script production skills. There is a need for further investigation of these variables with larger samples and with other types of aphasia treatments.
引用
- Cherney LR, Van Vuuren S. Complexity and Feedback During Script Training in Aphasia: A Feasibility Study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2022. PMID: 35304120. doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2022.03.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。