直肠癌调强质子束放疗野设计的优化:需要多少野来应对直肠扩张不确定性?
该研究针对局部晚期直肠癌术前放化疗,评估质子束治疗中不同射野安排对肠道气体所致解剖不确定性的稳健性。采用笔束扫描计划,比较1野、2野、3野和5野设计在12个稳健性优化计划和60次计划评估中的表现。结果显示单后前野在直肠短轴扩张≥3 cm时靶区覆盖明显下降,应避免;2野(RPO/LPO)和3野(PA+侧野)均可考虑,RPO/LPO因降低积分剂量更受青睐。
要点
- 单后前野在直肠短轴扩张≥3 cm时V100%<90%,应避免使用。
- 2野RPO/LPO和3野PA+对穿侧野均可维持覆盖至5 cm扩张。
- 计划CT直肠扩张≥3 cm时强烈考虑重新模拟或减少肠道气体。
核心结论
- 直肠癌质子束治疗应避免单后前野,RPO/LPO和PA/对穿侧野均可考虑,RPO/LPO因降低积分剂量更受青睐。
- 计划CT直肠扩张≥3 cm时强烈考虑重新模拟或采取减少肠道气体的策略。
研究设计与样本
- 采用笔束扫描计划,设计1野PA、2野RPO/LPO、3野PA+对穿侧野、5野PA+RPO/LPO+对穿侧野四种射野安排。
- 创建12个稳健性优化计划,针对不同程度肠道气体扩张共进行60次计划评估。
主要发现
- 单PA野在直肠短轴扩张≥3 cm时出现靶区覆盖明显下降,V100%<90%。
- 其他射野设计在直肠扩张达5 cm时仍维持覆盖。
- 基于5 cm扩张直肠充气介质计划,1野、3野和5野在直肠收缩≤3 cm时V100%<90%,而2野维持覆盖至低至2 cm。
- 基于3 cm直肠扩张计划,2野和3野在直肠塌陷至低至1 cm时仍维持V100%>90%。
关键数值与推荐
- 靶区覆盖目标为临床靶区处方50 Gy,V100%≥90%为维持覆盖。
- 单PA野在直肠短轴扩张≥3 cm时V100%<90%。
- 2野和3野基于3 cm扩张计划在直肠塌陷至1 cm时V100%>90%。
临床怎么用
- 直肠癌质子束治疗避免使用单后前野。
- 优先考虑RPO/LPO双野安排以降低积分剂量并避免射束穿过髋部。
- 计划CT显示直肠扩张≥3 cm时,应重新模拟或采取措施减少肠道气体。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Preoperative chemoradiation represents the standard of care in patients with locally advanced rectal cancer. Robustness is often compromised in the setting of proton beam therapy owing to the sensitivity of proton particles to tissue heterogeneity, such as with intestinal gas. The ideal beam arrangement to mitigate the anatomic uncertainty caused by intestinal gas is not well defined. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We developed pencil beam scanning plans using (1) 1-beam posteroanterior (PA) plans, (2) 2-beam with right and left posterior oblique (RPO and LPO) plans, (3) 3-beam with PA and opposed lateral plans, and (4) 5-beam with PA, RPO, LPO, and opposed lateral plans. We created 12 plans with robustness optimization and ran a total of 60 plan evaluations for varying degrees of intestinal gas distension to evaluate which plans would maintain clinical goals to the greatest degree. RESULTS: A single PA beam resulted in considerable loss of target coverage to the clinical target volume prescribed 50 Gy (volume receiving 100% of the prescribed dose [V100%] < 90%) with rectal distension ≥3 cm in diameter in the short axis. In contrast, the other field designs maintained coverage with up to 5 cm of distension. On plans generated based on a 5-cm distended rectum with air medium, the 1-beam, 3-beam, and 5-beam arrangements resulted in loss of target coverage (V100% < 90%) with rectal contraction ≤3 cm, whereas the 2-beam arrangement maintained coverage to as low as 2 cm. On plans generated based on a 3-cm distension of the rectum, both the 2-beam and 3-beam arrangements maintained V100% > 90% even with collapsed rectum to as low as 1 cm, simulating a patient treatment scenario without any rectal gas. CONCLUSIONS: A single PA beam should be avoided when using proton beam therapy for rectal cancer. RPO/LPO and PA/opposed lateral arrangements may both be considered; RPO/LPO is favored to reduce integral dose and avoid beams traversing the hips. In patients for whom the plan CT has rectal distension of ≥3 cm, resimulation or strategies to reduce intestinal gas should be strongly considered.
引用
- Parzen JS, Zheng W, Li X, et al. Optimization of Field Design in the Treatment of Rectal Cancer with Intensity Modulated Proton Beam Radiation Therapy: How Many Fields Are Needed to Account for Rectal Distension Uncertainty? Adv Radiat Oncol. 2021. PMID: 34646968. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2021.100749
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。