基于深度学习的乳腺癌放疗自动勾画系统评估
本研究由两家机构的11位专家对10例保乳术后辅助放疗患者的9个危及器官进行手动勾画,并提供自动勾画供专家修正;分析110份手动轮廓、110份修正自动轮廓及10份自动轮廓,比较DSC与HD。结果显示自动勾画与专家手动勾画精度相似,修正自动勾画可减少医师间变异并大幅缩短时间。
要点
- 自动勾画与手动勾画的平均DSC相似(0.88 vs 0.90 vs 0.90)。
- 修正自动勾画减少医师间变异:DSC 0.89-0.90 vs 0.87-0.90。
- 9个OAR总平均时间由手动37分钟降至修正自动6分钟。
核心结论
- 自动勾画系统在危及器官勾画上表现与专家手动勾画相似,可提升乳腺癌放疗质量并减少医师间变异。
研究设计与样本
- 来自两家机构的11位专家对10例保乳术后辅助放疗患者的9个危及器官进行勾画,并提供自动勾画供修正。
- 共分析110份手动轮廓、110份修正自动轮廓及每种OAR的10份自动轮廓,以DSC和HD比较与最佳手动轮廓的一致性。
主要发现
- 手动轮廓、修正自动轮廓和自动轮廓的平均DSC值相似(0.88 vs 0.90 vs 0.90)。
- 基于DSC,自动轮廓在手动轮廓中排名第二;基于HD,自动轮廓排名第一。
- 修正自动轮廓的医师间变异较手动轮廓减小(DSC:0.89-0.90 vs 0.87-0.90;HD:4.3-5.8 mm vs 5.3-7.6 mm)。
- 手动勾画中乳腺轮廓变异最大,使用自动勾画系统后改善最显著。
- 9个OAR的总平均时间手动为37分钟,修正自动为6分钟;调查显示用户满意度良好。
临床怎么用
- 在临床实践中可采用自动勾画系统辅助乳腺癌放疗危及器官勾画,并经专家修正以提高一致性。
- 自动勾画可显著缩短勾画时间并减少医师间变异,尤其对乳腺轮廓变异改善明显。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To study the performance of a proposed deep learning-based autocontouring system in delineating organs at risk (OARs) in breast radiotherapy with a group of experts. METHODS: Eleven experts from two institutions delineated nine OARs in 10 cases of adjuvant radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery. Autocontours were then provided to the experts for correction. Overall, 110 manual contours, 110 corrected autocontours, and 10 autocontours of each type of OAR were analyzed. The Dice similarity coefficient (DSC) and Hausdorff distance (HD) were used to compare the degree of agreement between the best manual contour (chosen by an independent expert committee) and each autocontour, corrected autocontour, and manual contour. Higher DSCs and lower HDs indicated a better geometric overlap. The amount of time reduction using the autocontouring system was examined. User satisfaction was evaluated using a survey. RESULTS: Manual contours, corrected autocontours, and autocontours had a similar accuracy in the average DSC value (0.88 vs. 0.90 vs. 0.90). The accuracy of autocontours ranked the second place, based on DSCs, and the first place, based on HDs among the manual contours. Interphysician variations among the experts were reduced in corrected autocontours, compared to variations in manual contours (DSC: 0.89-0.90 vs. 0.87-0.90; HD: 4.3-5.8 mm vs. 5.3-7.6 mm). Among the manual delineations, the breast contours had the largest variations, which improved most significantly with the autocontouring system. The total mean times for nine OARs were 37 min for manual contours and 6 min for corrected autocontours. The results of the survey revealed good user satisfaction. CONCLUSIONS: The autocontouring system had a similar performance in OARs as that of the experts' manual contouring. This system can be valuable in improving the quality of breast radiotherapy and reducing interphysician variability in clinical practice.
引用
- Byun HK, Chang JS, Choi MS, et al. Evaluation of deep learning-based autosegmentation in breast cancer radiotherapy. Radiat Oncol. 2021. PMID: 34649569. doi:10.1186/s13014-021-01923-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。