自适应头颈放疗中半自动分割方法的剂量与NTCP评估
本研究在15例重复CT上比较人工分割、形变配准和深度学习轮廓三种方法对15个头颈危及器官的分割效果,并以三位观察者平均Dmean和NTCP为金标准计算绝对偏差。结果显示腮腺人工分割Dmean偏差最低,半自动分割策略使90%病例的NTCP预测偏差在1.5%以内。
要点
- 腮腺人工分割的Dmean平均绝对偏差为1.40 Gy,低于DIR和DLC。
- DLC在中咽缩肌的Dmean偏差最高,达5.13 Gy。
- 半自动分割策略下90%病例的NTCP预测偏差为1.50%。
核心结论
- 自适应头颈放疗中腮腺人工分割对准确解读平均剂量和NTCP仍是必要的。
- 提出的半自动分割方法可使90%病例的NTCP预测精度在1.5%以内。
研究设计与样本
- 对15例重复CT上的15个危及器官进行三位观察者人工分割、形变配准轮廓传播和深度学习轮廓分割。
- 以三位观察者平均Dmean和NTCP预测为金标准,计算Dmean和NTCP预测的绝对偏差。
主要发现
- 腮腺人工分割的平均|ΔDmean|为1.40 Gy,低于DIR的3.64 Gy(p < 0.001)和DLC的3.72 Gy(p < 0.001)。
- DLC在中咽缩肌的|ΔDmean|最高,为5.13 Gy(p = 0.01)。
- DIR在环咽入口的|ΔDmean|次高,为2.85 Gy(p = 0.01)。
- DIR、DLC、HS和SAS的90百分位|ΔNTCP|分别为2.19%、2.24%、1.10%和1.50%。
关键数值与推荐
- 半自动分割对腮腺采用人工分割、对中咽缩肌采用DIR、对其他所有危及器官采用DLC。
- SAS的90百分位|ΔNTCP|为1.50%。
临床怎么用
- 自适应头颈放疗中腮腺应保留人工分割以确保平均剂量和NTCP评估准确。
- 其余危及器官可采用半自动分割策略,在90%病例中NTCP预测偏差不超过1.5%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Accurate segmentation of organs-at-risk (OARs) is crucial but tedious and time-consuming in adaptive radiotherapy (ART). The purpose of this work was to automate head and neck OAR-segmentation on repeat CT (rCT) by an optimal combination of human and auto-segmentation for accurate prediction of Normal Tissue Complication Probability (NTCP). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Human segmentation (HS) of 3 observers, deformable image registration (DIR) based contour propagation and deep learning contouring (DLC) were carried out to segment 15 OARs on 15 rCTs. The original treatment plan was re-calculated on rCT to obtain mean dose (Dmean) and consequent NTCP-predictions. The average Dmean and NTCP-predictions of the three observers were referred to as the gold standard to calculate the absolute difference of Dmean and NTCP-predictions (|ΔDmean| and |ΔNTCP|). RESULTS: The average |ΔDmean| of parotid glands in HS was 1.40 Gy, lower than that obtained with DIR and DLC (3.64 Gy, p < 0.001 and 3.72 Gy, p < 0.001, respectively). DLC showed the highest |ΔDmean| in middle Pharyngeal Constrictor Muscle (PCM) (5.13 Gy, p = 0.01). DIR showed second highest |ΔDmean| in the cricopharyngeal inlet (2.85 Gy, p = 0.01). The semi auto-segmentation (SAS) adopted HS, DIR and DLC for segmentation of parotid glands, PCM and all other OARs, respectively. The 90th percentile |ΔNTCP|was 2.19%, 2.24%, 1.10% and 1.50% for DIR, DLC, HS and SAS respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Human segmentation of the parotid glands remains necessary for accurate interpretation of mean dose and NTCP during ART. Proposed semi auto-segmentation allows NTCP-predictions within 1.5% accuracy for 90% of the cases.
引用
- Gan Y, Langendijk JA, Oldehinkel E, et al. A novel semi auto-segmentation method for accurate dose and NTCP evaluation in adaptive head and neck radiotherapy. Radiother Oncol. 2021. PMID: 34597740. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2021.09.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。