深吸气屏气与自由呼吸CT扫描中心脏亚结构自动分割的独立多图谱验证
该研究为乳腺癌放疗心脏并发症NTCP模型开发,验证了针对深吸气屏气(DIBH)和自由呼吸(FB)CT扫描分别构建的多图谱自动分割(MABAS)心脏结构的准确性。结果显示,FB和DIBH图谱的Dice系数均≥0.8,平均轮廓距离≤2 mm且小于CT层厚,在相关剂量水平剂量体积参数无显著差异;DIBH图谱准确性至少与手动勾画观察者间变异相似,心室更好;交叉验证显示呼吸技术间性能下降。结论认为多图谱准确性至少与观察者间勾画变异相似,且准确性依赖呼吸技术,分别使用图谱可能获益。
要点
- FB和DIBH图谱自动分割心脏结构Dice≥0.8,平均轮廓距离≤2 mm且小于CT层厚。
- DIBH图谱准确性至少与手动勾画观察者间变异相似,心室分割更优。
- 跨呼吸技术交叉验证显示MABAS性能下降,提示需分别构建图谱。
核心结论
- 多图谱自动分割准确性至少与观察者间勾画变异相似。
- 准确性依赖呼吸技术,分别使用DIBH和FB图谱可能提升图谱性能。
研究设计与样本
- 乳腺癌患者DIBH扫描10例和FB扫描20例用于构建独立多图谱,包含全心脏、心房和心室的专家 panel 勾画。
- 在独立数据集(DIBH和FB各10例)中以专家勾画验证图谱生成轮廓准确性,并评估FB图谱在DIBH患者及反之的交叉验证。
主要发现
- 所有结构FB和DIBH图谱与各自参考轮廓的Dice系数≥0.8,平均轮廓距离≤2 mm且小于CT层厚。
- 在WH、LV和RV的相关剂量水平剂量体积参数无显著差异。
- DIBH图谱准确性至少与手动勾画观察者间变异相似,心室分割优于观察者间变异。
- 呼吸技术间交叉验证显示MABAS性能下降。
关键数值与推荐
- FB和DIBH图谱Dice系数≥0.8,平均轮廓距离≤2 mm且小于CT层厚。
- WH、LV和RV在相关剂量水平剂量体积参数无显著差异。
- DIBH图谱准确性至少与观察者间变异相似,心室分割优于观察者间变异。
临床怎么用
- 乳腺癌放疗计划中可考虑使用与呼吸技术匹配的多图谱自动分割心脏亚结构。
- DIBH和FB扫描应分别使用对应图谱,避免跨呼吸技术交叉使用导致性能下降。
局限性
- 样本量较小,DIBH和FB各10例用于验证。
- 研究仅针对乳腺癌患者,未涉及其他肿瘤类型。
- 未报告交叉验证性能下降的具体数值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Developing NTCP-models for cardiac complications after breast cancer (BC) radiotherapy requires cardiac dose-volume parameters for many patients. These can be obtained by using multi-atlas based automatic segmentation (MABAS) of cardiac structures in planning CT scans. We investigated the relevance of separate multi-atlases for deep inspiration breath hold (DIBH) and free breathing (FB) CT scans. MATERIALS AND METHODS: BC patients scanned in DIBH (n = 10) and in FB (n = 20) were selected to create separate multi-atlases consisting of expert panel delineations of the whole heart, atria and ventricles. The accuracy of atlas-generated contours was validated with expert delineations in independent datasets (n = 10 for DIBH and FB) and reported as Dice coefficients, contour distances and dose-volume differences in relation to interobserver variability of manual contours. Dependency of MABAS contouring accuracy on breathing technique was assessed by validation of a FB atlas in DIBH patients and vice versa (cross-validation). RESULTS: For all structures the FB and DIBH atlases resulted in Dice coefficients with their respective reference contours ≥ 0.8 and average contour distances ≤ 2 mm smaller than slice thickness of (CTs). No significant differences were found for dose-volume parameters in volumes receiving relevant dose levels (WH, LV and RV). Accuracy of the DIBH atlas was at least similar to, and for the ventricles better than, the interobserver variation in manual delineation. Cross-validation between breathing techniques showed a reduced MABAS performance. CONCLUSION: Multi-atlas accuracy was at least similar to interobserver delineation variation. Separate atlases for scans made in DIBH and FB could benefit atlas performance because accuracy depends on breathing technique.
引用
- Spoor DS, Sijtsema NM, van den Bogaard VAB, et al. Validation of separate multi-atlases for auto segmentation of cardiac substructures in CT-scans acquired in deep inspiration breath hold and free breathing. Radiother Oncol. 2021. PMID: 34343547. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2021.07.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。