危及器官轮廓变异对NSCLC自动治疗计划的影响
结果显示自动轮廓变异所致剂量差异与观察者内轮廓变异相当或更低,心脏与PTV重叠时建议纠正Dmean勾画误差,Dmax参数在距PTV较近时建议检查轮廓。
要点
- 自动轮廓变异所致剂量差异与观察者内变异相当或更低
- 心脏与PTV重叠时建议纠正Dmean勾画误差
- Dmax参数在距PTV小于5 cm时建议检查轮廓
核心结论
- 自动轮廓变异所致剂量差异与观察者内轮廓变异量级相当或更低。
- 心脏Dmean在心脏与PTV重叠时建议纠正勾画误差。
- Dmax参数在距PTV小于5 cm时建议检查轮廓。
- 肺部仅需调整明显的大误差。
研究设计与样本
- 为每套轮廓生成自动治疗计划。
- 使用胸部危及器官的DVH参数评估观察者内轮廓变异及轮廓变异对计划评估与生成的影响。
主要发现
- 观察者内轮廓变异所致剂量效应最高为心脏Dmax(3.4 ± 6.8 Gy),最低为全肺减GTV Dmean(0.3 ± 0.4 Gy)。
- 轮廓变异对治疗计划评估的影响最高为心脏Dmax(6.0 ± 13.4 Gy)和食管Dmax(8.7 ± 17.2 Gy)。
- 基于参考手动轮廓评估时,各治疗计划的剂量差异平均低于1 Gy/1%。
- 心脏Dmean在心脏与PTV重叠时剂量差异更高(中位数0.2 Gy,95% 1.7 Gy),无PTV重叠时(中位数0 Gy,95% 0.5 Gy)。
- Dmax参数在距PTV 0-1 cm时剂量差异最大(中位数1.5 Gy,95% 4.7 Gy)。
关键数值与推荐
- 心脏与PTV重叠时,建议纠正心脏Dmean的勾画误差。
- Dmax参数在距PTV小于5 cm时,建议检查轮廓。
- 肺部仅需调整明显的大误差。
临床怎么用
- 在NSCLC自动轮廓流程中,心脏与PTV重叠时应对心脏Dmean勾画误差进行纠正。
- 对Dmax参数,若危及器官距PTV小于5 cm应检查轮廓。
- 肺部轮廓仅需调整明显大误差,无需过度修正。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Quality of automatic contouring is generally assessed by comparison with manual delineations, but the effect of contour differences on the resulting dose distribution remains unknown. This study evaluated dosimetric differences between treatment plans optimized using various organ-at-risk (OAR) contouring methods. MATERIALS AND METHODS: OARs of twenty lung cancer patients were manually and automatically contoured, after which user-adjustments were made. For each contour set, an automated treatment plan was generated. The dosimetric effect of intra-observer contour variation and the influence of contour variations on treatment plan evaluation and generation were studied using dose-volume histogram (DVH)-parameters for thoracic OARs. RESULTS: Dosimetric effect of intra-observer contour variability was highest for Heart Dmax (3.4 ± 6.8 Gy) and lowest for Lungs-GTV Dmean (0.3 ± 0.4 Gy). The effect of contour variation on treatment plan evaluation was highest for Heart Dmax (6.0 ± 13.4 Gy) and Esophagus Dmax (8.7 ± 17.2 Gy). Dose differences for the various treatment plans, evaluated on the reference (manual) contour, were on average below 1 Gy/1%. For Heart Dmean, higher dose differences were found for overlap with PTV (median 0.2 Gy, 95% 1.7 Gy) vs. no PTV overlap (median 0 Gy, 95% 0.5 Gy). For Dmax-parameters, largest dose difference was found between 0-1 cm distance to PTV (median 1.5 Gy, 95% 4.7 Gy). CONCLUSION: Dose differences arising from automatic contour variations were of the same magnitude or lower than intra-observer contour variability. For Heart Dmean, we recommend delineation errors to be corrected when the heart overlaps with the PTV. For Dmax-parameters, we recommend checking contours if the distance is close to PTV (<5 cm). For the lungs, only obvious large errors need to be adjusted.
引用
- Vaassen F, Hazelaar C, Canters R, et al. The impact of organ-at-risk contour variations on automatically generated treatment plans for NSCLC. Radiother Oncol. 2021. PMID: 34461185. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2021.08.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。