文献速递放疗物理与技术

性别与资历能否预测期刊审稿人评论质量?

Can Sex and Seniority Predict the Quality of a Journal Reviewer's Manuscript Critique?
PubMed 文献 · Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys · 2021-05-24

该研究评估了《国际放射肿瘤学·生物学·物理学杂志》审稿人的及时性和审稿质量是否与性别和资历相关。研究分析了2011至2014年间受邀审稿的3962人,重点比较了1657名至少受邀3次的审稿人,并对124名美国审稿人使用审稿质量工具(RQI)进行子集分析。结果显示男女审稿人在及时性和质量上无显著差异,但女性受邀审稿频率较低。

要点

  • 男女审稿人在审稿及时性和质量上无显著差异。
  • 审稿质量与性别、h指数或首次认证年份无关。
  • 女性受邀审稿频率较低,可能与放射肿瘤学领域女性代表不足有关。

核心结论

  • 女性和男性审稿人的审稿质量相同,与资历和h指数无关,但女性受邀审稿频率较低。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究分析了2011至2014年IJROBP editorial office提供的3962名受邀审稿人数据,重点比较1657名至少受邀3次的审稿人的审稿及时性和评分。
  • 子集分析对124名返回「重大修改」决定的美国审稿人使用审稿质量工具(RQI)进行评分。
  • 使用比值比和t检验比较平均RQI评分及可能与质量相关的因素,特别是Hirsch指数(h指数)和首次认证年份。

主要发现

  • 在1657名审稿人中,男性1245名(75.1%),女性412名(24.9%)。
  • 男女在回应邀请的时间上无统计学显著差异。
  • 基于性别的及时性或审稿提醒无统计学显著差异。
  • 子集分析显示审稿质量(RQI评分)基于审稿人性别、h指数或首次认证年份无差异。

临床怎么用

  • 审稿人性别和资历不应作为评估审稿质量的依据。
  • 需关注女性在放射肿瘤学学术出版中代表不足的问题。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: To evaluate reviewers' timeliness and review quality for the International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics (IJROBP) by sex and seniority. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The IJROBP editorial office provided data on 3962 individuals invited to review manuscripts from 2011 through 2014. We identified 1657 reviewers who had been invited to provide a review on at least 3 occasions during the study period and compared review timeliness and scoring between male and female reviewers. We confirmed the reviewers' sex after having unblinded their names based on our personal acquaintance with them and via an Internet search on their department websites. We then did a subset analysis of 124 US-based reviewers who had returned a "major revision" decision. We used the Review Quality Instrument (RQI) to rate their reviews. We used odds ratios and t tests to look for differences in mean RQI scores and factors that might be associated with quality-in particular, Hirsch indices (h indices) and year of first certification. RESULTS: Of the 1657 reviewers of interest, 1245 (75.1%) were men and 412 (24.9%) were women. We found no statistically significant differences between men and women in the time to respond to invitations. There were no statistically significant differences in timeliness or review reminders based on sex. Our subset analysis showed no difference in quality (RQI scores) based on the reviewers' sex, h index, or year of first certification. CONCLUSIONS: Women and men render reviews of equal quality regardless of seniority and h index, yet women have been invited less frequently to review. This is likely because of the underrepresentation of women in radiation oncology. A more balanced academic population is needed to address this continuing disparity of women's representation in academic publishing.

来源:Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jamorabo DS, Deek MP, Yom SS, et al. Can Sex and Seniority Predict the Quality of a Journal Reviewer's Manuscript Critique? Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2021. PMID: 34044095. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2021.05.111

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。