食管癌笔束扫描质子治疗的运动稳健性策略
该研究纳入26例曾接受IMRT的食管癌患者,基于4D-CT为每例设计7种质子笔束扫描计划,比较不同射野配置与优化策略对CTV覆盖的影响。结果显示,采用双后野并同时对PTV覆盖和CTV稳健优化的方案最稳健,而仅用侧后野加CTV稳健优化但不要求PTV覆盖的方案最差;呼吸与解剖变化联合作用下,稳健方案仍优于IMRT。
要点
- 双后野联合PTV覆盖与CTV稳健优化的质子方案对呼吸和解剖变化最稳健。
- 仅用侧后野加CTV稳健优化而不要求PTV覆盖时,10例出现靶区欠量。
- 单次分次间交互效应显著降低V95%CTV,但10次分次后一般被平均化。
核心结论
- 使用后野角度的笔束扫描质子治疗对解剖变化和呼吸运动的稳健性优于IMRT。
- 呼吸效应在存在解剖变化时被增强,单次分次交互效应在10次分次后被平均化。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究纳入26例既往接受IMRT治疗的食管癌患者,基于4D-CT为每例创建7种不同射野配置和优化策略的质子笔束扫描计划。
- 通过计算相位剂量、4D剂量和包含交互效应的4D动态剂量评估呼吸影响,并在4D-CT监测扫描的所有相位上重算计划以评估解剖变化影响。
主要发现
- 最稳健的质子方案为双后野同时要求PTV覆盖和CTV稳健优化(2PAPTVRO),仅1例在计划CT的1个或多个相位出现V95%CTV<97%。
- 最不稳健的质子方案为侧后野加CTV稳健优化但不要求PTV覆盖(2LPRO),10例出现靶区欠量;IMRT有2例出现欠量。
- 单次分次照射时交互效应显著降低V95%CTV,但10次分次后一般被平均化;仅稳健优化计划的交互效应显著大于稳健优化联合PTV覆盖的计划。
- 在4D-CT监测扫描上联合解剖变化与呼吸效应后,V95%CTV<97%的患者数分别为2PAPTVRO组3例、2LPRO组16例、IMRT组8例。
临床怎么用
- 食管癌质子笔束扫描治疗宜优先采用后野角度,并同时实施PTV覆盖与CTV稳健优化以提高运动稳健性。
- 评估质子计划稳健性时需综合考虑呼吸、解剖变化及分次间交互效应,单次分次结果可能高估交互效应影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Proton therapy of esophageal cancer is superior to photon radiation therapy in terms of normal tissue sparing. However, respiratory motion and anatomical changes may compromise target dose coverage owing to density changes, geometric misses, and interplay effects. Here we investigate the combined effect on clinical target volume (CTV) coverage and compare proton therapy with intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT). METHODS AND MATERIALS: This study includes 26 patients with esophageal cancer previously treated with IMRT planned on 4-dimensional computed tomography (4D-CT). For each patient, 7 proton pencil beam scanning (PBS) plans were created with different field configurations and optimization strategies. The effect of respiration was investigated by calculating the phase doses, 4D dose, and 4D dynamic dose (including interplay effects). The effect of anatomical changes was investigated by recalculating all plans on all phases of a 4D-CT surveillance scan. RESULTS: The most robust PBS plans were achieved using 2 posterior beams requiring coverage of planning target volume (PTV) and simultaneously using robust optimization (RO) of CTV (2PAPTVRO), resulting in only 1 patient showing V95%CTV <97% in 1 or more phases of the planning CT. For the least robust PBS plans obtained using lateral + posterior beams and CTV-RO, but not requiring PTV coverage (2LPRO), 10 patients showed underdosage. For IMRT, 2 patients showed underdosage. Interplay effects reduced V95%CTV significantly when delivering only 1 fraction, but the effects generally averaged out after 10 fractions. The effect of interplay was significantly larger for RO-only plans compared with plans optimized with RO combined with PTV coverage. Combining the effect of anatomical changes and respiration on the 4D-CT surveillance scan resulted in V95%CTV <97% for 3 2PAPTVRO, 16 2LPRO, and 8 IMRT patients. CONCLUSIONS: PBS using posterior beam angles was more robust to anatomical changes and respiration than IMRT. The effect of respiration was enhanced when anatomical changes were present. Single fraction interplay effects deteriorated the dose distribution but were averaged out after 10 fractions.
引用
- Møller DS, Poulsen PR, Hagner A, et al. Strategies for Motion Robust Proton Therapy With Pencil Beam Scanning for Esophageal Cancer. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2021. PMID: 33974885. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2021.04.040
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。