指南与共识头颈部肿瘤放疗

头颈部鳞癌术后放疗中皮瓣管理的国际共识建议

Recommendations for postoperative radiotherapy in head & neck squamous cell carcinoma in the presence of flaps: A GORTEC internationally-reviewed HNCIG-endorsed consensus.
指南 / 共识 · Radiother Oncol · 2021-05-11

GORTEC与HNCIG组织放疗、内科和外科肿瘤专家,围绕皮瓣患者术后放疗的59个议题构建国际共识,涵盖影像识别、肿瘤复发风险与靶区定义、功能损伤及皮瓣规避可行性四个领域;仅功能损伤领域达成共识(73.3%),肿瘤扩散模式领域共识率仅11.1%,存在显著知识缺口。

要点

  • 仅功能损伤领域达成国际共识(中位评分≥7/9),共识率73.3%。
  • 皮瓣规避被推荐用于减少骨皮瓣放射性骨坏死,但不用于减少软组织毒性。
  • 专家对皮瓣是否易发生肿瘤播散存在分歧,肿瘤扩散模式共识率仅11.1%。

核心结论

  • 形成了GORTEC与HNCIG背书的头颈部放疗中皮瓣管理国际建议,但肿瘤扩散模式等关键领域知识缺口阻碍进一步共识。

研究设计与样本

  • 由GORTEC及国际HNCIG组织的放疗、内科和外科肿瘤专家参与的共识构建方法,覆盖四个领域共59个议题。

主要发现

  • 功能损伤领域国际共识率73.3%,皮瓣规避共识率55.6%,皮瓣定义共识率41.2%,肿瘤扩散模式共识率11.1%。
  • 放射性皮瓣纤维化或萎缩及其功能影响被广泛认可,而皮瓣坏死未被认可,提示前者需剂量-体积适配。
  • 皮瓣规避被推荐用于减少骨皮瓣放射性骨坏死,但不用于减少软组织毒性。
  • 识别和靶向原生组织与皮瓣间高危交界区需CT计划、标记物和准确手术报告,获广泛认可。
  • 专家对皮瓣是否易发生肿瘤播散看法不一,国际评审参与者对11个条目的评分存在差异。

关键数值与推荐

  • 国际共识定义为中位评分≥7/9,仅功能损伤领域达到该标准(73.3%)。
  • 皮瓣规避推荐用于减少骨皮瓣放射性骨坏死,不推荐用于减少软组织毒性。

临床怎么用

  • 术后放疗规划中应关注放射性皮瓣纤维化或萎缩的功能影响并考虑剂量-体积适配。
  • 对骨皮瓣可考虑规避以降低放射性骨坏死风险,但不以降低软组织毒性为目的。
  • 应利用CT计划、标记物和准确手术报告识别并靶向原生组织与皮瓣间高危交界区。

局限性

  • 肿瘤扩散模式等领域共识率低(11.1%),存在显著知识缺口。
  • 专家对皮瓣是否易发生肿瘤播散存在分歧,国际评审参与者对11个条目评分不一致。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Head and neck reconstructive surgery using a flap is increasingly common. Best practices and outcomes for postoperative radiotherapy (poRT) with flaps have not been specified. We aimed to provide consensus recommendations to assist clinical decision-making highlighting areas of uncertainty in the presence of flaps. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Radiation, medical, and surgical oncologists were assembled from GORTEC and internationally with the Head and Neck Cancer International Group (HNCIG). The consensus-building approach covered 59 topics across four domains: (1) identification of postoperative tissue changes on imaging for flap delineation, (2) understanding of tumor relapse risks and target volume definitions, (3) functional radiation-induced deterioration, (4) feasibility of flap avoidance. RESULTS: Across the 4 domains, international consensus (median score ≥ 7/9) was achieved only for functional deterioration (73.3%); other consensus rates were 55.6% for poRT avoidance of flap structures, 41.2% for flap definition and 11.1% for tumor spread patterns. Radiation-induced flap fibrosis or atrophy and their functional impact was well recognized while flap necrosis was not, suggesting dose-volume adaptation for the former. Flap avoidance was recommended to minimize bone flap osteoradionecrosis but not soft-tissue toxicity. The need for identification (CT planning, fiducials, accurate operative report) and targeting of the junction area at risk between native tissues and flap was well recognized. Experts variably considered flaps as prone to tumor dissemination or not. Discrepancies in rating of 11 items among international reviewing participants are shown. CONCLUSION: International GORTEC and HNCIG-endorsed recommendations were generated for the management of flaps in head and neck radiotherapy. Considerable knowledge gaps hinder further consensus, in particular with respect to tumor spread patterns.

来源:Radiother Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Carsuzaa F, Lapeyre M, Gregoire V, et al. Recommendations for postoperative radiotherapy in head & neck squamous cell carcinoma in the presence of flaps: A GORTEC internationally-reviewed HNCIG-endorsed consensus. Radiother Oncol. 2021. PMID: 33984351. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2021.04.026

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。