文献速递泌尿生殖与妇科肿瘤放疗放疗物理与技术

儿童肾肿瘤高适形侧腹靶区定义的国际多中心勾画差异研究

Inter-clinician delineation variation for a new highly-conformal flank target volume in children with renal tumors: A SIOP-Renal Tumor Study Group international multicenter exercise.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Transl Radiat Oncol · 2021-03-11

SIOP-RTSG 新制定的儿童肾肿瘤高适形侧腹靶区定义在国际多中心勾画练习中显示,参与者与参考靶区之间的 CTV 中位 Dice 相似系数为 0.55,且随病例顺序未见改善(P=0.15)。标准化评审发现多数参与者在病例 5–6 存在不可接受的勾画变异,提示该靶区定义在大范围推广前需额外培训和集中治前审核。

要点

  • 新侧腹靶区定义下 CTV 中位 DSCref/part 仅 0.55,勾画几何变异明显。
  • 病例 5–6 中多数参与者出现不可接受的 CTV 低估变异。
  • 建议实施前开展额外培训与集中治前审核。

核心结论

  • 新共识的高适形术后侧腹靶区定义在国际多中心勾画中导致参与者间几何变异。
  • 标准化评审显示多数参与者存在不可接受的勾画变异,强烈提示需额外培训和集中治前审核。

研究设计与样本

  • SIOP-RTSG 将 6 例儿童肾癌病例转交来自 7 个欧洲国家的 10 名放射肿瘤科医生勾画。
  • 参与者在两个测试阶段(病例 1–2 和 3–4)勾画术前和术后 GTV 及 CTV,随后进行指南细化和质量保证阶段(病例 5–6)。
  • 由 3 名经验丰富的放射肿瘤科医生建立参考靶区,计算每个病例的 Dice 相似系数(DSCref/part)。
  • 病例 5–6 的勾画由 4 名独立评审者使用 18 项标准化标准分级为「符合方案」(0–4 mm)、「轻微偏差」(5–9 mm)或「重大偏差」(≥10 mm)。
  • 导致 CTVref 低估的重大偏差被视为不可接受变异。

主要发现

  • 共完成 57/60 套勾画。
  • CTV 的中位 DSCref/part 为 0.55,序贯病例后未见改善(病例 3–4 与病例 5–6 比较:P=0.15)。
  • 病例 5–6 中,GTVpre、GTVpost、CTV-T 和 CTV-N 分别有 5/18、12/17、18/18 和 4/9 套收集的勾画存在重大偏差。
  • 病例 5 中 7/9 参与者、病例 6 中 6/9 参与者存在不可接受的 CTVref 变异。

关键数值与推荐

  • 重大偏差定义为与勾画指南偏差 ≥10 mm,轻微偏差为 5–9 mm,符合方案为 0–4 mm。
  • 不可接受变异定义为导致 CTVref 低估的重大偏差。
  • CTV 中位 DSCref/part 为 0.55(无改善,病例 3–4 与 5–6 比较 P=0.15)。

临床怎么用

  • 在较大规模实施该高适形侧腹靶区勾画方法前,应开展额外培训。
  • 建议对该靶区定义实施集中治前审核。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Recently, the SIOP-RTSG developed a highly-conformal flank target volume definition for children with renal tumors. The aims of this study were to evaluate the inter-clinician delineation variation of this new target volume definition in an international multicenter setting and to explore the necessity of quality assurance. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Six pediatric renal cancer cases were transferred to ten radiation oncologists from seven European countries ('participants'). These participants delineated the pre- and postoperative Gross Tumor Volume (GTVpre/post), and Clinical Target Volume (CTV) during two test phases (case 1-2 and 3-4), followed by guideline refinement and a quality assurance phase (case 5-6). Reference target volumes (TVref) were established by three experienced radiation oncologists. The Dice Similarity Coefficient between the reference and participants (DSCref/part) was calculated per case. Delineations of case 5-6 were graded by four independent reviewers as 'per protocol' (0-4 mm), 'minor deviation' (5-9 mm) or 'major deviation' (≥10 mm) from the delineation guideline using 18 standardized criteria. Also, a major deviation resulting in underestimation of the CTVref was regarded as an unacceptable variation. RESULTS: A total of 57/60 delineation sets were completed. The median DSCref/part for the CTV was 0.55 without improvement after sequential cases (case 3-4 vs. case 5-6: p = 0.15). For case 5-6, a major deviation was found for 5/18, 12/17, 18/18 and 4/9 collected delineations of the GTVpre, GTVpost, CTV-T and CTV-N, respectively. An unacceptable variation from the CTVref was found for 7/9 participants for case 5 and 6/9 participants for case 6. CONCLUSION: This international multicenter delineation exercise demonstrates that the new consensus for highly-conformal postoperative flank target volume delineation leads to geometrical variation among participants. Moreover, standardized review showed an unacceptable delineation variation in the majority of the participants. These findings strongly suggest the need for additional training and centralized pre-treatment review when this target volume delineation approach is implemented on a larger scale.

来源:Clin Transl Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mul J, Melchior P, Seravalli E, et al. Inter-clinician delineation variation for a new highly-conformal flank target volume in children with renal tumors: A SIOP-Renal Tumor Study Group international multicenter exercise. Clin Transl Radiat Oncol. 2021. PMID: 33796796. doi:10.1016/j.ctro.2021.03.001

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。