加拿大与美国老年乳腺癌患者乳房X线监测:我们是否在明智选择?
该研究比较了美国Medicare按服务付费项目与加拿大安大略省在老年乳腺癌患者保乳术后放疗后乳房X线监测中低价值检查的比例。结果显示,美国短期(放疗后6个月内)乳房X线比例高于安大略(55.9% vs 38.0%),高频(放疗后12个月内>1次)比例也更高(39.6% vs 7.9%)。两国放疗科医生开具低价值乳房X线的比例最高。
要点
- 美国短期乳房X线比例55.9%,安大略38.0%,差异显著。
- 美国高频乳房X线比例39.6%,安大略仅7.9%。
- 两国放疗科医生开具低价值乳房X线的比例最高。
核心结论
- 尽管有指南和Choosing Wisely推荐,美国和安大略均存在较高的短期乳房X线监测率,美国还存在较高的高频乳房X线监测率。
- 需要进一步国际努力以减少低价值乳房X线检查。
研究设计与样本
- 比较美国Medicare按服务付费项目和加拿大安大略省的回顾性队列研究。
- 纳入≥65岁、接受保乳治疗且随访至少24个月的乳腺癌女性(美国n=19,715;安大略n=6,479)。
主要发现
- 美国短期乳房X线比例为55.9%,安大略为38.0%(P < .001)。
- 美国高频乳房X线比例为39.6%,安大略为7.9%(P < .001)。
- 安大略短期乳房X线与年轻年龄(42% ≥85岁 vs 58% <74岁,P < .001)和化疗(69% vs 51%,P < .001)相关。
- 美国短期乳房X线与年龄、较早诊断年份、分期、化疗、农村居住和学术中心治疗相关。
- 两国高频乳房X线均与化疗相关(安大略13% vs 7%,P < .001;美国69% vs 51%,P = .02),美国还与年轻年龄、较早诊断年份、分期和非学术中心治疗相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 低价值乳房X线定义为短期(放疗后6个月内)或高频(放疗后12个月内>1次)。
临床怎么用
- 放疗科医生应关注并减少低价值乳房X线监测,遵循指南推荐。
- 两国需加强Choosing Wisely等举措以减少低价值乳房X线检查。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Guidelines on mammographic surveillance after breast cancer treatment have been disseminated internationally and incorporated into Choosing Wisely recommendations to reduce low-value care. However, adherence within different countries before their publication is unknown. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Low-value mammography, defined as "short-interval" (within 6 months of radiation) or "high-frequency" (>1 within 12 months of radiation), was compared in Medicare fee-for-service in the United States and Ontario, Canada. Women ≥65 years diagnosed with breast cancer who underwent breast-conserving therapy with a minimum of 24 months of follow-up were included (n = 19,715 United States; 6479 Ontario). Secondary outcomes were patient and physician characteristics associated with discordance. RESULTS: Short-interval mammography was higher in the United States than in Ontario (55.9% vs 38.0%, P < .001), as was high-frequency (39.6% vs 7.9%, P < .001). In Ontario, younger age (42% ≥85 vs 58% <74 years, P < .001) and chemotherapy (69% vs 51%, P < .001) were associated with short-interval mammography; in the United States, age, earlier diagnosis year, stage, chemotherapy, rurality, and academic center treatment were associated with greater use. Chemotherapy was associated with high-frequency mammography in both countries (13% vs 7% in Ontario, P < .001; 69% vs 51% in United States, P = .02); younger age, earlier diagnosis year, stage, and nonacademic center treatment were associated in the United States. In both countries, radiation oncologists had the highest proportion of providers ordering low-value mammograms. CONCLUSIONS: Despite significant evidence guiding surveillance mammography recommendations, there are high rates of short-interval mammography in both the United States and Ontario, and high rates of high-frequency mammography in the United States. Further international efforts, such as Choosing Wisely, are needed to reduce low-value mammography.
引用
- Rodin D, Glicksman RM, Clark K, et al. Mammographic Surveillance in Older Women With Breast Cancer in Canada and the United States: Are We Choosing Wisely? Pract Radiat Oncol. 2021. PMID: 33753302. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2021.03.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。