文献速递放疗物理与技术

基于真值变形矢量场的多解剖部位形变配准基准测试

Benchmarking of Deformable Image Registration for Multiple Anatomic Sites Using Digital Data Sets With Ground-Truth Deformation Vector Fields.
PubMed 文献 · Pract Radiat Oncol · 2021-03-17

该研究利用基于3例匿名患者CT(头颈、胸腹、盆腔)生成的9对数字数据集,评估三种商用系统的形变配准(DIR)算法精度,并分析DVF误差与轮廓指标的相关性。结果显示DVF误差随形变强度增加,脑、肝、左肺、膀胱误差较大;多数轮廓指标与DVF误差无相关性。

要点

  • DVF误差随形变强度增加,脑、肝、左肺、膀胱在3个系统中均出现较大误差。
  • 多数基于轮廓的指标与DVF误差无相关性,良好轮廓传播不直接代表剂量形变准确。
  • DVF误差容差值应因解剖部位、形变强度、器官大小等因素而异。

核心结论

  • 多数基于轮廓的指标与DVF误差无相关性,良好轮廓传播不直接表明轮廓内剂量形变和累加准确。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于3例匿名患者CT(头颈、胸腹、盆腔)通过轮廓控制形变生成9对数字数据集,每部位设低、中、高形变强度。
  • 图像对及轮廓导入MIM-Maestro、Raystation和Velocity系统进行DIR和轮廓传播,与真值数据比较。

主要发现

  • DVF误差随形变强度增加而增大。
  • 食管、气管、左右股骨和尿道在所有DIR算法中表现良好(平均和最大DVF误差分别<2.50 mm和<4.27 mm;Dice相似系数0.93-0.99)。
  • 脑、肝、左肺和膀胱在3个系统中均显示较大DVF误差(dmax:2.8-91.90 mm)。
  • 最小和最大DVF误差、 conformity index和Dice相似系数与体积相关(|rho|:0.41-0.64),尤其对极大或极小结构(|rho|:0.64-0.80)。
  • 仅Raystation和Velocity的平均距离一致性(mean distance to agreement)与部分DVF误差指标相关(r:0.70-0.78)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 食管、气管、左右股骨和尿道的平均DVF误差<2.50 mm、最大DVF误差<4.27 mm、Dice相似系数0.93-0.99。
  • 脑、肝、左肺和膀胱的最大DVF误差为2.8-91.90 mm。

临床怎么用

  • 自适应放疗中应关注DVF精度而非仅轮廓传播效果,因轮廓指标不能替代剂量形变准确性评估。
  • DVF误差容差值需根据解剖部位、形变强度、器官大小等因素调整。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: This study aimed to evaluate the accuracy of deformable image registration (DIR) algorithms using data sets with different levels of ground-truth deformation vector fields (DVFs) and to investigate the correlation between DVF errors and contour-based metrics. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Nine pairs of digital data sets were generated through contour-controlled deformations based on 3 anonymized patients' CTs (head and neck, thorax/abdomen, and pelvis) with low, medium, and high deformation intensity for each site using the ImSimQA software. Image pairs and their associated contours were imported to MIM-Maestro, Raystation, and Velocity systems, followed by DIR and contour propagation. The system-generated DVF and propagated contours were compared with the ground-truth data. The correlation between DVF errors and contour-based metrics was evaluated using the Pearson correlation coefficient (r), while their correlation with volumes were calculated using Spearman correlation coefficient (rho). RESULTS: The DVF errors increased with increasing deformation intensity. All DIR algorithms performed well for esophagus, trachea, left femoral, right femoral, and urethral (mean and maximum DVF errors <2.50 mm and <4.27 mm, respectively; Dice similarity coefficient: 0.93-0.99). Brain, liver, left lung, and bladder showed large DVF errors for all 3 systems (dmax: 2.8-91.90 mm). The minimum and maximum DVF errors, conformity index, and Dice similarity coefficient were correlated with volumes (|rho|: 0.41-0.64), especially for very large or small structures (|rho|: 0.64-0.80). Only mean distance to agreement of Raystation and Velocity correlated with some indices of DVF errors (r: 0.70-0.78). CONCLUSIONS: Most contour-based metrics had no correlation with DVF errors. For adaptive radiation therapy, well-performed contour propagation does not directly indicate accurate dose deformation and summation/accumulation within each contour (determined by DVF accuracy). Tolerance values for DVF errors should vary as the acceptable accuracy for overall adaptive radiation therapy depends on anatomic site, deformation intensity, organ size, and so forth. This study provides benchmark tables for evaluating DIR accuracy in various clinical scenarios.

来源:Pract Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Shi L, Chen Q, Barley S, et al. Benchmarking of Deformable Image Registration for Multiple Anatomic Sites Using Digital Data Sets With Ground-Truth Deformation Vector Fields. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2021. PMID: 33722783. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2021.02.012

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。