头颈癌自动放疗计划系统的临床可接受性
本研究纳入50例在三级中心接受治疗的头颈癌患者,用全自动放疗计划系统Radiation Planning Assistant基于原批准轮廓生成自动计划,并与临床已批准并实施的手工计划比较。常用DVH指标显示两者覆盖与危及器官约束相似;
要点
- 自动计划与临床计划在DVH覆盖和危及器官约束指标上非常相似。
- 盲法评审中88%自动计划、78%临床计划可原样使用。
- 72%评审者认为自动计划或两者之一更可取,0%认为两者均不可用。
核心结论
- 自动放疗计划可生成一致、临床可接受且满足DVH标准、经医生评审认可的头颈癌治疗计划。
研究设计与样本
- 研究队列为50例在三级中心由专门头颈癌团队治疗的患者,使用Radiation Planning Assistant基于原批准轮廓生成自动计划,并与临床已批准并实施的手工计划比较。
- 采用常用DVH标准比较自动计划与临床计划质量。
主要发现
- 自动计划与临床计划在覆盖和关键结构约束的DVH指标上非常相似。
- 医生评审认为临床计划与自动计划均可接受;总体78%的临床计划和88%的自动计划可原样使用(无需任何修改)。
- 在被要求选择更倾向批准的计划时,27%的医生评审选择临床计划,47%选择自动计划,25%认为两者等效,0%认为两者均不可取。
- 总体72%的医生评审认为自动计划或临床计划与自动计划任一者更可取。
关键数值与推荐
- 78%的临床计划被评审认为可原样使用(无需任何修改)。
- 88%的自动计划被评审认为可原样使用(无需任何修改)。
- 选择偏好:27%选临床计划,47%选自动计划,25%认为两者等效,0%认为两者均不可取。
临床怎么用
- 对于头颈癌放疗,自动计划系统可基于已批准轮廓生成满足常用DVH标准且经医生盲法评审可接受的计划,可作为提高计划质量与效率的选项。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Radiation treatment planning for head and neck cancer is a complex process with much variability; automated treatment planning is a promising option to improve plan quality and efficiency. This study compared radiation plans generated from a fully automated radiation treatment planning system to plans generated manually that had been clinically approved and delivered. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The study cohort consisted of 50 patients treated by a specialized head and neck cancer team at a tertiary care center. An automated radiation treatment planning system, the Radiation Planning Assistant, was used to create autoplans for all patients using their original, approved contours. Common dose-volume histogram (DVH) criteria were used to compare the quality of autoplans to the clinical plans. Fourteen radiation oncologists, each from a different institution, then reviewed and compared the autoplans and clinical plans in a blinded fashion. RESULTS: Autoplans and clinical plans were very similar with regard to DVH metrics for coverage and critical structure constraints. Physician reviewers found both the clinical plans and autoplans acceptable for use; overall, 78% of the clinical plans and 88% of the autoplans were found to be usable as is (without any edits). When asked to choose which plan would be preferred for approval, 27% of physician reviewers selected the clinical plan, 47% selected the autoplan, 25% said both were equivalent, and 0% said neither. Hence, overall, 72% of physician reviewers believed the autoplan or either the clinical or autoplan was preferable. CONCLUSIONS: Automated radiation treatment planning creates consistent, clinically acceptable treatment plans that meet DVH criteria and are found to be appropriate on physician review.
引用
- Olanrewaju A, Court LE, Zhang L, et al. Clinical Acceptability of Automated Radiation Treatment Planning for Head and Neck Cancer Using the Radiation Planning Assistant. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2021. PMID: 33640315. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2020.12.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。