颈动脉及其他出血事件在头颈再程立体定向放疗中的剂量-体积耐受性初步数据汇总
本文汇总PubMed文献中头颈再程SBRT/SABR的颈动脉及其他大血管最大点剂量数据,共6篇文章238个剂量点,用于logistic建模,并另对2项后续研究单独建模比较。初步建立3个预测出血事件的模型,但数据有限,仅作为风险参考而非强结论。
要点
- 汇总6篇文献238个大血管最大点剂量,建立3个初步出血风险模型。
- 非连续每日治疗、肿瘤环绕血管范围小、无手术操作可能降低出血风险。
- 颈动脉和脊髓等关键结构的并发症数据有限,不能视为强概率结论。
核心结论
- 头颈再程SBRT/SABR中颈动脉及其他大血管的剂量-体积数据经汇总建立3个初步出血风险模型,但数据有限仅作一般参考。
研究设计与样本
- 2018年4月PubMed检索英文文献(stereotactic、carotid、radiation),从6篇文章汇总238个大血管最大点剂量进行logistic建模,另对2项后续剂量-体积研究单独建模比较。
主要发现
- 既往放疗剂量未按患者统一报告,分析中按常规分割70 Gy考虑,多数病例估计间隔约≥6个月。
- 非连续每日治疗、肿瘤环绕血管周径范围较小、SBRT前后无手术操作可能与出血事件风险降低相关。
- 分析尝试将颈动脉破裂综合征与其他出血事件分开,但除1个数据集外其余均混杂出血事件。
关键数值与推荐
- 既往放疗按常规分割70 Gy考虑,多数病例估计间隔约≥6个月。
- 汇总6篇文章共238个大血管最大点剂量用于建模。
- 另对2项后续剂量-体积研究单独建模比较。
临床怎么用
- 可将3个初步模型作为头颈再程SBRT/SABR时颈动脉剂量-体积考虑的参考,但不应视为强概率结论。
- 可考虑非连续每日治疗、减少肿瘤环绕血管周径、避免SBRT前后手术操作以降低出血风险。
- 需遵循HyTEC倡导的更好报告标准,积累关键结构并发症数据。
局限性
- 既往放疗剂量未按患者统一报告,分析中按常规分割70 Gy假设。
- 多数数据集出血事件混杂,难以完全区分颈动脉破裂综合征与其他出血。
- 颈动脉和脊髓等关键结构并发症数据有限,不能视为强概率结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Dose-volume data for injury to carotid artery and other major vessels in stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT)/SABR head and neck reirradiation were reviewed, modeled, and summarized. METHODS AND MATERIALS: A PubMed search of the English-language literature (stereotactic and carotid and radiation) in April 2018 found 238 major vessel maximum point doses in 6 articles that were pooled for logistic modeling. Two subsequent studies with dose-volume major vessel data were modeled separately for comparison. Attempts were made to separate carotid blowout syndrome from other bleeding events (BE) in the analysis, but we acknowledge that all except 1 data set has some element of BE interspersed. RESULTS: Prior radiation therapy (RT) dose was not uniformly reported per patient in the studies included, but a course on the order of conventionally fractionated 70 Gy was considered for the purposes of the analysis (with an approximately ≥6-month estimated interval between prior and subsequent treatment in most cases). Factors likely associated with reduced risk of BE include nonconsecutive daily treatment, lower extent of circumferential tumor involvement around the vessel, and no surgical manipulation before or after SBRT. CONCLUSIONS: Initial data pooling for reirradiation involving the carotid artery resulted in 3 preliminary models compared in this Hypofractionated Treatment Effects in the Clinic (HyTEC) report. More recent experiences with alternating fractionation schedules and additional risk-reduction strategies are also presented. Complications data for the most critical structures such as spinal cord and carotid artery are so limited that they cannot be viewed as strong conclusions of probability of risk, but rather, as a general guideline for consideration. There is a great need for better reporting standards as noted in the High Dose per Fraction, Hypofractionated Treatment Effects in the Clinic introductory paper.
引用
- Grimm J, Vargo JA, Mavroidis P, et al. Initial Data Pooling for Radiation Dose-Volume Tolerance for Carotid Artery Blowout and Other Bleeding Events in Hypofractionated Head and Neck Retreatments. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2021. PMID: 33583641. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2020.12.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。