大数据分析资源系统结合人工智能算法识别头颈患者吞咽困难的临床可操作放疗剂量阈值
本研究将临床实践变革、标准化与技术结合,构建大数据分析资源系统(BDARS),并开发人工智能算法,从≥22000例患者数据中识别132例头颈癌放疗后吞咽困难加重(最大分级≥2)的患者,分析与吞咽困难相关的结构剂量体积直方图(DVH)指标。研究采用统计分类算法联合机器学习(SCA-ML)对7个吞咽结构的738个候选DVH指标进行排序,发现咽上缩肌D20%(EQD2)≥47.7 Gy等指标与吞咽困难相关,基于咽上缩肌D20%的模型灵敏度和曲线下面积分别为0.88±0.13和0.74±0.17。
要点
- 咽上缩肌D20%(EQD2)≥47.7 Gy与吞咽困难相关,模型灵敏度0.88±0.13。
- 咽下缩肌D35%≥61.7 Gy、高剂量颌下腺D35%≥61.7 Gy等指标SCA-ML评分高。
- 基于SCA-ML的DVH指标排序可为头颈放疗吞咽结构保护提供参考。
核心结论
- 结合大数据与人工智能可增加临床学习范式中的证据量,并识别与吞咽困难相关的结构DVH阈值。
研究设计与样本
- 从BDARS中≥22000例患者数据中筛选132例头颈癌放疗后吞咽困难评分从基线恶化至最大分级≥2的患者。
- 开发使用物理和生物校正(α/β=2.5)DVH曲线的方法,测试绝对和百分比体积DVH指标。
- 采用统计分类算法联合机器学习(SCA-ML)对候选DVH指标进行排序,并构建灵敏度引导的最小输入机器学习模型。
主要发现
- 7个吞咽结构产生738个候选DVH指标,包括咽上缩肌、咽下缩肌、喉和食管等。
- SCA-ML评分高的指标包括:咽上缩肌D20%(EQD2 Gy)≥47.7、D25%(Gy)≥50.4;咽下缩肌D35%(Gy)≥61.7;低剂量腮腺D60%(Gy)≥13.2;高剂量颌下腺D35%(Gy)≥61.7。
- 喉D25%(Gy)≥21.2和低剂量颌下腺D45%≥28.2评分高,但勾画计划不足90%。
- 基于咽上缩肌D20%(EQD2 Gy)单独模型灵敏度和曲线下面积分别为0.88±0.13和0.74±0.17。
关键数值与推荐
- 咽上缩肌D20%(EQD2 Gy)≥47.7、D25%(Gy)≥50.4;咽下缩肌D35%(Gy)≥61.7;低剂量腮腺D60%(Gy)≥13.2;高剂量颌下腺D35%(Gy)≥61.7;喉D25%(Gy)≥21.2;低剂量颌下腺D45%≥28.2。
临床怎么用
- 可将咽上缩肌D20%(EQD2)≥47.7 Gy等DVH阈值作为头颈癌放疗计划优化时吞咽结构保护的参考。
局限性
- 喉和低剂量颌下腺指标基于不足90%计划的勾画,可能影响其可靠性。
- 样本量有限(132例),结论需更大数据集验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: We combined clinical practice changes, standardizations, and technology to automate aggregation, integration, and harmonization of comprehensive patient data from the multiple source systems used in clinical practice into a big data analytics resource system (BDARS). We then developed novel artificial intelligence algorithms, coupled with the BDARS, to identify structure dose volume histograms (DVH) metrics associated with dysphagia. METHODS AND MATERIALS: From the BDARS harmonized data of ≥22,000 patients, we identified 132 patients recently treated for head and neck cancer who also demonstrated dysphagia scores that worsened from base line to a maximum grade ≥2. We developed a method that used both physical and biologically corrected (α/β = 2.5) DVH curves to test both absolute and percentage volume based DVH metrics. Combining a statistical categorization algorithm with machine learning (SCA-ML) provided more extensive detailing of response threshold evidence than either approach alone. A sensitivity guided, minimum input, machine learning (ML) model was iteratively constructed to identify the key structure DVH metric thresholds. RESULTS: Seven swallowing structures producing 738 candidate DVH metrics were ranked for association with dysphagia using SCA-ML scoring. Structures included superior pharyngeal constrictor (SPC), inferior pharyngeal constrictor (IPC), larynx, and esophagus. Bilateral parotid and submandibular gland (SG) structures were categorized by relative mean dose (eg, SG_high, SG_low) as a dose versus tumor centric analog to contra and ipsilateral designations. Structure DVH metrics with high SCA-ML scores included the following: SPC: D20% (equivalent dose [EQD2] Gy) ≥47.7; SPC: D25% (Gy) ≥50.4; IPC: D35% (Gy) ≥61.7; parotid_low: D60% (Gy) ≥13.2; and SG_high: D35% (Gy) ≥61.7. Larynx: D25% (Gy) ≥21.2 and SG_low: D45% ≥28.2 had high SCA-ML scores but were segmented on less than 90% of plans. A model based on SPC: D20% (EQD2 Gy) alone had sensitivity and area under the curve of 0.88 ± 0.13 and 0.74 ± 0.17, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides practical demonstration of combining big data with artificial intelligence to increase volume of evidence in clinical learning paradigms.
引用
- Mayo CS, Mierzwa M, Moran JM, et al. Combination of a Big Data Analytics Resource System With an Artificial Intelligence Algorithm to Identify Clinically Actionable Radiation Dose Thresholds for Dysphagia in Head and Neck Patients. Adv Radiat Oncol. 2020. PMID: 33305091. doi:10.1016/j.adro.2019.12.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。