文献速递放疗物理与技术姑息放疗与转移瘤

放射治疗模拟定位前多学科同行评审的前瞻性分析

A Comprehensive Analysis of a Prospective Multidisciplinary Peer Review Process Before Radiation Therapy Simulation.
PubMed 文献 · Pract Radiat Oncol · 2020-11-13

该研究在单一三级医疗中心对500例连续模拟定位患者实施标准化指令和多学科模拟前同行评审,前瞻性记录修改情况。结果显示21%的指令被修改,复杂治疗(IMRT/SRS/SBRT)修改比例高于3DCRT(25% vs 16%,P < .025)。结论认为标准化指令联合前瞻性多学科同行评审对优化流程和减少错误至关重要,约五分之一的患者从中获益。

要点

  • 21%的模拟定位指令经多学科评审后被修改,复杂治疗修改率更高。
  • 修改主要涉及患者体位与固定(20%)、治疗部位与护理路径(6.8%)。
  • 标准化指令联合模拟前多学科同行评审可优化流程并减少错误。

核心结论

  • 标准化模拟定位指令联合前瞻性放射肿瘤多学科模拟前同行评审对优化科室流程和减少错误至关重要。
  • 约五分之一的患者从该同行评审流程中获益,尤其是接受IMRT/SRS/SBRT治疗的患者。

研究设计与样本

  • 单中心三级医疗中心前瞻性质量改进登记研究,连续纳入500例接受外照射放疗模拟定位的患者。
  • 模拟定位指令由多学科代表评审,修改情况前瞻性记录,采用Fisher精确检验和t检验分析变量与修改发生的关联。

主要发现

  • 500例连续模拟定位中,105份指令(21%)被修改,其中29份(5.8%)需要超过1次修改,共发生149次修改。
  • 修改分类包括患者体位与固定(n=100,20%)、治疗部位与护理路径(n=34,6.8%)、模拟协调活动(n=6,1.2%)、治疗技术与计划指令(n=9,1.8%)。
  • 复杂治疗(IMRT/SRS/SBRT)在多学科评审时的修改比例高于3DCRT(25% vs 16%,P < .025)。
  • 治疗意图为根治性269例(53.8%)、姑息性203例(40.6%)、良性3例(0.6%),25例(5%)未选择治疗意图。
  • 所有模拟定位指令均由医生在模拟前中位3天录入(范围1-76天),每月中位模拟量为105例。

临床怎么用

  • 在模拟定位前实施标准化的多学科同行评审流程,可识别并修正约五分之一的指令问题。
  • 对接受IMRT/SRS/SBRT等复杂治疗的患者应优先安排多学科模拟前评审。

局限性

  • 研究为单中心三级医疗中心的前瞻性质量改进登记分析,结果外推需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Although peer review in radiation oncology (RO) has been recommended to improve quality of care, an analysis of modifications resulting from an RO multidisciplinary presimulation standardized review process has yet to be empirically demonstrated. METHODS AND MATERIALS: A standardized simulation directive was used for patients undergoing simulation for external beam radiation therapy at a single tertiary care institution. The simulation directives were presented, and all aspects were reviewed by representatives from key RO disciplines. Modifications to the original directives were prospectively captured in a quality improvement registry. Association between key variables and the incidence of modifications were performed using Fisher exact test and t test. RESULTS: A registry of 500 consecutive simulations for patients undergoing radiation therapy was reviewed. A median of 105 simulations occurred per month. All simulation directives were entered by a physician a median of 3 days before simulation (range, 1-76 days). The treatment intent was curative for 269 patients (53.8%), palliative for 203 patients (40.6%), and benign for 3 patients (0.6%). Twenty-five (5%) patients did not have a treatment intent selected. Based on RO multidisciplinary review, 105 directives (21%) were modified from the original intent, with 29 (5.8%) requiring more than 1 modification. A total of 149 modifications were made and categorized as changes to patient positioning and immobilization (n = 100, 20%), treatment site and care path (n = 34, 6.8%), simulation coordination activities (n = 6, 1.2%), and treatment technique and planning instructions (n = 9, 1.8%). A higher proportion of modifications occurred at the time of multidisciplinary review in patients receiving more complex treatments (intensity modulated radiation therapy/stereotactic radiosurgery/stereotactic body radiation therapy [IMRT/SRS/SBRT] vs 3-dimensional radiation therapy [3DCRT] radiation therapy, 25% vs 16%, P < .025). CONCLUSIONS: Given the complexity of radiation therapy simulation, standardization of directives with prospective RO multidisciplinary presimulation peer review is critical to optimizing department processes and reducing errors. Approximately 1 in 5 patients benefits from this peer review process, especially patients treated with IMRT/SRS/SBRT.

来源:Pract Radiat Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kotecha R, LeGrand LA, Valladares MA, et al. A Comprehensive Analysis of a Prospective Multidisciplinary Peer Review Process Before Radiation Therapy Simulation. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2020. PMID: 33197645. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2020.10.012

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。