乳腺癌放疗多器官及临床靶区自动分割:图谱法与深度学习法的临床评估
本研究基于62例乳腺癌保乳术后患者的增强计划CT,比较两种商用图谱分割方案与基于全卷积DenseNet的深度学习自动分割在靶区、器官及心脏亚结构上的表现,并以14例测试患者的Dice相似系数和Hausdorff距离对照专家轮廓评估,另用14例平扫CT做敏感性分析。结果显示深度学习法在多数结构上更一致、更稳健,尤其在靶区与心脏亚结构上Dice最高、Hausdorff距离最低,图谱法在食管、心脏动脉及较小靶区等软组织区域表现有限;增强与平扫测试集间深度学习法差异小,图谱法差异大。
要点
- 深度学习自动分割在多数靶区与正常器官上较图谱法更一致、更稳健。
- 靶区与心脏亚结构上深度学习法Dice最高、Hausdorff距离最低。
- 图谱法在食管、心脏动脉及较小靶区等软组织区域表现有限。
核心结论
- 所提出的深度学习自动分割算法在多数靶区与正常器官上较图谱法表现更一致、更稳健。
- 深度学习自动分割有望辅助放疗流程关键环节,帮助优化并减少临床工作量。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用62例接受保乳手术的乳腺癌患者的增强计划CT扫描。
- 靶区、器官及心脏亚结构轮廓由两种商用图谱分割方案与基于全卷积DenseNet的深度学习自动分割生成。
- 以14例测试患者参照专家轮廓,用Dice相似系数与Hausdorff距离评估分割准确性。
- 另用14例额外患者的平扫计划CT进行敏感性分析。
主要发现
- 与图谱法相比,深度学习模型结果更一致,平均Dice相似系数最高、Hausdorff距离最低,尤其针对靶区与心脏亚结构。
- 图谱法在食管、心脏动脉及较小靶区等基于软组织的区域表现有限。
- 增强与平扫CT测试集间敏感性分析显示深度学习法性能差异小,而图谱法差异大。
临床怎么用
- 在乳腺癌放疗计划中可优先考虑深度学习自动分割以提升靶区与心脏亚结构勾画的一致性。
- 对食管、心脏动脉及较小靶区等软组织区域,图谱法结果需谨慎复核。
- 增强与平扫CT下深度学习法表现稳定,可支持不同扫描条件的临床使用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Manual segmentation is the gold standard method for radiation therapy planning; however, it is time-consuming and prone to inter- and intra-observer variation, giving rise to interests in auto-segmentation methods. We evaluated the feasibility of deep learning-based auto-segmentation (DLBAS) in comparison to commercially available atlas-based segmentation solutions (ABAS) for breast cancer radiation therapy. This study used contrast-enhanced planning computed tomography scans from 62 patients with breast cancer who underwent breast-conservation surgery. Contours of target volumes (CTVs), organs, and heart substructures were generated using two commercial ABAS solutions and DLBAS using fully convolutional DenseNet. The accuracy of the segmentation was assessed using 14 test patients using the Dice Similarity Coefficient and Hausdorff Distance referencing the expert contours. A sensitivity analysis was performed using non-contrast planning CT from 14 additional patients. Compared to ABAS, the proposed DLBAS model yielded more consistent results and the highest average Dice Similarity Coefficient values and lowest Hausdorff Distances, especially for CTVs and the substructures of the heart. ABAS showed limited performance in soft-tissue-based regions, such as the esophagus, cardiac arteries, and smaller CTVs. The results of sensitivity analysis between contrast and non-contrast CT test sets showed little difference in the performance of DLBAS and conversely, a large discrepancy for ABAS. The proposed DLBAS algorithm was more consistent and robust in its performance than ABAS across the majority of structures when examining both CTVs and normal organs. DLBAS has great potential to aid a key process in the radiation therapy workflow, helping optimise and reduce the clinical workload.
引用
- Choi MS, Choi BS, Chung SY, et al. Clinical evaluation of atlas- and deep learning-based automatic segmentation of multiple organs and clinical target volumes for breast cancer. Radiother Oncol. 2020. PMID: 32991916. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2020.09.045
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。