心脏全运动范围在放疗计划中的实用补偿方法
本研究基于10例接受立体定向消融放疗的肺癌患者的3D与4D CT,比较基于3D、4D平均投影(AVG)和最大密度投影(MIP)的心脏勾画需外扩多少才能覆盖4D成像采集期间心脏全运动范围。结果显示MIP勾画最接近全运动范围,仅需≤2.5 mm外扩,AVG和3D分别需至多3.4 mm和7.1 mm。
要点
- 基于MIP的心脏勾画最接近4D全运动范围,仅需≤2.5 mm外扩。
- 基于AVG和3D的心脏勾画分别需至多3.4 mm和7.1 mm外扩。
- 最大外扩方向分别为3D的下方、AVG的右侧和MIP的前方。
核心结论
- 基于3D、AVG或MIP扫描的心脏勾画均需外扩以代表心脏全运动范围,其中MIP所需外扩最小。
研究设计与样本
- 使用10例接受立体定向消融放疗的肺癌患者的3D和4D CT扫描,由3名观察者在3D CT、AVG、MIP和25%呼气相扫描上勾画心脏并取中位面。
- 将每例患者的25%呼气相轮廓传播至4D扫描各时相,所有4D时相勾画的并集(U4D)代表成像采集期间心脏全运动范围。
- 计算U4D至3D、AVG和MIP体积的表面距离,利用最极端表面点(上下最远1.5 cm、左右前后最远10%)推导仅考虑系统性(勾画)误差的外扩。
主要发现
- MIP上的心脏勾画最接近全运动范围,仅需≤2.5 mm外扩。
- AVG上的勾画需至多3.4 mm外扩,3D扫描上的勾画需至多7.1 mm外扩。
- 最大外扩分别位于3D勾画的下方、AVG勾画的右侧和MIP勾画的前方。
关键数值与推荐
- MIP勾画外扩≤2.5 mm可覆盖心脏全运动范围。
- AVG勾画外扩至多3.4 mm可覆盖心脏全运动范围。
- 3D勾画外扩至多7.1 mm可覆盖心脏全运动范围。
临床怎么用
- 在放疗计划中基于MIP勾画心脏可最小化所需外扩,仅需≤2.5 mm即可覆盖4D成像采集期间心脏全运动范围。
- 若使用AVG或3D勾画,应分别考虑至多3.4 mm和7.1 mm的外扩以代表心脏全运动范围。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入10例肺癌患者,样本量有限。
- 外扩仅考虑系统性(勾画)误差,未包含随机成分。
- 尚需每日成像研究确定随机误差成分,并需剂量学测量确定创建心脏计划危及器官体积的相关性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Emerging evidence suggests that the heart is more radiosensitive than previously assumed; therefore, accounting for heart motion in radiation therapy planning is becoming more critical. In this study, we determined how much heart delineations based on 3-dimensional (3D) computed tomography (CT), 4-dimensional (4D) average projection (AVG), and maximum intensity projection (MIP) images should be extended to represent the full extent of heart motion during 4D imaging acquisition. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The 3D and 4D CT scans of 10 lung cancer patients treated with stereotactic ablative radiation therapy were used. Median surfaces were derived from heart delineations of 3 observers on the 3D CT, AVG, MIP, and 25% exhale scans. Per patient, the 25% exhale contour was propagated on every phase of the 4D scan. The union of all 4D phase delineations (U4D) represented the full extent of heart motion during imaging acquisition. Surface distances from U4D to 3D, AVG, and MIP volumes were calculated. Distances in the most extreme surface points (1.5 cm most superoinferior, 10% most right/left/anteroposterior) were used to derive margins accounting only for systematic (delineation) errors. RESULTS: Heart delineations on the MIP were the closest to the full extent of motion, requiring only ≤2.5-mm margins. Delineations on the AVG and 3D scans required margins up to 3.4 and 7.1 mm, respectively. The largest margins were for the inferior, right, and anterior aspects for the delineations on the 3D, AVG, and MIP scans, respectively. CONCLUSION: Delineations on 3D, AVG, or MIP scans required extensions for representing the heart's full extent of motion, with the MIP requiring the smallest margins. Research including daily imaging to determine the random components for the margins and dosimetric measurements to determine the relevance of creating a planning organ at risk volume of the heart is required.
引用
- Vasquez Osorio EM, McCallum H, Bedair A, et al. Protecting the Heart: A Practical Approach to Account for the Full Extent of Heart Motion in Radiation Therapy Planning. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2020. PMID: 32629080. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2020.06.068
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。