放射肿瘤学住院医师对2019年初次认证资格考试体验的调查
该研究调查了360名2019和2020届放射肿瘤学住院医师,应答率58%(n=210)。住院医师在医学物理和放射生物学考试前12周中位学习160小时,对研究产出、心理健康、临床发展和家庭生活产生中度或显著负面影响。住院医师支持制定共识课程并倾向于将三门资格考试合并为一次笔试。
要点
- 住院医师备考中位学习160小时,对研究、心理、临床和家庭生活有负面影响。
- 52%使用保护性科研或选修时间备考,21%使用中位5天假期。
- 住院医师强烈支持制定共识课程,并同意合并三门资格考试为一次笔试。
核心结论
- 放射肿瘤学住院医师为初次认证考试投入大量时间,牺牲了培训和健康相关结果。
- 住院医师报告物理和放射生物学课程质量差异大,支持制定共识课程并合并考试。
- 2019年考试高通过率不应免除对毕业后医学教育和认证过程持续改进的需要。
研究设计与样本
- 放射肿瘤学住院医师协会向2019和2020届360名住院医师分发调查问卷。
- 调查涵盖医学物理、放射与肿瘤生物学和临床放射肿瘤学资格考试准备相关主题。
主要发现
- 应答率58%(n=210)。
- 医学物理和放射生物学考试前12周,首次考生中位学习160小时(四分位距96-270)。
- 住院医师报告对研究产出、心理健康、临床发展和家庭生活有中度或显著负面影响,评分均为3(2-4)。
- 52%(n=110)使用保护性科研或选修时间备考,21%(n=45)使用中位5天(3-20)假期。
- 住院医师同意物理课程重要(4[2-4]),对放射生物学课程价值中立(3[2-4])。
关键数值与推荐
- 住院医师强烈支持制定共识放射肿瘤学课程(5[4-5])。
- 住院医师同意将医学物理、放射与肿瘤生物学和临床放射肿瘤学资格考试合并为一次笔试(4[3-4])。
临床怎么用
- 住院医师备考需大量时间,项目应考虑保护性学习时间以减少对临床和健康的影响。
- 项目应关注物理和放射生物学课程质量,住院医师支持共识课程。
- 住院医师倾向于合并资格考试为一次笔试,可作为认证改革参考。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To characterize the resident experience preparing for the 2019 American Board of Radiology initial certification (IC) qualifying examinations in radiation oncology. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The Association of Residents in Radiation Oncology distributed a survey to 360 radiation oncology residents from the 2019 and 2020 graduating classes covering topics pertinent to preparation for the medical physics (MP), radiation and cancer biology (RCB), and clinical radiation oncology (CRO) qualifying examinations. RESULTS: The response rate was 58% (n = 210). In the 12 weeks before the MP and RCB examinations, first-time examinees studied a median of 160 hours (interquartile range, 96 to 270). Residents reported a "moderate" or "significant" negative effect on research productivity (3 [2-4]), mental health (3 [2-4]), clinical development (3 [2-4]), and family life (3 [2-4]). Half of surveyed residents (52%, n = 110) used a protected research or elective block to study while an additional 21% (n = 45) used a median of 5 (3-20) vacation days. Residents overall "agreed" (4 [2-4]) that their program's physics course was "important" for their preparation but were "neutral" (3 [2-4]) regarding the value of their program's radiobiology course. Question-based educational resources were most frequently rated as "important" study resources. Respondents "strongly" endorsed the development of a consensus radiation oncology curriculum (5 [4-5]) and "agreed" (4 [3-4]) that consolidation of the MP, RCB, and CRO qualifying examinations into a single written examination would be preferred. CONCLUSIONS: Radiation oncology residents dedicate substantial time preparing for the IC examinations at the expense of training- and health-related outcomes. Residents report a wide range in quality of internal program didactic courses in physics and radiobiology, endorse development of a consensus radiation oncology curriculum, and prefer consolidation of the three qualifying examinations into a single written IC examination. We caution the high pass rates seen on the 2019 examinations do not obviate the need for ongoing improvement in radiation oncology graduate medical education and the board certification process.
引用
- Campbell SR, Jeans EB, Albert A, et al. Radiation Oncology Initial Certification Qualification Examinations: The Resident Experience in 2019. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2020. PMID: 32428765. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2020.04.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。