文献速递泌尿生殖与妇科肿瘤放疗

EMBRACE-II宫颈癌IMRT靶区勾画在线放疗质量保证与继续医学教育实施报告

Implementing an online radiotherapy quality assurance programme with supporting continuous medical education - report from the EMBRACE-II evaluation of cervix cancer IMRT contouring.
PubMed 文献 · Radiother Oncol · 2020-03-30

EMBRACE-II是一项国际前瞻性研究,针对局部晚期宫颈癌的IMRT和MRI引导自适应近距离放疗实施在线放疗质量保证(RTQA)与继续医学教育(CME)项目。78名临床医生对6个感兴趣体积的勾画进行评分,首次通过率41%,专家反馈可提高勾画依从性,但Jaccard conformity index(JCI)不能可靠替代专家评估。

要点

  • 专家定性反馈可提高靶区勾画依从性,但JCI不能替代专家评估。
  • 选择性淋巴结CTV(CTV-E)和ITV-T平均得分最低。
  • CME内容使用率中等,限制了对CME效果的评估。

核心结论

  • 专家评估结合定性反馈提高了勾画依从性,JCI不是专家评估的可靠替代方法。

研究设计与样本

  • EMBRACE-II为国际前瞻性研究,针对局部晚期宫颈癌的IMRT和MRI引导自适应近距离放疗(IGABT)。
  • 对78名临床医生提交的1个基准病例的6个感兴趣体积(VOI)勾画进行评分(2=优秀,1=一般,0=需修改)。
  • 回顾性计算Jaccard conformity index(JCI),并分析用户对CME内容的交互情况。

主要发现

  • 78名临床医生提交勾画,首次通过率41%,一次修改后通过44%,两次或以上修改后通过6%,9%失败后未重新提交。
  • 平均得分最低为选择性淋巴结CTV(CTV-E)1.01/2和ITV-T 1.06/2。
  • 6个VOI共识别60种不同错误,其中5种对局部区域控制有潜在高影响。
  • JCI截断值0.7可识别87%未通过专家评估的勾画,但也排除了54%通过的勾画。
  • 39名临床医生回答预认证问卷,36%预计ITV-T有困难,13%预计CTV-E有困难。

关键数值与推荐

  • 勾画评分标准:2=优秀,1=一般,0=需修改。
  • JCI截断值0.7可识别87%未通过专家评估的勾画,但排除54%通过的勾画。

临床怎么用

  • 在线RTQA项目结合专家定性反馈可用于评估和改善IMRT靶区勾画依从性。
  • JCI不能作为专家评估的可靠替代,仍需专家评审。
  • CME内容使用率中等,需提高参与度以充分发挥其作用。

局限性

  • 选择性CME内容使用率中等,限制了对CME效果的评估。
  • JCI回顾性计算,且截断值0.7存在误分类。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: EMBRACE-II is an international prospective study of IMRT and MRI-guided adaptive brachytherapy (IGABT) in locally advanced cervix cancer. An online radiotherapy quality assurance (RTQA) programme with minimal data transfer and supporting continuing medical education (CME) was implemented for IMRT contouring. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Participant contours for six volumes-of-interest (VOIs) on one benchmark case were scored (2 = excellent, 1 = fair, 0 = revision required) against a consensus reference contour. For contours receiving a 0 or 1 score, additional qualitative comments were provided. The Jaccard conformity index (JCI) was retrospectively calculated. User interaction with CME content (pre-accreditation questionnaire, contouring atlas, practice cases, quizzes, internal target volume (ITV-T) guide) was analysed. RESULTS: 78 clinicians submitted contours for evaluation. 41% passed at the first attempt, 44% after one revision and 6% after two or more revisions. 9% did not re-submit after failing. The lowest mean scores were for the elective nodal CTV (CTV-E) (1.01/2) and ITV-T (1.06/2). 60 different errors across the six VOIs were identified; five potentially had high impact on loco-regional control. A JCI cut-off of 0.7 would have identified 87% contours that failed expert assessment, but also excluded 54% of passing contours. 39 clinicians responded to the pre-accreditation questionnaire - 36% anticipated difficulties with the ITV-T and 13% with the CTV-E. 35% clinicians contoured on the practice cases, 17% answered a quiz, 96% used the atlas and 38% the ITV-T guide. CONCLUSION: Expert evaluation with qualitative feedback improved contouring compliance. The JCI is not a reliable alternative to expert assessment. Moderate uptake of optional CME content limited evaluation.

来源:Radiother Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Duke SL, Tan LT, Jensen NBK, et al. Implementing an online radiotherapy quality assurance programme with supporting continuous medical education - report from the EMBRACE-II evaluation of cervix cancer IMRT contouring. Radiother Oncol. 2020. PMID: 32240907. doi:10.1016/j.radonc.2020.02.017

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。