指南与共识头颈部肿瘤放疗消化道肿瘤放疗泌尿生殖与妇科肿瘤放疗

放射肿瘤学靶区勾画指南系统综述:频率、方法与共识推荐传达方式分析

A Systematic Review of Contouring Guidelines in Radiation Oncology: Analysis of Frequency, Methodology, and Delivery of Consensus Recommendations.
指南 / 共识 · Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys · 2020-04-18

该系统综述检索1995年后发表的靶区勾画指南,最终纳入142部指南进行分析。结果显示指南发表数量随时间显著增加,头颈部为最常见部位,临床试验相关指南更常采用基于图像的共识方法和发布完整图像集推荐。

要点

  • 1995至2019年间靶区勾画指南发表数量显著增加,2015至2019年达65部。
  • 临床试验相关指南更常采用基于图像的勾画分析和发布完整图像集推荐。
  • 头颈部、消化道和妇科是靶区勾画指南最常见的疾病部位。

核心结论

  • 靶区勾画共识推荐数量随时间增加,但共识制定方法存在差异。
  • 临床试验相关指南更常包含基于图像的共识分析和完整图像集推荐。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述检索1995年后发表的靶区勾画指南,从11124条引文中筛选332篇全文评估,最终纳入142部指南。
  • 提取内容包括共识过程目的、方法学关键要素和信息传达方式,采用Fisher精确检验比较临床试验与常规诊疗指南的差异。

主要发现

  • 142部指南中16部(11%)为临床试验制定。
  • 指南发表数量从1995-1999年的0部增至2015-2019年的65部(P = .03)。
  • 最常见疾病部位为头颈部(24%)、消化道(12%)和妇科(12%)。
  • 制定推荐的方法包括文献综述(50%)和基于图像的方法(45%)。
  • 专家组中位医师数为10人(四分位距7-16),70%的专家组具有多学科专业构成。

关键数值与推荐

  • 临床试验相关指南更可能包含基于图像的方法、对专家组成员提交勾画进行定量分析以及发布完整图像集推荐(P < .005)。

临床怎么用

  • 临床可参考基于图像的共识勾画分析和完整图像集推荐以提高指南的接受度和可用性。
  • 多学科专家组的共识指南有助于标准化靶区勾画。

局限性

  • 原文未报告具体局限性内容。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Clinical trials have described variation in radiation therapy plan quality, of which contour delineation is a key component, and linked this to inferior patient outcomes. In response, consensus guidelines have been developed to standardize contour delineation. This investigation assesses trends in contouring guidelines and examines the methodologies used to generate and deliver recommendations. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We conducted a literature search for contouring guidelines published after 1995. Of 11,124 citations, 332 were identified for full-text review to determine inclusion. We abstracted articles for the intent of the consensus process, key elements of the methodology, and mode of information delivery. A Fisher exact test was used to identify elements that differed among the guidelines generated for clinical trials and routine care. RESULTS: Overall, 142 guidelines were included, of which 16 (11%) were developed for a clinical trial. There was an increase in guideline publication over time (0 from 1995-1999 vs 65 from 2015- 2019; P = .03), particularly among recommendations for stereotactic radiation and brachytherapy. The most common disease sites were head and neck (24%), gastrointestinal (12%), and gynecologic (12%). Methods used to develop recommendations included literature review (50%) and image-based methods (45%). Panels included a median of 10 physicians (interquartile range, 7-16); 70% of panels represented multidisciplinary expertise. Guidelines developed for a clinical trial were more likely to include an image-based approach, with quantitative analysis of contours submitted by the panel members and to publish a full set of image-based recommendations (P < .005). CONCLUSIONS: This review highlights an increase in consensus contouring recommendations over time. Guidelines focus on disease sites, such as head and neck, with evidence supporting a correlation between treatment planning and patient outcomes, although variation exists in the approach to the consensus process. Elements that may improve guideline acceptance (ie, image-based consensus contour analysis) and usability (ie, inclusion of a full image set) are more common in guidelines developed for clinical trials.

来源:Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lin D, Lapen K, Sherer MV, et al. A Systematic Review of Contouring Guidelines in Radiation Oncology: Analysis of Frequency, Methodology, and Delivery of Consensus Recommendations. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2020. PMID: 32311418. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2020.04.011

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。