采用大分割前列腺癌外照射方案时机构间计划质量差异
该研究回顾性分析加拿大阿尔伯塔省4个癌症中心235例遵循PROFIT方案的前列腺癌计划,发现多个剂量学参数存在机构间统计学显著差异,但肿瘤控制概率与正常组织并发症概率差异小于1%,临床意义有限。
要点
- 4中心235例前列腺癌计划中多个剂量学参数存在统计学显著差异。
- 剂量学代表性病例分析结果一致,差异部分源于本地计划实践。
- TCP与NTCP差异小于1%,提示计划质量差异临床意义有限。
核心结论
- 尽管遵循共同指南,4个中心的前列腺癌计划质量指标仍存在统计学显著差异。
- 差异至少部分源于本地计划实践的不同。
- TCP和NTCP计算提示这些差异的临床意义极小。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析加拿大阿尔伯塔省4个癌症中心235例遵循PROFIT方案的前列腺癌计划。
- 采用单因素方差分析和Games-Howell事后分析比较机构间计划质量参数分布。
- 使用k-medoid聚类选取各中心剂量学代表性病例进行剂量体积直方图和剂量分布比较。
主要发现
- 膀胱壁D30%和D50%、左右股骨头D5%、PTV D99%和D1cc、CTV D99%的均值在中心间存在统计学显著差异。
- 剂量学代表性病例展示了一致的结果。
- 尽管观察到中心间人群解剖差异,使用解剖相似病例分析仍显示一致的剂量学差异趋势。
- 4个中心间TCP和NTCP差异小于1%。
关键数值与推荐
- 膀胱壁D30%和D50%、左右股骨头D5%、PTV D99%和D1cc、CTV D99%在中心间均值比较有统计学显著差异。
- TCP和NTCP在4个中心间差异小于1%。
临床怎么用
- 采用共同协议时,机构间计划质量指标存在一定变异,但TCP和NTCP差异小于1%提示临床意义有限。
- 该结果可作为采用共同协议时可接受的中心间变异程度的参考。
局限性
- 原文未报告
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: This study quantified plan quality differences across the 4 cancer centers in Alberta, Canada for plans that followed the PROstate Fractionated Irradiation Trial protocol. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Prostate plans of 235 patients were retrospectively reviewed. Interinstitutional plan quality comparisons were made based on distributions of protocol-specified parameters using 1-way analysis of variance with Games-Howell post hoc analysis. Dosimetrically representative cases were selected from each center using k-medoid clustering, enabling side-by-side comparison of dose-volume histograms and dose distributions. Fourteen anatomic features were investigated to explore interinstitutional patient population differences. Anatomically representative cases were selected from each center to explore differences in planning practices. Tumor control probability (TCP), as well as rectal wall and bladder wall normal tissue complication probabilities (NTCPs), were calculated to quantify the clinical effect of the differences in plan quality. RESULTS: Comparing the mean value of each center to the other 3, statistically significant differences were observed for bladder wall D30% and D50%, left and right femoral heads D5%, planning target volume D99% and D1cc, and clinical target volume D99%. Dosimetrically representative cases demonstrated consistent results. Although anatomic differences were observed between the center-specific populations, an analysis using anatomically similar cases demonstrated consistent trends in the dosimetric differences, suggesting the dosimetric variation is not exclusively due to anatomic differences. Minimal differences (<1%) among the 4 centers were noted for TCP and NTCPs, suggesting the reported differences in plan quality may not have any clinical significance. CONCLUSIONS: Despite common guidelines, statistically significant differences in plan quality metrics occurred among the 4 investigated centers. The differences are due at least in part to variation in local planning practices. TCP and NTCP calculations suggest that the clinical significance of the differences is minimal. These results can serve as a reference for the degree of variation among centers that can be accepted when a common protocol is adopted.
引用
- Sun L, Smith W, Kirkby C, et al. Variation in Interinstitutional Plan Quality When Adopting a Hypofractionated Protocol for Prostate Cancer External Beam Radiation Therapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2020. PMID: 32112880. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2020.02.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。