肺癌SBRT中ITV与MidV计划靶区比较:基于治疗中4D-CBCT的覆盖度与PTV适形性评估
结果显示PTVMidV、PTVITV+5mm、PTVITV+4mm和PTVITV+3mm的平均靶区覆盖度分别为98.6%、99.6%、98.9%和97.2%,且所有PTV在至少90%病例中单次治疗覆盖度>95%。与PTVITV+5mm相比,PTVMidV、PTVITV+4mm和PTVITV+3mm的PTV平均缩小16%、19%和33%。
要点
- PTVITV+3mm较PTVMidV显著缩小PTV且仍维持足够的治疗中靶区覆盖度。
- 所有四种PTV策略在至少90%病例中单次治疗覆盖度>95%。
- 基于4D-CBCT图像引导的VMAT中,ITV approach采用小于常规5mm的margin可作为MidV的替代。
核心结论
- 在基于4D-CBCT图像引导的VMAT中,采用小于常规5mm margin的ITV-based方法可作为MidV-based方法的替代,以减少肺SBRT中健康组织受照。
- 与PTVMidV相比,PTVITV+3mm显著缩小PTV的同时仍维持足够的治疗中靶区覆盖度。
研究设计与样本
- 每分次通过治疗中4D-CBCT(与VMAT同步采集)确定GTV的呼吸相关位置,并勾画10个呼吸时相的GTV。
- 靶区覆盖度定义为患者呼吸周期中GTV包含在PTV内的平均百分比,并对整个治疗疗程取平均。
- 比较了基于剂量概率margin的PTVMidV以及各向同性margin为5mm、4mm和3mm的三种ITV-based PTV(PTVITV+5mm、PTVITV+4mm、PTVITV+3mm)。
主要发现
- 共分析100幅治疗中4D-CBCT图像。
- PTVMidV、PTVITV+5mm、PTVITV+4mm和PTVITV+3mm的平均靶区覆盖度分别为98.6%、99.6%、98.9%和97.2%。
- 所有PTV margin在至少90%的评估病例中单次治疗靶区覆盖度高于95%。
- 与PTVITV+5mm相比,PTVMidV、PTVITV+4mm和PTVITV+3mm的平均PTV分别缩小16%、19%和33%。
关键数值与推荐
- PTVMidV平均靶区覆盖度98.6%,PTVITV+5mm为99.6%,PTVITV+4mm为98.9%,PTVITV+3mm为97.2%。
- 所有PTV margin在至少90%病例中单次治疗覆盖度>95%。
- 与PTVITV+5mm相比,PTVMidV、PTVITV+4mm和PTVITV+3mm的PTV平均缩小分别为16%、19%和33%。
临床怎么用
- 在实施基于4D-CBCT图像引导的VMAT时,可考虑采用ITV-based方法配合小于常规5mm的margin(如3mm)作为MidV-based方法的替代,以缩小PTV并减少健康组织受照。
- 选择PTV策略时需权衡靶区覆盖度与PTV缩小程度,PTVITV+3mm在维持足够覆盖度的同时显著缩小PTV。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The internal target volume (ITV) approach and the mid-ventilation (MidV) concept are the two main respiratory motion-management strategies under free breathing. The purpose of this work was to compare the actual in-treatment target coverage during volumetric modulated arctherapy (VMAT) delivered through both ITV-based and MidV-based planning target volume (PTV) and to provide knowledge in choosing the optimal PTV for stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) for lung lesions. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Thirty-two lung cancer patients treated by a VMAT technique were included in the study. For each fraction, the mean time-weighted position of the target was localized by using a 4-dimensional cone-beam CT (4D-CBCT)-based image guidance procedure. The respiratory-correlated location of the gross tumor volume (GTV) during treatment delivery was determined for each fraction by using in-treatment 4D-CBCT images acquired concurrently with VMAT delivery (4D-CBCTin-treat). The GTV was delineated from each of the ten respiratory phase-sorted 4D-CBCTin-treat datasets for each fraction. We defined target coverage as the average percentage of the GTV included within the PTV during the patient's breathing cycle averaged over the treatment course. Target coverage and PTVs were reported for a MidV-based PTV (PTVMidV) using dose-probabilistic margins and three ITV-based PTVs using isotropic margins of 5 mm (PTVITV + 5mm), 4 mm (PTVITV + 4mm) and 3 mm (PTVITV + 3mm). The in-treatment baseline displacements and target motion amplitudes were reported to evaluate the impact of both parameters on target coverage. RESULTS: Overall, 100 4D-CBCTin-treat images were analyzed. The mean target coverage was 98.6, 99.6, 98.9 and 97.2% for PTVMidV, PTVITV + 5mm, PTVITV + 4mm and PTVITV + 3mm, respectively. All the PTV margins led to a target coverage per treatment higher than 95% in at least 90% of the evaluated cases. Compared to PTVITV + 5mm, PTVMidV, PTVITV + 4mm and PTVITV + 3mm had mean PTV reductions of 16, 19 and 33%, respectively. CONCLUSION: When implementing VMAT with 4D-CBCT-based image guidance, an ITV-based approach with a tighter margin than the commonly used 5 mm margin remains an alternative to the MidV-based approach for reducing healthy tissue exposure in lung SBRT. Compared to PTVMidV, PTVITV + 3mm significantly reduced the PTV while still maintaining an adequate in-treatment target coverage.
引用
- Bellec J, Arab-Ceschia F, Castelli J, et al. ITV versus mid-ventilation for treatment planning in lung SBRT: a comparison of target coverage and PTV adequacy by using in-treatment 4D cone beam CT. Radiat Oncol. 2020. PMID: 32127010. doi:10.1186/s13014-020-01496-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。