影像配准与验证工作坊:一项先导研究
本研究为医学与物理住院医师创建了联合影像验证工作坊,包含授课与实操,并在2018和2019年两次开展。首次参与者两项自评能力显著提升,重复参与者评估成像适宜性信心小幅增加但独立核查舒适度下降,提示需重复培训以维持技能。
要点
- 联合影像验证工作坊可提升住院医师首次培训后的自评能力。
- 重复参加者独立核查图像的舒适度反而下降,提示技能需定期强化。
- 两次工作坊后测结果统计等效,课程效果可重复。
核心结论
- 正式跨专业影像验证工作坊对住院医师教育有价值,但需要重复暴露以维持技能。
研究设计与样本
- 针对医学与物理住院医师的联合影像验证工作坊,含授课与实操,2018年9人、2019年7人加2名新住院医师参加,采用前后问卷配对分析。
主要发现
- 首次参与者评估成像方式适宜性自评均值从6.27升至7.27(P=.029),独立核查验证图像自评均值从5.36升至7.18(P=.003)。
- 重复参与者评估成像适宜性信心从7.14升至7.64(P=.038),独立核查图像舒适度从7.29降至6.00(P=.022)。
- 两次工作坊后测结果统计等效(单尾t检验,α=0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 可将跨专业影像验证工作坊纳入住院医师培训,并安排重复培训以维持独立核查技能。
局限性
- 为先导研究,样本量小(2018年9人、2019年7人加2名新住院医师),自评指标为主。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Image guided radiation therapy is essential to ensure complex treatment plans are delivered safely. Residents in radiation oncology have little to no structured training on how to order or evaluate patient setup imaging. We created a joint image verification workshop for medical and physics residents to learn about setup imaging options available, understand information needed to review patient setup, practice image review, and promote interprofessional collaboration during training. The workshop consisted of a didactic session and a hands-on portion for practice with setup images from example patients. Residents completed pre- and postsurveys where each rated their ability on a 10-point scale to (1) assess the appropriateness of an imaging modality for a given treatment and (2) independently check verification images. The workshop was given twice. Nine residents participated in 2018 and 7 again in 2019, along with 2 new residents. Participant scores were paired for analysis. First-time participants had a significant improvement in both areas (1-tailed t test, α = 0.05): meanA:6.27 vs 7.27, P = .029, meanB:5.36 vs 7.18, P = .003. Between workshops (2-tailed t test, α = 0.05), repeat participants had a small increase in self-confidence for assessing the appropriateness of imaging (7.14 vs 7.64, P = .038), whereas comfort with independently checking films decreased (7.29 vs 6.00, P = .022). Postworkshop results (1-tailed t test, α = 0.05) were statistically equivalent for both workshops. A formal interprofessional image verification workshop provides valuable resident education, but repeat exposures are necessary to maintain skills.
引用
- Padilla L, Dault J, Fields E, et al. Image Registration and Verification Workshop: A Pilot Study. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31821897. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2019.12.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。