基于网络众包平台评估肺立体定向放疗计划的变异性和质量
研究通过众包平台收集全球227份早期肺癌SBRT计划(处方11 Gy×5)和轮廓勾画数据,发现计划变异性主要由用户驱动,与计划系统或投照方式无关;许多高质量计划投照时间最短。危及器官轮廓常出现过度或不足勾画,常仅包括管腔空气而忽略黏膜层,强调质量保证和同行评审的重要性。
要点
- 227份肺SBRT计划变异主要由用户驱动,与计划系统、投照方式、总机器跳数或预估束流时间无关。
- 许多最高质量计划投照时间最短,与投照技术无关。
- 危及器官轮廓常过度或不足勾画,常仅包括气管、近端支气管树和食管的管腔空气而忽略黏膜层。
核心结论
- 肺SBRT计划质量变异主要由用户驱动,与计划系统或投照方式无关;轮廓勾画常不准确,凸显质量保证和同行评审的价值。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分计划和轮廓勾画两部分,通过基于网络的技术平台进行;计划部分邀请肺SBRT计划设计者为 centralized stage I 肺癌病例设计、评分并提交计划(处方11 Gy×5),使用标准化图像和预定义轮廓;轮廓勾画部分使用单独图像集,用Dice系数和StructSure评分评估危及器官轮廓准确性。
主要发现
- 共提交227份计划,代表7种不同治疗计划系统和7种不同投照方式。
- 计划变异性主要由用户驱动,与治疗计划系统、投照方式、总机器跳数或预估束流时间无关。
- 许多最高质量计划所需投照时间最短,与投照技术无关。
- 危及器官轮廓常过度或不足勾画,常仅包括气管、近端支气管树和食管的管腔空气,即使黏膜层距靶区肿瘤仅几厘米。
关键数值与推荐
- 计划评分采用20项加权指标,改编自当前招募的III期肺SBRT试验。
- 轮廓准确性使用Dice系数和StructSure评分评估。
临床怎么用
- 应重视肺SBRT计划设计和轮廓勾画的质量保证,通过同行评审和比较改进质量。
- 可借助易获取的质量评估软件解决方案满足日益增长的质量保证需求。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: The quality of stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) treatment plans for early stage lung cancer are unknown outside of peer-reviewed publications. Thus, a study was conducted to crowdsource and analyze a variety of lung SBRT treatment plans from around the world. METHODS AND MATERIALS: This study had 2 parts, planning and contouring, and each was facilitated by a web-based technology platform. For planning, lung SBRT planners were invited to design, score, and submit their treatment plans (prescription of 11 Gy × 5) for a centralized stage I lung cancer case using standardized images and predefined contours. Each plan was scored with 20 weighted metrics adapted from currently recruiting phase 3 lung SBRT trials. For contouring, a separate image set was used to evaluate organ-at-risk contour accuracy using Dice coefficients and a StructSure score. RESULTS: For planning 227 plans were submitted in total with 7 different treatment planning systems and 7 different delivery methods represented. Variability was primarily user driven and not associated with the treatment planning system, delivery modality, total monitor units, or estimated beam-on time. Many of the highest-quality plans required the shortest amount of time to deliver, independent of the delivery technique. For contouring, organ-at-risk contours were frequently over- or undercontoured and often included only the luminal air of the trachea, proximal bronchial tree, and esophagus, even when the mucosal linings were within a few centimeters of the target tumor. CONCLUSIONS: These findings demonstrate the importance of quality assurance to help improve planning and contouring and the value of peer review and comparison. More readily accessible quality evaluation software solutions, such as the one used herein, may help meet this growing need.
引用
- Moghanaki D, Slotman B, Swaminath A, et al. Assessing the Variability and Quality of Lung Stereotactic Radiation Therapy Treatment Plans Using a Web-Based Crowdsourcing Platform. Pract Radiat Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31837477. doi:10.1016/j.prro.2019.12.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。